Madison Fare

1225 Madison Ave, New York
(917) 261-4662

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Tracey Maher

Madison Fare: A Gourmet Marketplace That Delights Every Sense

Whenever I’m in NYC I always go to my favorite store Madison Fare. I can’t say enough good things about this vibrant culinary haven. Owned and lovingly curated by Amin Kinana. This gourmet marketplace is a treasure trove of prepared foods, artfully assembled gift baskets, and, believe it or not, some of the most delightful frozen yogurt I’ve ever tasted. All the prepared food is delicious and made by Amin himself who in a previous life was a gourmet chef.

From the moment I step inside, I am greeted by an inviting, warm atmosphere that truly captures the eclectic energy of New York City. The store’s offerings are as diverse as they are delectable…whether you’re craving a hearty, chef-inspired prepared meal, looking for the perfect gift basket to celebrate a special occasion, or just in need of a refreshing scoop of frozen yogurt, Madison Fare delivers with flair.

What really sets Madison Fare apart is Amin’s passion and personal touch. His commitment to quality shines through in every product, and you can tell that each item is selected with care. Amin isn’t just running a store; he’s curating an experience, one that celebrates the art of food and the joy of sharing it with others.

If you’re in NYC and in search of a gourmet experience that goes beyond the ordinary, make sure to stop by Madison Fare. It’s more than just a marketplace, it’s a celebration of flavor, community, and the simple pleasure of good food. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this is one culinary destination you won’t want to miss. You can also order online if you don’t have time to go the store and want the perfect gift or snack.

Hanan Jamal

Great yogurt, good quality ingredients and toppings. Thought this could be overhyped on social media but its actually delicious.... especially the kataifi and pistachio toppings.

Sarah Leite Gavioli

The frozen yogurt here is absolutely delicious — the best I’ve ever had! It has the perfect balance of flavor: slightly tart, not overly sweet, and incredibly creamy. I especially loved the pistachio flavor, but honestly, all the toppings looked amazing. Definitely a treat worth giving yourself!

Ragıp KADEMOĞLU

The best

Taina O

9. Dollars for a greek frozen yougurt with just syrup. They have other flavors but you can't try it. I never heard about that.

Traveling Doggie (littledoggietravels)

Really great froyo and the sauces were really fresh. Definitely worth a stop if you’re in the neighborhood.

Amanda Chong

Better than culture

Daniel Eneric

Really great froyo, and even better service

Aryella Almeida

Great Greek frozen yogurt!! Delicious!!

Zara Su

Love the food and customer service!

Stephan Herard

The frozen yogurt was really great actually. The line isnt fun but if its not too long the pistachio option is good

CrAzY egg tart

Love love love!

Chloe Tero

The portions are very generous and the person working there is also very nice

Leslie Saliba Nasr

Loved discovering this place and meeting Amin who is kind and welcoming.

Lovonne Brown

Loveee Greek yogurt and love this little gem! Besides the yogurt ….there are cute little worldwide, inexpensive delicacies you didn’t think you needed …. Like sardines! Haha Cute spot

Loading...