O'Toole's Way

518 W 30th St, New York
(646) 558-5706

Recent Reviews Order Online Reserve

Customers' Favorites

Skillet Chocolate Chip Cookie
Espresso Rubbed Chicken Wings
Proper Fish and Chips Plate
Dangerous Dave's Dublin Dip
Devils on Horseback Plate
Fillet of Salmon Plate
The High Line Salad
Chicken Sandwich
Margherita Pizza
Chicken Pot Pie

Small Plates

Devils on Horseback Plate
Goat cheese, port reduction.

Soups & Salads

Farmhouse Potato & Leek Soup
served with house-made soda bread

Sandwiches & Burgers
"Dangerous Dave's" Dublin Dip
shaved prime rib, irish cheddar, caramelized onions, horseradish, served on ciabatta, "with its own gravy"

Large Plates

Mussels and Fries Plate
Irish cider, garlic, cream, lemon, parsley.
Squash Ravioli
Ricotta, toasted hazelnuts, burnt butter, crispy sage
Steak Frites
14oz Espresso Rub Prime NY Strip, truffle butter, watercress, roasted garlic, fries
Charred Cauliflower Steak
cauliflower and quinoa cous cous, spinach & cherry tomato, nigella seeds

Sides
Fries with Parmesan & Truffle Oil
Dirty Fries Plate
Short rib gravy, Irish cheddar, scallions.

Puddings (Irish Dessert)
Dangerous Dave's Key Lime Pie
toasted coconut, chantilly cream
Sticky Toffee
moist sponge cake with chopped dates, covered with toffee sauce

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+40 photos
Photo credit: google
+39 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I loved the menu options - something for everyone! Service was warm and responsive, they were able and happy to accommodate some food preferences/sensitivities. The location was excellent and it had an elevated Irish pub vibe that felt casual yet thoughtful. Will return for another meal when I'm in the area!
October 2025
My group and I had a lovely time! There are five of us, I had the brick chicken, which was delicious! Three of us had the brick chicken. One had a burger and he enjoyed it very much and another person had the salmon which was also delicious! Our server Camilla was lovely and attentive! We will be back again.
October 2025
Great place to eat. May not seem family friendly but we went with our kids - 3 ( ages 10, 9 and 5) and it was perfect after a day at the high line. Also our waitress, Camila was awesome!!
September 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Cafe Grumpy - Manhattan West - inside Whole Foods Market, 450 W 33rd St
Coffee Shops, Coffee, Coffee & Tea
Kahlo - 525 W 29th St
Mexican, New Mexican Cuisine, Tacos, Vegan, Vegetarian
La Barra at Mercado Little Spain - 10 Hudson Yards
Spanish, Tapas Bar, Pet Friendly

O'Toole's Way

518 W 30th St, New York, NY 10001
(646) 558-5706