Luke's Lobster Upper West Side

426 Amsterdam Ave, New York
(212) 877-8800

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Lobster Roll Flight
Lobster Roll Combo
랍스터ロール
Truffle Butter
Lobster Bisque
Lobster Rolls
Shrimp Roll
Luke's Trio
Crab Roll
Chowder

Menu

Featured items
Lobster Bisque
Hearty chunks of wild-caught lobster claw meat in a smooth, cream-based soup made with lobster. Made in small batches by Hurricane's Soups in Greene, Maine. GF
Clam Chowder
Chock full of sustainably caught Atlantic surf clams, potatoes, and onions. Award-winning and made in small batches by Hurricane's Soups in Greene, Maine. GF
Soup + Drink Combo
Make your roll a combo and save $2 when you add on a soup and drink!
Lobster Mac
Pasta in a mascarpone-cheddar blend with chunks of wild-caught lobster, topped with garlic herb breadcrumbs.
By The Pound
Order our seafood by the half-pound to liven up your at-home recipes!
Kids Grilled Cheese
Buttered and toasted organic white bread with melted cheddar cheese.

ROLL COMBOS
Soup + Drink Combo
Make your roll a combo and save $2 when you add on a soup and drink!
Side + Drink Combo
Make your roll a combo and save $2 when you add on a side and drink!
Lobster Mac + Cheese & Drink Combo
Lobster Mac + Cheese & Drink Combo

ROLLS
Lobster Roll
Our claim to fame! 4oz or 6oz of chilled, wild-caught lobster in a toasted, buttered bun with mayo, lemon butter, and Luke's Secret Seasoning. Served with kettle chips.
Luke's Trio
Our seafood sampler! 2oz lobster roll, 2oz crab roll, and 2 oz shrimp roll served on a toasted, buttered half buns with mayo, lemon butter, and Luke's Secret Seasoning. Served with kettle chips.
Lobster Roll Flight
Three fun flavors, touching down for a limited time only! 2 oz lemon butter roll, 2 oz spicy honey butter roll, and 2 oz truffle butter roll served on half buns. Served with kettle chips.
Crab Roll
4oz or 6oz of chilled, wild-caught Jonah crab in a toasted, buttered bun with mayo, lemon butter, and Luke's Secret Seasoning. Served with kettle chips.
Dungeness Crab Roll
4oz or 6oz of chilled Dungeness crab in a toasted, buttered bun with mayo, lemon butter, and Luke's Secret Seasoning. Served with kettle chips.
White Truffle Roll
Our most decadent roll yet! 4oz or 6oz of chilled, wild-caught lobster crab or shrimp in a toasted, buttered bun with mayo and topped with melted Urbani white truffle butter. Served with kettle chips.
Shrimp Roll
4oz or 6oz of chilled, wild-caught North Atlantic shrimp in a toasted, buttered bun with mayo, lemon butter, and Luke's Secret Seasoning. Served with kettle chips.
Spicy Honey Butter Rolls
Melted Mike's Hot Honey - Extra Hot butter and silken chili.
Dungeness Trio
2oz lobster roll, 2oz Dungeness crab roll, and 2 oz shrimp roll served on a toasted, buttered half buns with mayo, lemon butter, and Luke's Secret Seasoning. Served with kettle chips.
Dungeness Crab Roll - 4 oz.
Dungeness Crab Roll - 4 oz.

SOUPS & SIDES
Lobster Bisque
Hearty chunks of wild-caught lobster claw meat in a smooth, cream-based soup made with lobster. Made in small batches by Hurricane's Soups in Greene, Maine. GF
Clam Chowder
Chock full of sustainably caught Atlantic surf clams, potatoes, and onions. Award-winning and made in small batches by Hurricane's Soups in Greene, Maine. GF
Lobster Mac
Pasta in a mascarpone-cheddar blend with chunks of wild-caught lobster, topped with garlic herb breadcrumbs.
Poppyseed Slaw
Not your average slaw! Shredded cabbage blend with our very own Luke's Poppyseed Vinaigrette Dressing for a light, refreshing side dish.
Chips
A bag of kettle chips
Whoopie Pie
Whoopie Pie
Grilled Cheese
Grilled Cheese
Lemon Butter
Lemon Butter
Truffle Butter
Truffle Butter
Spicy Honey Butter
Spicy Honey Butter
Pickle
Pickle
Luke's Seasoning Packet
Seasoning Packet
Bun
Bun
Gluten Friendly Bun
Gluten-Friendly Bun

FAMILY & GROCERY
By The Pound
Order our seafood by the half-pound to liven up your at-home recipes!

DRINKS
Blueberry Lemonade
A Luke's Lobster exclusive! 12oz bottle of Green Bee Blueberry Lemonade.
Diet Coke
12oz of Diet Coke.
Coke
12oz of Coca-Cola.
Root Beer
12oz of Maine Root Root Beer. Sweetened with real cane sugar.
Ginger Brew
12oz of spicy ginger soda.
Blueberry Soda
12oz of blueberry soda.
Bottled Water
12oz of bottled water.
Sparkling Water
12oz of sparkling water.
Apple Juice Box
All natural apple juice with no added sugar.

KIDS
Kids Seafood Roll
A seafood roll just for kids! A 2oz portion of either lobster, crab, or shrimp served in a toasted, buttered bun with mayo, lemon butter, and Luke's Secret Seasoning.
Kids Grilled Cheese
Buttered and toasted organic white bread with melted cheddar cheese.
Apple Juice Box
All natural apple juice with no added sugar.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: foursquare
Photo credit: foursquare
+44 photos
Photo credit: foursquare
+43 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Food is great. Service was meh. Ordered for two. Ate. Was great

Still hungry. We ordered again. Realized there’s a card. So two orders and $100 later, said only one punch per visit.
June 2025
Luke's lobster is known for the lobster dishes, as the lobster rolls but I went there looking for a clam chowder (New England style) and wasn't disappointed. Creamy and tasty. I missed a touch of bacon, but I guess this is not on the traditional recipe.
And next time I should definitely go for the lobster roll.
It's a small and cozy place. You can dine in or take away.
March 2025
the only staff member was very friendly and made a well seasoned lobster roll. she volunteered info and told me about the included cucumber

chill, rustic seaside vibe

can't wait to come back to try the other rolls :)
March 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Two Wheels Vietnamese - 426 Amsterdam Ave
Vietnamese, Vegan
Crave Fishbar - 428 Amsterdam Ave
Seafood, Bar, Pet Friendly, Vegan
Caledonia Bar - 424 Amsterdam Ave
Bar & Grill, Whiskey Bar, Bar

Luke's Lobster Upper West Side

426 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024
(212) 877-8800