Milk Bar

561 Columbus Ave, New York
(212) 256-0586

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Cereal Milk Soft Serve with Crunch Topping
Milk Bar Sampler
Cake Truffles
Compost Cookie
Birthday
Cookies
Pie

Menu

Featured items
B'day Cake Slice
Our bestselling Birthday Cake is inspired by the supermarket stuff we grew up with, and it took us over two years to get it just right: three tiers of rainbow-flecked vanilla Birthday cake layered with creamy Birthday frosting, crunchy Birthday crumbs, and rainbow sprinkles. Tastes like childhood.
Crunchy Cereal Milkshake
Cereal Milk™ Soft Serve and Cornflake Crunch, blended into a corny, creamy, crunchy shake.
Red Velvet Cheesecake Cake Slice
Our Red Velvet Cheesecake Cake ups the ante on decadence with layers of double chocolate red velvet cake and frosting, cheesecake filling, and red velvet crumbs.
Chocolate B'day Cake Slice
The classic Birthday Cake, but make it chocolate. Decadent chocolate cake plus chocolate chips, layered with creamy Birthday frosting, crunchy Birthday crumbs, and rainbow sprinkles.
B'day Milkshake
A sweet, sippable treat blending Cereal Milk™ Soft Serve with B'Day Cake Truffles.
Cake & Shake
The best dessert duo, choose a slice of cake to pair with a shake!
6" B'day Cake
Our bestselling Birthday Cake is inspired by the supermarket stuff we grew up with, and it took us over two years to get it just right: three tiers of rainbow-flecked vanilla Birthday cake layered with creamy Birthday frosting, crunchy Birthday crumbs, and rainbow sprinkles. Tastes like childhood.Serves 6-8 people.
Chocolate B'day Milkshake
A sweet, sippable treat blending Cereal Milk™ Soft Serve with Fudge and Chocolate B'Day Cake Truffles.
COOKIE 3 Deal
Choose 3 Milk Bar cookies - all individually wrapped.
Gluten Free B'day Cake Slice
Our classic Birthday Cake, inspired by the supermarket stuff we grew up with - now made gluten-free! Three tiers of rainbow-flecked, gluten-free vanilla B'Day cake layered with creamy B'Day frosting and crunchy gluten-free B'Day crumbs. Tastes like childhood (y'know… without the gluten).
CAKE Peppermint Bark Slice
This decadent winter wonder starts with rich, peppermint-soaked dark chocolate cake and layers up with crunchy cocoa crumbs, silky chocolate fudge, creamy peppermint frosting, and crushed candy cane bits.
Gooey Butter Cake Milkquake
Peppermint Bark Milkshake 12oz
The Greatest Hits
All the Milk Bar classics in one gorgeous dessert spread. Includes a slice of Milk Bar Pie, a 3-pack of B'Day Cake Truffles, a Compost Cookie®, and a single serving of Cereal Milk™ Soft Serve with Cornflake Crunch.
PIE Whole Milk Bar
The iconic dessert was a happy accident born in the kitchen of wd~50 when there wasn't much in the fridge. When Tosi served the simple, gooey pie (inspired by southern Chess Pie) at staff dinner, she never anticipated the reaction it got - and a signature pie was born! With a sticky, buttery, salty-sweet filling in a hearty oat cookie crust, Milk Bar Pie has been a Tosi favorite since the beginning.10" pie serves 8-10.
COOKIE 6 Deal
Choose 6 Milk Bar cookies - all individually wrapped. Add a Tin to make it a gift!
Marshmallow Brownie Cake Milkquake
3 Truffle Packs Deal
Choose from any three packs of truffles. Three truffles in each pack.
6" Chocolate B'day Cake
The classic Birthday Cake, but make it chocolate. Decadent chocolate cake plus chocolate chips, layered with creamy Birthday frosting, crunchy Birthday crumbs, and rainbow sprinkles.Serves 6-8 people.
6" Red Velvet Cheesecake Cake
Our Red Velvet Cheesecake Cake ups the ante on decadence with layers of double chocolate red velvet cake and frosting, cheesecake filling, and red velvet crumbs.

