Make My Fish

120 W 116th St, New York
(917) 388-3138

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Fried Shrimp Platter with Collard Greens & Macaroni and Cheese
Fried Whiting Fish Sandwich
Fish and Shrimp Dinner
Whiting Fish Dinner
Catfish and Chips
Catfish Sandwich
Fish and Chips
Catfish Dinner
Mac and Cheese
Fish and Grits

Menu

Picked for you
Shrimp and Fish Combo
Includes fries.
Fish and Chips
Four pieces.
All Shrimp
All Fish
Six pieces.
Fish Dinner
Four pieces. Includes two sides.

Bundles
Shrimp and Fish Combo Bundle
Includes fries. Served with your choice of Coca-Cola product.
Shrimp and Chips
Served with your choice of Coca-Cola product.
All Shrimp Bundle
Served with your choice of Coca-Cola product.

Side Orders
Macaroni and Cheese
Collard Greens
Candied Yams
French Fries
Grits
Cole Slaw

Whiting Fish Fillet
Fish and Chips
Four pieces.
All Fish
Six pieces.
Fish Dinner
Four pieces. Includes two sides.
Fish Sandwich
four pieces.
Fish & Shrimp Dinner
Fish and Shrimp Combo
Includes fries.
Fish and Grits

Catfish Fillet
Catfish & Shrimp Dinner
Catfish and Shrimp Combo
Includes fries.
All Catfish
Four pieces.
Triple Play
Two catfish, four whiting, seven jumbo shrimps, and fries.
Catfish Sandwich
Three pieces.
Catfish and Chips
Three pieces.
Catfish and Grits
Three pieces.

Shrimp Jumbo
Shrimp and Fish Combo
Includes fries.
Shrimp and Chips
All Shrimp
Shrimp Dinner
Includes two sides.
Prime Time Shrimp
Shrimp and Grits

Beverages
Half and Half
Can Sodas
Fruit Punch
Lemonade
Bottled Water
Ice Tea

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: tripadvisor
Photo credit: google
+7 photos
Photo credit: foursquare
+6 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

food was really good! even when it was cold, the fish still had a little crispness to it. my only concern was the amount of oil that the fish gets cooked in, i had heart burn the next morning.
March 2025
One good thing I can say about this place is that they have good customer service. the owner was flirting with me. I'm not sure if that's a good thing or a bad thing however I would not eat the food. It's way too greasy. The potato salad taste like Karen made it. The collard greens taste like a bowl of heartburn (my heart burn people get my point). The sweet potatoes taste like the red flavor of Kool-Aid with extra sugar.

Please don't let...
March 2025
Been coming to Make my Fish for quite sometime and love thier fish and all the seafood but I would be wrong to not address the elephant in the room.
They customer service when placing your order has got to Get BETTER and Quickly!!
No matter who they have working it’s always an attitude- frown on a stone face get mad when you want your food a certain way / like crispy fish or smaller chicken wings.
Don’t make no sense you MAD and I just got there...
March 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Le Baobab Gouygui - 120 W 116th St
Senegalese, West African, African
Jumbo Hamburgers - 112 W 116th St
Hamburger, Burgers, Vegetarian
Keur Coumba - 125 W 116th St
Senegalese, West African

Make My Fish

120 W 116th St, New York, NY 10026
(917) 388-3138