I always select this location for my order pickup. It's quick, the service is great and always organized.
Saira A
So do they not label the container ? The lady who was the cashier pointed to the fridge after I paid for two large banana puddings and they all looked the same and when I got home and opened them and they both not banana but blueberry. So just a heads up everyone.
Jacklinda Arma
Absolutely the best !
Jim Lyons
Good, fresh and tasty baked goods. Banana pudding is always a hit. Tried a new side version. But the classic will always be top rated. Also had a piece of hummingbird cake which was excellent and should not be missed. Standard line, a bit of a smile at the greeting but the register people couldn’t care less and just want to move you out of the store quickly.
Uno Songalia
Love their banana bread pudding thing and the service is really fast
Giovanni Correa-Quinones
Yes. Get the banana pudding. It’s so fluffy and delicious. It has that chilliness but not too cold, just the right amount to know that it’s so smooth and light. The banana is not too sweet nor too tough, just blends in with the rest of the pudding. I also got the red velvet cupcake and it was delicious! Staff was friendly and it was busy but it moves quick everything.
romina sattari
For the second time now this specific branch’s banana pudding is nearly inedible with zero flavor, not sweet at all and has no taste of banana whatsoever. It tastes like milk and cake with a few bananas in it. The sad part is that the other branches have the same product with AMAZING taste and this branch consistently does not know how to make the banana pudding. I’ve had this dessert for 5 years now and this is the only place where I take a bite and throw it out. Waste of money just to go another branch
Anne
The cheesecake was just as delicious as I remembered from my last visit to New York!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 5
jeffrey navarro
Best banana pudding in the world!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Banana Pudding
Elena Pierce
Picked up what I thought was a classic banana pudding, but it looks just like some mashed leftover cake. Taste is not good. Misleading labeling. Money wasted.
The banana pudding is always a must! The place is very small, made for take-out only. The food is delicious and worth it!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Bolo Veludo Vermelho
Aurora Ayuso
Mythical NY bakery, you definitely have to try their famous cupcakes and banana pudding. It didn't disappoint and we liked it a lot.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Serena Bini
You pass by Magnolia Bakery around 11, don't you want to stop and get a cup cake🧁? Let's say I don't regret the stop, but I wouldn't go there on purpose.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 3
sebahat kurutaş
I stopped by Magnolia Bakery because, of course, Sex and the City made it a must-see. I grabbed a red velvet and vanilla cupcake to-go, and it was such a fun experience, especially since I could totally connect it to the show. The cupcakes were delicious! I’m already planning my next visit to try the banana pudding and cheesecakes!
I always select this location for my order pickup. It's quick, the service is great and always organized.
So do they not label the container ? The lady who was the cashier pointed to the fridge after I paid for two large banana puddings and they all looked the same and when I got home and opened them and they both not banana but blueberry. So just a heads up everyone.
Absolutely the best !
Good, fresh and tasty baked goods. Banana pudding is always a hit. Tried a new side version. But the classic will always be top rated. Also had a piece of hummingbird cake which was excellent and should not be missed. Standard line, a bit of a smile at the greeting but the register people couldn’t care less and just want to move you out of the store quickly.
Love their banana bread pudding thing and the service is really fast
Yes. Get the banana pudding. It’s so fluffy and delicious. It has that chilliness but not too cold, just the right amount to know that it’s so smooth and light. The banana is not too sweet nor too tough, just blends in with the rest of the pudding. I also got the red velvet cupcake and it was delicious! Staff was friendly and it was busy but it moves quick everything.
For the second time now this specific branch’s banana pudding is nearly inedible with zero flavor, not sweet at all and has no taste of banana whatsoever. It tastes like milk and cake with a few bananas in it. The sad part is that the other branches have the same product with AMAZING taste and this branch consistently does not know how to make the banana pudding. I’ve had this dessert for 5 years now and this is the only place where I take a bite and throw it out. Waste of money just to go another branch
The cheesecake was just as delicious as I remembered from my last visit to New York!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best banana pudding in the world!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Banana Pudding
Picked up what I thought was a classic banana pudding, but it looks just like some mashed leftover cake. Taste is not good. Misleading labeling. Money wasted.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
The banana pudding is always a must! The place is very small, made for take-out only. The food is delicious and worth it!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Bolo Veludo Vermelho
Mythical NY bakery, you definitely have to try their famous cupcakes and banana pudding. It didn't disappoint and we liked it a lot.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
You pass by Magnolia Bakery around 11, don't you want to stop and get a cup cake🧁? Let's say I don't regret the stop, but I wouldn't go there on purpose.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 3
I stopped by Magnolia Bakery because, of course, Sex and the City made it a must-see. I grabbed a red velvet and vanilla cupcake to-go, and it was such a fun experience, especially since I could totally connect it to the show. The cupcakes were delicious! I’m already planning my next visit to try the banana pudding and cheesecakes!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good but not worth the hype
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Banana Pudding, Vanilla Cheesecake
Loading...