Cookies
COOKIE 3 Deal
Choose 3 Milk Bar cookies - all individually wrapped.
COOKIE Cornflake
A crunchy, chewy riff on the classic chocolate chip, packed with cornflakes and marshmallows.
COOKIE Compost
A sweet and salty kitchen sink cookie with chocolate chips in a graham cracker base - plus pretzels, potato chips, coffee, oats, and butterscotch.
COOKIE Confetti
Fluffy, chewy, sugary, and buttery, with a B'day punch of vanilla and rainbow sprinkles.
COOKIE 6 Deal
Choose 6 Milk Bar cookies - all individually wrapped. Add a Tin to make it a gift!
COOKIE Corn
A Milk Bar favorite. The down-home flavor of your favorite cornbread, captured in a cookie.
COOKIE Blueberry & Cream
A muffin top masquerading as a cookie. Sugar cookie dough, milk crumbs, and chewy dried blueberry morsels.
COOKIE 12 Deal
Choose 12 Milk Bar cookies - all individually wrapped. Add a Tin to make it a gift!
SNAP Mini Peppermint Snap
Pretzels, peppermint, caramel, and chocolate combine atop a crisp dark chocolate wafer before the whole thing gets dipped in silky white chocolate peppermint bark
MERCH 12 ct Tin
Pack your cookies up to make it a gift! *Does not include cookies!
MERCH 6 ct Tin
Pack your cookies up to make it a gift! *Does not include cookies!

Cake Slices
B'day Cake Slice
Our bestselling Birthday Cake is inspired by the supermarket stuff we grew up with, and it took us over two years to get it just right: three tiers of rainbow-flecked vanilla Birthday cake layered with creamy Birthday frosting, crunchy Birthday crumbs, and rainbow sprinkles. Tastes like childhood.
Red Velvet Cheesecake Cake Slice
Our Red Velvet Cheesecake Cake ups the ante on decadence with layers of double chocolate red velvet cake and frosting, cheesecake filling, and red velvet crumbs.
Chocolate B'day Cake Slice
The classic Birthday Cake, but make it chocolate. Decadent chocolate cake plus chocolate chips, layered with creamy Birthday frosting, crunchy Birthday crumbs, and rainbow sprinkles.
Gluten Free B'day Cake Slice
Our classic Birthday Cake, inspired by the supermarket stuff we grew up with - now made gluten-free! Three tiers of rainbow-flecked, gluten-free vanilla B'Day cake layered with creamy B'Day frosting and crunchy gluten-free B'Day crumbs. Tastes like childhood (y'know… without the gluten).
CAKE Peppermint Bark Slice
This decadent winter wonder starts with rich, peppermint-soaked dark chocolate cake and layers up with crunchy cocoa crumbs, silky chocolate fudge, creamy peppermint frosting, and crushed candy cane bits.

6" Cakes
6" B'day Cake
Our bestselling Birthday Cake is inspired by the supermarket stuff we grew up with, and it took us over two years to get it just right: three tiers of rainbow-flecked vanilla Birthday cake layered with creamy Birthday frosting, crunchy Birthday crumbs, and rainbow sprinkles. Tastes like childhood.Serves 6-8 people.
6" Chocolate B'day Cake
The classic Birthday Cake, but make it chocolate. Decadent chocolate cake plus chocolate chips, layered with creamy Birthday frosting, crunchy Birthday crumbs, and rainbow sprinkles.Serves 6-8 people.
6" Gluten Free B'day Cake
Our classic Birthday Cake, inspired by the supermarket stuff we grew up with - now made gluten-free! Three tiers of rainbow-flecked, gluten-free vanilla B'Day cake layered with creamy B'Day frosting and crunchy gluten-free B'Day crumbs. Tastes like childhood (y'know… without the gluten).Serves 6-8 people.
6" Red Velvet Cheesecake Cake
Our Red Velvet Cheesecake Cake ups the ante on decadence with layers of double chocolate red velvet cake and frosting, cheesecake filling, and red velvet crumbs.
6" Peppermint Bark Cake
Peppy is officially back in action! This decadent winter wonder starts with rich, peppermint-soaked dark chocolate cake and layers up with crunchy cocoa crumbs, silky chocolate fudge, creamy peppermint frosting, and crushed candy cane bits.

Truffles
B'day Truffles 3-pack
Rainbow-flecked, vanilla-infused cake bites, coated in a barely-there drizzle of white chocolate and rolled in B'day crumbs.
Red Velvet Truffles 3pk
Get ‘em truffles that say "bite me." Each decadent bite is filled with chocolate cake, chocolate chips, cream cheese, and red velvet crumbs with a delicate chocolate shell on the outside. So irresistible, you'll want to take a few back to your place ;).
3 Truffle Packs Deal
Choose from any three packs of truffles. Three truffles in each pack.
Chocolate B'Day Truffles 3-Pack
Fudgy cake bites loaded with chocolate chips and rainbow sprinkles, coated in more chocolate and a dusting of chocolate cake crumbs.
Dozen B'day Truffles
Rainbow-flecked, vanilla-infused cake bites, coated in a barely-there drizzle of white chocolate and rolled in B'day crumbs.
The Assorted Truffle Box
Perfect for gifting, treating yourself, or both. Choose up to 3 flavors, or all the same! Add a Tin to make it a gift!
Dozen Chocolate b'day Truffles
Fudgy cake bites loaded with chocolate chips and rainbow sprinkles, coated in more chocolate and a dusting of chocolate cake crumbs.
Dozen Red Velvet Truffles
Get ‘em truffles that say "bite me." Each decadent bite is filled with chocolate cake, chocolate chips, cream cheese, and red velvet crumbs with a delicate chocolate shell on the outside. So irresistible, you'll want to take a few back to your place ;).
TRUFFLE Chocolate Mint Chip 3pk
TRUFFLE Chocolate Mint Chip 12pk
18ct Truffle Tin
Pack your truffles up to make it a gift! *Does not include truffles!

