This place is a gem on the upper east side. Incredible pizza & chicken rolls. You must try!!
Sheldon McMeekan
Found our first Rude New Yorkers after being in town for two days. Customer service definitely not at the top of the list here.
Gary Wilson
Overpriced at $3.50.Medium thickness crust with good flavor.In fact that's the only thing with flavor.No Italian seasoning flavor whatsoever.In fact, no seasoning detectable at all.Too much crust.Basically a slice of grilled cheese with some red stuff.
Matthew Weitzman
I thought they had closed, sure enough just relocated down the block. Their pizza was amazing years ago and slowly went downhill. I’ve decided to give the new place a try. Probably one of the best plain pies in the neighborhood. Ask for it well done, hot sauce on the side.
Gerry Pion
Pizza is really good, but the place is small, don't expect to dine in or with several people.
Dale Allen
These guys are riding the name of the original John & Tony's that was located just South of this store and actually, the awning is still up on the corner of 60th&1st where the original restaraunt used to be. I used to order from there all the time back in the day. I happened to be in the area and when i ordered, i asked if this was the same restaurant and they told me it was even though it wasn't.Heroes were ok, not great like the original John & Tony's.
Tony Giannini & Mark Lewis
Delicious. Crispy crust and spicy sausage.
Matt V
Pizza is starting to go down… on the personal pie, half the slices is half crust even when ordering extra cheese… kinda disappointed
Randy Rocha
Great pizzeria and it was open late as I was coming home from work. Pepperoni slice is happening! ?
Jennifer L.
OMG! Just awful pizza!!!! I've lived in this neighborhood for 20+ years and thought I'd give John & Tony another try (haven't been here since pre-Covid) Just now, I ordered 2 slices of the Margarita (fresh mozzarella and basil.) It was THE absolute worst pizza I've eaten in recent memory!!!! I threw it in the garbage it was just SO awful! It cost me $9.00 - had I known that it would have ended up in the garbage - instead, I would have gladly spent $20.00 for a small Margarita pie at Patsy's Pizzeria nearby!!!! I will NEVER go back to John & Tony's!!!! Save your money, everyone!!!!
Great Pizza and the staff is very friendly. This place is very close to my apartment and come here frequently. Highly recommend
Deniz K.
Solid slice of pizza! I was just craving a slide of pizza on the way home from work so I walked in and ordered a Margareta pizza and Buffalo Chicken. They were able to reheat my slices very quickly and I was in and out in probably 5 minutes! They have a great thin crust that isn't soggy on the bottom. This won't be your artisanal pizza but it's a great quick pick up!
Fred Frederix
Yummy and open all night!
Sadri B.
a narrow tiny spaced pizza joint on 60th and 1st ave that has a really extensive menu besides pizza like calzones , rolls , sandwiches , plenty of apps including mozz sticks, wings, knots, garlic bread ,salads, soups, plenty of entrees and pasta dishes which include the norms like chicken parm, lasagna and so on . i always like to keep it simple with 2 cheese slices and bottle of diet coke but wow for a tiny pizza joint they sure have plenty of in and out with bike deliverys. overall pizza is good , nice size , chewy crunchy crust and not oily at all. should have grab a few chocolate chips cookies for the go but i already stuffed my mouth with 2 large slices . open on weekends till 4 and 5am so the drunks can grab a bite after getting blasted at the many bars and pubs in the area.
rich f.
When I used to live on the east side John and Tony's was my go to chicken parm place. Now years later I'm back in the neighborhood and even though they moved they still make the best chicken parm dinner. Even though I'm 12 blocks away the food came fast, hot and as good as I remember it too be.
This place is a gem on the upper east side. Incredible pizza & chicken rolls. You must try!!
Found our first Rude New Yorkers after being in town for two days. Customer service definitely not at the top of the list here.
Overpriced at $3.50.Medium thickness crust with good flavor.In fact that's the only thing with flavor.No Italian seasoning flavor whatsoever.In fact, no seasoning detectable at all.Too much crust.Basically a slice of grilled cheese with some red stuff.
I thought they had closed, sure enough just relocated down the block. Their pizza was amazing years ago and slowly went downhill. I’ve decided to give the new place a try. Probably one of the best plain pies in the neighborhood. Ask for it well done, hot sauce on the side.
Pizza is really good, but the place is small, don't expect to dine in or with several people.
These guys are riding the name of the original John & Tony's that was located just South of this store and actually, the awning is still up on the corner of 60th&1st where the original restaraunt used to be. I used to order from there all the time back in the day. I happened to be in the area and when i ordered, i asked if this was the same restaurant and they told me it was even though it wasn't.Heroes were ok, not great like the original John & Tony's.
Delicious. Crispy crust and spicy sausage.
Pizza is starting to go down… on the personal pie, half the slices is half crust even when ordering extra cheese… kinda disappointed
Great pizzeria and it was open late as I was coming home from work. Pepperoni slice is happening! ?
OMG! Just awful pizza!!!! I've lived in this neighborhood for 20+ years and thought I'd give John & Tony another try (haven't been here since pre-Covid) Just now, I ordered 2 slices of the Margarita (fresh mozzarella and basil.) It was THE absolute worst pizza I've eaten in recent memory!!!! I threw it in the garbage it was just SO awful! It cost me $9.00 - had I known that it would have ended up in the garbage - instead, I would have gladly spent $20.00 for a small Margarita pie at Patsy's Pizzeria nearby!!!! I will NEVER go back to John & Tony's!!!! Save your money, everyone!!!!
Restaurantji Recommends
Great Pizza and the staff is very friendly. This place is very close to my apartment and come here frequently. Highly recommend
Solid slice of pizza! I was just craving a slide of pizza on the way home from work so I walked in and ordered a Margareta pizza and Buffalo Chicken. They were able to reheat my slices very quickly and I was in and out in probably 5 minutes! They have a great thin crust that isn't soggy on the bottom. This won't be your artisanal pizza but it's a great quick pick up!
Yummy and open all night!
a narrow tiny spaced pizza joint on 60th and 1st ave that has a really extensive menu besides pizza like calzones , rolls , sandwiches , plenty of apps including mozz sticks, wings, knots, garlic bread ,salads, soups, plenty of entrees and pasta dishes which include the norms like chicken parm, lasagna and so on . i always like to keep it simple with 2 cheese slices and bottle of diet coke but wow for a tiny pizza joint they sure have plenty of in and out with bike deliverys. overall pizza is good , nice size , chewy crunchy crust and not oily at all. should have grab a few chocolate chips cookies for the go but i already stuffed my mouth with 2 large slices . open on weekends till 4 and 5am so the drunks can grab a bite after getting blasted at the many bars and pubs in the area.
When I used to live on the east side John and Tony's was my go to chicken parm place. Now years later I'm back in the neighborhood and even though they moved they still make the best chicken parm dinner. Even though I'm 12 blocks away the food came fast, hot and as good as I remember it too be.