Paul & Jimmy’s Ristorante
123 E 18th St, New York
(212) 475-9540
Customers' Favorites
Complementary Bread and Olive Oil
Spaghetti Alla Carbonara
Fusilli Alla Puttanesca
Linguine Alle Vongole
Pasta with Meat Sauce
Pollo Alla Parmigiana
Italian Cheese Cake
Eggplant Parmigiana
Chicken Franceses
Potato Croquettes
Menu
Photos
+84 photos
+83 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Northern Italian food at its finest! I had my first date, with my now wife, here 45 years ago and the owner Louie has impressed us with the same quality food and service as the first time we came here. Very good wine selection at reasonable prices. The burrata and beet salad was delicious as a starter. The halibut special was cooked to perfection as was the branzino! A side dish of pasta with oil and garlic was the perfect compliment to the halibut!
I love Italian food, but I’m allergic to garlic. P&J has always been able to accommodate me and the food is always delicious! They have a home made tomatoes sauce with no garlic that is so yummy! I just had the tastiest non-garlic mussels for the first time in years (they are slathered in garlic everywhere) and I was so happy!! Love the old country feel and that it is usually so quiet and pleasant. Some guest can get excited and loud, but it part of the charm :)
What a gem this place is! We called an audible and found Paul & Jimmy’s. From the service to the food, it was incredible. What a lovely little restaurant. Please go here and taste it for yourself.
You May Also Like
Javelina - 119 E 18th St
![]()
Tex-Mex, Southern, Mexican, Vegan, Vegetarian
Bedford Cheese Shop - 67 Irving Pl
![]()
Cheese Shops, Bagels
GupShup - 115 E 18th St (Between Park Ave &, Irving Pl
![]()
Indian, Cocktail Bar, Vegan, Vegetarian