Pie
PIE Slice Milk Bar
The iconic dessert was a happy accident born in the kitchen of wd~50 when there wasn't much in the fridge. When Tosi served the simple, gooey pie (inspired by southern Chess Pie) at staff dinner, she never anticipated the reaction it got - and a signature pie was born! With a sticky, buttery, salty-sweet filling in a hearty oat cookie crust, Milk Bar Pie has been a Tosi favorite since the beginning.
PIE Whole Milk Bar
The iconic dessert was a happy accident born in the kitchen of wd~50 when there wasn't much in the fridge. When Tosi served the simple, gooey pie (inspired by southern Chess Pie) at staff dinner, she never anticipated the reaction it got - and a signature pie was born! With a sticky, buttery, salty-sweet filling in a hearty oat cookie crust, Milk Bar Pie has been a Tosi favorite since the beginning.10" pie serves 8-10.

Milkshakes
Crunchy Cereal Milkshake
Cereal Milk™ Soft Serve and Cornflake Crunch, blended into a corny, creamy, crunchy shake.
B'day Milkshake
A sweet, sippable treat blending Cereal Milk™ Soft Serve with B'Day Cake Truffles.
Chocolate B'day Milkshake
A sweet, sippable treat blending Cereal Milk™ Soft Serve with Fudge and Chocolate B'Day Cake Truffles.
Peppermint Bark Milkshake 12oz

Milkquakes
Gooey Butter Cake Milkquake
Marshmallow Brownie Cake Milkquake

Breads
BREAD Bagel Bomb
Our classic Bagel Bomb is filled with smokey bacon, scallion cream cheese, and topped with everything bagel spice!

Bundles
Cake & Shake
The best dessert duo, choose a slice of cake to pair with a shake!
The Greatest Hits
All the Milk Bar classics in one gorgeous dessert spread. Includes a slice of Milk Bar Pie, a 3-pack of B'Day Cake Truffles, a Compost Cookie®, and a single serving of Cereal Milk™ Soft Serve with Cornflake Crunch.
Party Pack
The best gift duo, an assorted Truffle dozen and assorted 6 Cookie Tin.
The Classic
Classic, timeless: one 6" Birthday Cake, plus a dozen B'day Cake Truffles.
The Chocolatey Classic
Classic, but make it chocolate: one 6" Chocolate Birthday Cake, plus a dozen Chocolate B'day Cake Truffles!
The OGs

Ice Cream Pints
ICECREAM Gingerbread Latte

Crunchies
Chocolate Snowball
Candy Cane Chocolate Chip

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: ubereats
+56 photos
Photo credit: ubereats
+55 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I want to be nice about it but just to be clear, how are we rationalizing $11 for a slice of cake? I was ready to dig in. I said I KNOW I’m about to have an experience and I took that first bite and said 😑 … I purchased all their flavor of cookies as well. I would never go back. For the prices in NYC and options we have, you can do so much better. I’m so sorry but to each taste palate their own. To put in perspective, I find a fresh warm batch of chocolate cookies from...
March 2025
I had wanted to taste Milk's Birthday Cake for several years and didn't want to order online because I wanted a fresh slice. I arrived at the Columbus Street location yesterday and ordered it. I didn't want to wait to get back to the hotel to taste it, so we sat at the bar to try it. When I opened the box, it appeared old. The icing was separating from the cake and after tasting it, the cake was dry and appeared to have been refrigerated for some time. The cookie...
October 2024
Lovely place to grab a sweet treat, with very kind and accommodating staff. Thank you to Glen and Kaitlyn for their amazing service and kindness every time i visit?

Dietary restrictions: Nut free!
August 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

PlantShed - 555 Columbus Ave
Coffee & Tea, Nurseries & Gardening, Cafe, Pet Friendly
Tacos El Azteca - W 87 st &, 568 Columbus Ave
Tacos, Mexican, Tex-Mex
Bodega 88 - 573 Columbus Ave
Sports Bar, Cocktail Bar, Latin American

Milk Bar

561 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024
(212) 256-0586