The posh makeover is nice but I liked the restaurant the way it was before. I was actually devastated they got a new chef because he was beyond skilled and everything was delectable. The food was better when it was Italian, . Now; the drinks are what I come here for; they are AMAZING!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Paul Margiotta
Reviews are stale! Grand reopening 3 weeks ago is a grand success. Chef F. is spectacular! Server Saxon is the man!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pasang Sherpa
This is my favourite spot in West Village. The food is always delicious, service is always top notch and the ambience is always warm and welcoming. The lobby is stunning, adding to the overall charm of the place. A must-visit!
We had a great experience dining here, starting with the warm and inviting atmosphere. The restaurant is beautifully designed, creating a comfortable yet chic setting that's perfect for a relaxing meal.
Our server, Gustavo, was fantastic—attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable. He made sure we had everything we needed and offered great recommendations that really enhanced our meal.
The food was delicious, with fresh ingredients and thoughtful presentation. Every dish we tried was flavorful and satisfying, making it a memorable dining experience.
Overall, Margaux is a solid choice for anyone looking for a great meal in the city, with excellent service to match. We’ll definitely be back!
Well..this was one those not too great experiences but then someone saves the day kind of thing?? Came in here just because of how cozy it looks from outside. Walked in, server sees me by the podium and walks away. I wanted to really try the place so I chased after him and asked to be seated. He looked bothered, but got a better attitude a bit later. I get it: We all have bad days and dealing with the public is a pain! But then he went MIA. Gustavo, the bus boy/waiter saved the day. He took care of me and was on top of service one. A new waiter came in and was friendly though. The pros: beautiful space...the cons: innatentive service, average food, and unimpressive cocktails (Not everyone knows how to incorporate mezcal into a cocktail without overwhelming). Wanted to love this place, but can't recommend in good faith..
John Ng
The burger was excellent, fries was krispy and well seasoned . The service was fast and friendly.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pulled Pork
JS
Great place
Rae Cassidy
Honestly, we had a great experience. Food was a bit greasy but otherwise delicious. Incredible atmosphere and good service.
Matt Fallon
Horrific service. Good food, drinks and ambiance, but a >3 hour dinner because of just Abysmal service.
L B (Loz)
I’ve always liked the cozy setting. Their hours are great being available for late lunches etc. the fact I was ravenous didn’t help the rigatoni dish, although delish was v small for $19. My glass of wine was more than the small food. Service was practically non-existent. 20years living in NYC I’ve never said that. Left unattended for over 20 minutes. No sign of server, follow up menu/course etc. bizarre.
Literally the worst place I’ve been in nyc. The revive was literally insulting just dropped the plates onto the table and threw the check onto the table without even acknowledging us. Seriously shocking. The veggie burger sucked and the cheese bird was insulting the assortment of jams was basically non existent, wanted to like this place so badly it’s sad.
Sasha Lazard
I came for dinner with a friend at 6:30pm last night (Nov 17) The place was empty. I asked to host if we could sit on a booth, he said were for larger parties. We sat at a small table for an hour. The host/ waiter never came back to take our order, and no one ever came to sit in any of the booths. The host took an order from a woman who came in after us. We were punished for requesting a booth in a near empty restaurant. We left and went down the street for Loring Place where were were greeted warmly, and had the most delicious dinner. Margaux has a nice atmosphere, decent food- but the service has always been bad, and last night it was appalling.
Brandon Brown
Absolutely incredible and tragically underrated. I have never had anything short of a great meal here. The pasta is made fresh-in house daily. Highly recommend for locals in the know and Marlton Hotel guests alike.
Matthew Lysne
Had a very nice dinner experience with a couple of old friends! Server was quiet, with just the right amount of attention, but not too much. Good food and a nice atmosphere. I’ll be back.
Yerra Sugarman
The worst service I have ever had anywhere. The food was bland as well. I told the hostess that the service was poor and she said “okay,” not even apologizing. Terrible place.
