Very tasty slice of pizza. Currently running a special where you get two generous slices and a fountain drink for $9.
Harrison Gerson
Pizza was decent but I was overcharged on the slice. First, there was a card fee that was not shown anywhere before payment. So then, when I paid in cash, I was given back less change than I was supposed to get. Server wasn't kind about it; didn't want to deal with me.
Sawwal Qayyum
Great slices, make sure to grab a drink as well
Sael Marie Fuentes
Pizza here is one of the best in the UES. We commute from the Bronx for the Margherita slice. Food is always fresh, staff is friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margarita Pizza, Chicken Bacon Ranch, White Spinach Pizza, Cheese Pizza Pie
Christopher Craig
Plain slice was as good as it gets for by the slice pizza not counting pizza restaurants that only sell whole pies But don't know if taste will change if NYC removes brominated flour from bakers
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza Slice
Amy
The chicken parm hero was made fresh - they toasted the bun and chicken/sauce/cheese separately and it was assembled together in front of me - delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Beautiful, Blessed \u0026 Highly Favored
I had a terrible experience at this location. I ordered a whole one topping pizza. I requested that half of the pizza have ham and the other half I wanted pepperoni.
They proceeded to put ham and pepperoni on the entire pizza. When I said that wasn’t what I wanted-I was attacked.
The cashier was rude when taking my payment. I asked for a manager and the manager stated he was also the owner. He proceeded to disrespect me in front of my son.
I finally requested a refund and he gave me cash minus a surcharge fee. I initially paid with my card so I returned the cash and asked for my entire refund via my card.
I will not return to any Little Italy Pizzeria. I am not sure why the men argued with me or felt the need to disrespect me. But I won’t return and I will advise everyone I know to not spend money at Little Italy establishments.
I had previously wrote a raving review about a different location. But I won’t support a business that disrespects black women. I will spend my money elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Daniel Medina
Great flavor and cooked to perfection, had to come back because I couldn't stop thinking about the great taste of the pizza
badro kik
“The price was too high for the quality. The pizza tasted old and bland, and the service was not good either. Very disappointing overall
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Christa
The chicken caesar salad slice might have been one of the best slices I’ve ever consumed. TRUST
Have not tried their pizza but have tried their garlic knots and spinach rolls. They are disgusting. The dough was still raw, it had no flavor and just tasted horrible. Idk who’s in charge of the garlic knots and rolls but something needs to change. There are 4-5 other pizza spots within a 2 minute walk. Go anywhere but here.
Ian Lafferty
Loved it here. Pizza is good, good selection, and service was kind.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Starr O’Hal
Little Italy Pizza is one of my absolute favorite spots every time I’m in Midtown NYC. Consistently delicious slices, fast service, and exactly the kind of classic NYC pizza you crave when you’re in the city.
Always a must-stop for me — reliable, satisfying, and so good every single time. 🍕🗽
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ricardo Devilee
This restaurant is not capable to adjust to the needs of the customer. If you are allergic for cheese they just say, you can go somewhere else. Very weak. Dissapointing.
Yoel Saldana flores
The pizza was great and the service was smooth. The place was clean tables n all
Very tasty slice of pizza. Currently running a special where you get two generous slices and a fountain drink for $9.
Pizza was decent but I was overcharged on the slice. First, there was a card fee that was not shown anywhere before payment. So then, when I paid in cash, I was given back less change than I was supposed to get. Server wasn't kind about it; didn't want to deal with me.
Great slices, make sure to grab a drink as well
Pizza here is one of the best in the UES. We commute from the Bronx for the Margherita slice. Food is always fresh, staff is friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margarita Pizza, Chicken Bacon Ranch, White Spinach Pizza, Cheese Pizza Pie
Plain slice was as good as it gets for by the slice pizza not counting pizza restaurants that only sell whole pies
But don't know if taste will change if NYC removes brominated flour from bakers
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza Slice
The chicken parm hero was made fresh - they toasted the bun and chicken/sauce/cheese separately and it was assembled together in front of me - delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I had a terrible experience at this location. I ordered a whole one topping pizza. I requested that half of the pizza have ham and the other half I wanted pepperoni.
They proceeded to put ham and pepperoni on the entire pizza. When I said that wasn’t what I wanted-I was attacked.
The cashier was rude when taking my payment. I asked for a manager and the manager stated he was also the owner. He proceeded to disrespect me in front of my son.
I finally requested a refund and he gave me cash minus a surcharge fee. I initially paid with my card so I returned the cash and asked for my entire refund via my card.
I will not return to any Little Italy Pizzeria. I am not sure why the men argued with me or felt the need to disrespect me. But I won’t return and I will advise everyone I know to not spend money at Little Italy establishments.
I had previously wrote a raving review about a different location. But I won’t support a business that disrespects black women. I will spend my money elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Great flavor and cooked to perfection, had to come back because I couldn't stop thinking about the great taste of the pizza
“The price was too high for the quality. The pizza tasted old and bland, and the service was not good either. Very disappointing overall
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
The chicken caesar salad slice might have been one of the best slices I’ve ever consumed. TRUST
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Have not tried their pizza but have tried their garlic knots and spinach rolls. They are disgusting. The dough was still raw, it had no flavor and just tasted horrible. Idk who’s in charge of the garlic knots and rolls but something needs to change. There are 4-5 other pizza spots within a 2 minute walk. Go anywhere but here.
Loved it here. Pizza is good, good selection, and service was kind.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Little Italy Pizza is one of my absolute favorite spots every time I’m in Midtown NYC. Consistently delicious slices, fast service, and exactly the kind of classic NYC pizza you crave when you’re in the city.
Always a must-stop for me — reliable, satisfying, and so good every single time. 🍕🗽
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This restaurant is not capable to adjust to the needs of the customer.
If you are allergic for cheese they just say, you can go somewhere else. Very weak. Dissapointing.
The pizza was great and the service was smooth. The place was clean tables n all
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...