Oddfellows Ice Cream

141 8th Ave, New York
(631) 825-2342

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Dr. William Starsiak

What sets this a place apart from either ice cream places is really the decor. It's kind of out there and funky. Creative ice cream based edgy art on the walls, a TV playing semi-psychedelic weird ice cream based grainy videos near the front, big red and white stripes all over. It's a fun place to get ice cream.

joanne sinovoi

Good Ice cream. Next time I get stamped free. Rewards card

Marisa Gesualdi

Skimpy hand packed pint (packed is not the word I would use) and the mango sticky rice was completely missing the mochi rice. I’m just so disappointing because I’ve been wanting to try that flavor specifically for the mochi taste and texture and all I got was smooth ice cream (boring!) for $12.52 after tax

Pete Jones

Nice ice cream but way too expensive ($10 for a single scoop cone), the cone was stale and the spoon cut my lip! Van Leeuwen is across the street, go there instead.

any de leon

I rate it 5 because the ice cream is very good and it looks so cartoonish. I love it!!

Dwight Rodwell

Very delicious Ice-cream and a very comfortable atmosphere to be in. My dad and I enjoyed it entirely. The server/cashier was very pleasant and kind to talk to. The flavors were remarkable with the Passion Fruit Apricot Pistachio flavor standing out for me and my dad would agree. Definitely would recommend this place for those who have a certain sweet tooth. Will be back whenever possible.

Sports Opinion Log

Being an ice cream, kind of sore when I saw Oddfellows, I know I had to go in and try out their flavors

However, they have a peanut butter s’mores ice cream and unfortunately I have allergies to peanuts so I cannot partake in that delicious s’mores ice cream however, I did have a chocolate chunk and I believe something hot like a marshmallow cake ice cream which was good

Bonus. They also have a happy hour I believe, which is between 2 and 5 PM Monday through Friday, which I would highly recommend.

Kayla heart

I went to this place to get ice cream and it was definitely enjoyed. Nice soft tasting ice cream. The Ambiance was nice and I loved how the store was decorated.

Jason Ortiz

High air content (overrun), melts immediately, low fat content, no egg yolk content. This is el cheapo ice cream masquerading as quality ice cream.

colm johnston

Yum 😋

Nick Felker

I got a root beer float here. This ice cream shop has a variety of flavors and options for how the ice cream is served.

Richard Clervil

Amazing flavors got to bring some friends to check it out next time

Stephanie A

I tried the “cookie jar” flavor ice cream and it was great.

Henry SooHoo

The vegan coconut mango sticky rice. It is pretty good. You can hardly tell that it is vegan. Yes, you can taste a coconut, but it seemed more like an intrinsic part of the flavor than the base. The mochi in it was so, so good. However, the base is too sweet, and it was tough to eat by the second half of the cup. This would be pretty much perfect if it was a third less sweet.

Seth Michael May

Insanely good ice cream from the bizarre mix in flavors to the simpler tastes.

Loading...