The posh makeover is nice but I liked the restaurant the way it was before. I was actually devastated they got a new chef because he was beyond skilled and everything was delectable. The food was better when it was Italian, . Now; the drinks are what I come here for; they are AMAZING!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Reviews are stale! Grand reopening 3 weeks ago is a grand success. Chef F. is spectacular! Server Saxon is the man!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is my favourite spot in West Village. The food is always delicious, service is always top notch and the ambience is always warm and welcoming. The lobby is stunning, adding to the overall charm of the place. A must-visit!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Burger, Salmon Tartare, Burrata, Rotisserie Amish Chicken
We had a great experience dining here, starting with the warm and inviting atmosphere. The restaurant is beautifully designed, creating a comfortable yet chic setting that's perfect for a relaxing meal.
Our server, Gustavo, was fantastic—attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable. He made sure we had everything we needed and offered great recommendations that really enhanced our meal.
The food was delicious, with fresh ingredients and thoughtful presentation. Every dish we tried was flavorful and satisfying, making it a memorable dining experience.
Overall, Margaux is a solid choice for anyone looking for a great meal in the city, with excellent service to match. We’ll definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mezzi Rigatoni, Spaghetti Pomodoro, House-Made Shoestring Fries
Well..this was one those not too great experiences but then someone saves the day kind of thing?? Came in here just because of how cozy it looks from outside. Walked in, server sees me by the podium and walks away. I wanted to really try the place so I chased after him and asked to be seated. He looked bothered, but got a better attitude a bit later. I get it: We all have bad days and dealing with the public is a pain! But then he went MIA. Gustavo, the bus boy/waiter saved the day. He took care of me and was on top of service one. A new waiter came in and was friendly though. The pros: beautiful space...the cons: innatentive service, average food, and unimpressive cocktails (Not everyone knows how to incorporate mezcal into a cocktail without overwhelming). Wanted to love this place, but can't recommend in good faith..
The burger was excellent, fries was krispy and well seasoned . The service was fast and friendly.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pulled Pork
Great place
Honestly, we had a great experience. Food was a bit greasy but otherwise delicious. Incredible atmosphere and good service.
Horrific service. Good food, drinks and ambiance, but a >3 hour dinner because of just Abysmal service.
I’ve always liked the cozy setting. Their hours are great being available for late lunches etc. the fact I was ravenous didn’t help the rigatoni dish, although delish was v small for $19. My glass of wine was more than the small food. Service was practically non-existent. 20years living in NYC I’ve never said that. Left unattended for over 20 minutes. No sign of server, follow up menu/course etc. bizarre.
Restaurantji Recommends
Literally the worst place I’ve been in nyc. The revive was literally insulting just dropped the plates onto the table and threw the check onto the table without even acknowledging us. Seriously shocking. The veggie burger sucked and the cheese bird was insulting the assortment of jams was basically non existent, wanted to like this place so badly it’s sad.
I came for dinner with a friend at 6:30pm last night (Nov 17)
The place was empty. I asked to host if we could sit on a booth, he said were for larger parties. We sat at a small table for an hour. The host/ waiter never came back to take our order, and no one ever came to sit in any of the booths. The host took an order from a woman who came in after us. We were punished for requesting a booth in a near empty restaurant. We left and went down the street for Loring Place where were were greeted warmly, and had the most delicious dinner. Margaux has a nice atmosphere, decent food- but the service has always been bad, and last night it was appalling.
Absolutely incredible and tragically underrated. I have never had anything short of a great meal here. The pasta is made fresh-in house daily. Highly recommend for locals in the know and Marlton Hotel guests alike.
Had a very nice dinner experience with a couple of old friends! Server was quiet, with just the right amount of attention, but not too much. Good food and a nice atmosphere. I’ll be back.
The worst service I have ever had anywhere. The food was bland as well. I told the hostess that the service was poor and she said “okay,” not even apologizing. Terrible place.
Loading...