old school steak house. loved the atmosphere and food, very old new york style.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Laura Degrenia
Steak was amazing, dessert was delicious. Our waiter Henry was wonderful. Amazing place to come if you’re visiting New York!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Creme Brulee, Potato, Old Homestead Caesar Salad
Amy Hyewon Hong
Grabbing my check, our server pointed out the bill and said “the tip doesn’t include here, the tip includes this amount. Ok???”Wow. I’ve never heard of that ridiculous uncomfortable sentence in any other restaurants in the states. We had enjoyed our meal but he ruined it. Furthermore, when we left there, another server said “Cie-Cie!!! Chao-Chao!” OMG. We’re not even Chinese. What a nasty racial discrimination?!!!???????? You guys must train them from the very beginning. What a horrible experience there.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 1
Maura Earles
So I treated one of my family members to a trip to New York, technically to go see the Andrea Bocelli concert, but while we were in New York, we also treated ourselves to a nice dinner out, but the reason I cannot give it a five star and I have to give it a three which would actually be a 3 1/2 is I ordered a medium rare steak and was probably wrong and should’ve ordered a medium steak so I asked for it to be taken back and just seared a little bit more and I don’t know if it was the cook or the waiter but somebody chided me on that and you just don’t do that to a customer
Martin Saposnick
1895 Old Steakhouse in
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Mashed Potatoes, The Gotham Rob Steak on the Bone 24 Oz
RICCARDO CARRIERI
Very good meat, kind service but challenging prices (in line with the crazy costs of New York)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Andreas Larcher
Place to be in New York! Really perfekt steaks and nice Service! Not too cheep but you het what you pay?✅✅✅
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steve B.
Can't go wrong with a classic establishment that has stood the test of time. Everything was delicious! We had the pleasure of having Henry take care of us and his recommendations made the dinner that much more enjoyable. Look forward to the next visit.
Zack Frankel
Classic steakhouse with delicious food. We got the burger and filet, perfectly cooked. Sides were mushrooms that burst with flavor when you take a bite. The chocolate cake with vanilla ice cream was great.On the more expensive side of restaurants but good for a treat!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Prime Steakhouse Burger, Hand Cut Fries, Salad, Mashed Potatoes
Michael R.
Great steak and sides Henry our waiter brought his A game. pricey but what steakhouse isn't There is a reason it's been around so long and the neighborhoods mainstay Visiting NY hit this spot ask for Henry sit back and loosen your belt
I expected so much more coming here. It definitely was very disappointing. We had the porter house and the 40 day aged steak. It was unseasoned, tough, and had a lot of cartilage in the meat. Why call yourself a steakhouse if you can't even make a good steak?? In all honesty, the sides were way better than the freaking STEAK. The service was very good. We had a guy named Henry and he was funny.
Isabella S.
Best food, best service, and the coolest steakhouse I've been to in the city!! A must !!!
Susanne J.
Everything was excellent and the service was great. The creamed spinach was the best that I've had
Daniel E.
I expected way more. Over-priced is not the only word that comes to mind, overrated is another. We got the porterhouse for two but there was one key ingredient missing, salt! Not sure why a steakhouse thinks that there meat is so good that it doesn't need salt. This ruined my whole experience
James C.
best crab cake in the city shrimp cocktail are the biggest I've ever had bacon as a side is phenomenal Henry, Dana - class acts
old school steak house. loved the atmosphere and food, very old new york style.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steak was amazing, dessert was delicious. Our waiter Henry was wonderful. Amazing place to come if you’re visiting New York!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Creme Brulee, Potato, Old Homestead Caesar Salad
Grabbing my check, our server pointed out the bill and said “the tip doesn’t include here, the tip includes this amount. Ok???”Wow. I’ve never heard of that ridiculous uncomfortable sentence in any other restaurants in the states. We had enjoyed our meal but he ruined it. Furthermore, when we left there, another server said “Cie-Cie!!! Chao-Chao!” OMG. We’re not even Chinese. What a nasty racial discrimination?!!!???????? You guys must train them from the very beginning. What a horrible experience there.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 1
So I treated one of my family members to a trip to New York, technically to go see the Andrea Bocelli concert, but while we were in New York, we also treated ourselves to a nice dinner out, but the reason I cannot give it a five star and I have to give it a three which would actually be a 3 1/2 is I ordered a medium rare steak and was probably wrong and should’ve ordered a medium steak so I asked for it to be taken back and just seared a little bit more and I don’t know if it was the cook or the waiter but somebody chided me on that and you just don’t do that to a customer
1895 Old Steakhouse in
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Mashed Potatoes, The Gotham Rob Steak on the Bone 24 Oz
Very good meat, kind service but challenging prices (in line with the crazy costs of New York)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Place to be in New York! Really perfekt steaks and nice Service! Not too cheep but you het what you pay?✅✅✅
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Can't go wrong with a classic establishment that has stood the test of time. Everything was delicious! We had the pleasure of having Henry take care of us and his recommendations made the dinner that much more enjoyable. Look forward to the next visit.
Classic steakhouse with delicious food. We got the burger and filet, perfectly cooked. Sides were mushrooms that burst with flavor when you take a bite. The chocolate cake with vanilla ice cream was great.On the more expensive side of restaurants but good for a treat!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Prime Steakhouse Burger, Hand Cut Fries, Salad, Mashed Potatoes
Great steak and sides Henry our waiter brought his A game. pricey but what steakhouse isn't There is a reason it's been around so long and the neighborhoods mainstay Visiting NY hit this spot ask for Henry sit back and loosen your belt
Restaurantji Recommends
I expected so much more coming here. It definitely was very disappointing. We had the porter house and the 40 day aged steak. It was unseasoned, tough, and had a lot of cartilage in the meat. Why call yourself a steakhouse if you can't even make a good steak?? In all honesty, the sides were way better than the freaking STEAK. The service was very good. We had a guy named Henry and he was funny.
Best food, best service, and the coolest steakhouse I've been to in the city!! A must !!!
Everything was excellent and the service was great. The creamed spinach was the best that I've had
I expected way more. Over-priced is not the only word that comes to mind, overrated is another. We got the porterhouse for two but there was one key ingredient missing, salt! Not sure why a steakhouse thinks that there meat is so good that it doesn't need salt. This ruined my whole experience
best crab cake in the city shrimp cocktail are the biggest I've ever had bacon as a side is phenomenal Henry, Dana - class acts