Papa Johns Pizza
1709 Amsterdam Ave, New York
(212) 281-7272
Customers' Favorites
Extra Large New York Style Pizza
Chocolate Brownie
Pepperoni Pizza
Green Peppers
Pizzas Wings
Featured Selection
Create Your Own Spicy Garlic Epic Stuffed Crust Pizza
Create Your Own Garlic Epic Stuffed Crust Pizza
XL New York Style Create Your Own Pizza
Create Your Own Doritos® Cool Ranch® Papadia
Garlic Parmesan Boneless Wings
Papa Picks
Create Your Own Garlic Epic Stuffed Crust Pizza
Create Your Own Spicy Garlic Epic Stuffed Crust Pizza
Create Your Own Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Sausage Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Epic Pepperoni-Stuffed Crust Pepperoni Pizza
Epic Stuffed Crust Create Your Own Pizza
Create Your Own Gluten-Free Crust
Pizza
The Works Pizza
The Meats Pizza
Zesty Italian Trio Pizza
Meatball Pepperoni Pizza
Super Hawaiian Pizza
Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza
BBQ Chicken Bacon Pizza
Fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Philly Cheesesteak Pizza
Pepperoni, Sausage & Six Cheese Pizza
Extra Cheesy Alfredo Pizza
Fresh Spinach & Tomato Alfredo Pizza
Garden Fresh Pizza
Tuscan Six Cheese Pizza
Hawaiian BBQ Chicken Pizza
Papa Bowls
Italian Meats Trio Papa Bowl
Garden Veggie Papa Bowl
Chicken Alfredo Papa Bowl
Create Your Own Papa Bowl
Papadias
Doritos® Cool Ranch® Chicken Papadia
Doritos® Cool Ranch® Steak Papadia
Doritos® Cool Ranch® Beef Papadia
Create Your Own Doritos® Cool Ranch® Papadia
Create Your Own Papadia
Philly Cheesesteak Papadia
BBQ Chicken & Bacon Papadia
Grilled Buffalo Chicken Papadia
Meatball Pepperoni Papadia
Italian Papadia
Parmesan Crusted Create Your Own Papadia
Parmesan Crusted Philly Cheesesteak Papadia
Parmesan Crusted BBQ Chicken & Bacon Papadia
Parmesan Crusted Grilled Buffalo Chicken Papadia
Parmesan Crusted Meatball Pepperoni Papadia
Parmesan Crusted Italian Papadia
Papa Bites
OREO® Cookie Papa Bites
Chicken Parmesan Papa Bites
Jalapeño Papa Bites
Wings
Unsauced Roasted Wings
Garlic Parmesan Wings
Hot Lemon Pepper Wings
Buffalo Wings
BBQ Wings
Honey Chipotle Wings
Unsauced Boneless Wings
Garlic Parmesan Boneless Wings
Hot Lemon Pepper Boneless Wings
Buffalo Boneless Wings
BBQ Boneless Wings
Honey Chipotle Boneless Wings
Sides
Original Breadsticks
Garlic Parmesan Breadsticks
Cheesesticks
Bacon Cheesesticks
Tuscan 6-Cheese Cheesesticks
Garlic Knots
Chicken Parmesan Papa Bites
Jalapeño Papa Bites
Desserts
OREO® Cookie Papa Bites
Cinnamon Pull Aparts
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Double Chocolate Chip Brownie
Drinks
Pepsi
Mountain Dew
Diet Pepsi
Starry
Crush Orange
Aquafina
Extras
Pepperoncinis
Jalapeño Peppers
Banana Peppers
Anchovies
Doritos® Cool Ranch® Sauce
Special Zesty Sauce
Special Garlic Sauce
Spicy Garlic Sauce
Original Pizza Sauce
Ranch Sauce
Blue Cheese Sauce
Honey Mustard Sauce
Buffalo Spicy Sauce
Barbeque Sauce
Cream Cheese Icing
Special Seasonings
Crushed Red Pepper
Parmesan Cheese
Photos
+46 photos
+45 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Papa John's is my go to delish extra cheesy yummy pizzas to enjoy.There are so many varieties to choose from with sodas,breadsticks,desserts,dipping sauces The toppings are yummy to add on your pizzas.My pizzas are always hot and fresh with flavor.The staff is friendly and great.The place is clean and you can smell the pizzas baking in the oven.Thr crust is thin and made to order with stuffed garlic and many delish vegetables to bite into your favorite pizzas.The prices...
October 2025
My small cheese pizza was awesome and the staff were super helpful and friendly—not sure of the other staff member’s name I spoke with, but Pablo and he were both awesomely great!
My only beef: and this is of course at no fault of the staff—the difference between carry-out and delivery was from $6 to $18.
Man, the staff were so nice and I do have a bit of an addiction to Papa John’s pizza, so I’m sure I’ll order again but only...
My only beef: and this is of course at no fault of the staff—the difference between carry-out and delivery was from $6 to $18.
Man, the staff were so nice and I do have a bit of an addiction to Papa John’s pizza, so I’m sure I’ll order again but only...
September 2025
One time I went there and the guy serving pizza had this gross looking yellow substance on his arm. It looked like mucus or vomit. I mention and wiped it off a little. I cannot confirm if he washed his hands. Needless to say, hygiene isn’t always prioritized at every location.
February 2025
You May Also Like
The Oma, Coffee + Home - 1707 Amsterdam Ave
![]()
Cafe, Coffee & Tea
Falafel Tarboosh - 1701 Amsterdam Ave
![]()
Falafel, Fast Food, Middle Eastern, Pet Friendly
4 Brothers Food Market And Deli - 1712 Amsterdam Ave
![]()
Mexican, Grocery