Pi Bakerie
35 Cedar St, New York
(917) 991-6424
Customers' Favorites
Olive Oil Cake Slice
Notabagel Platter
Almond Croissant
Mini Cheese Pie
Greek Pastries
Baklava PI
Croissants
Orange PI
Tyropita
Bougatsa
Easter Specials
Tsoureki Vasilopita 2lb
Special Holiday Desserts
Melomakarona 1/2 Lb
Kourabiedes 1/2Lb
Kourabiedes 1Lb
Hot Coffee
[SMALL] Drip Coffee
[LARGE] Drip Coffee
Americano
Cappuccino
Cortado
Espresso
Flat White
Greek Coffee
Latte
Macchiato
Mocha
Cold Coffee
[SMALL] Cold Brew
[LARGE] Cold Brew
Iced Americano
Ice Latte
Freddo Espresso
Freddo Cappuccino
Frappe
Iced Mocha
Cold Beverages
Mint Lemonade
Ice Matcha Latte
Ice Matcha
Iced Chai Latte
Mint Lemonade Matcha
Green John Juice (Green Apple, Celery, Spinach, Kale,lemon)
Doctors Advice Juice
Freshly Squeezed Orange Juice
Coke
Diet Coke
Ice Chocolate
Ice Greek Tea
Yuzzu
sparkling water
still water
Hot Beverages
Chai Latte
Matcha
Hot Chocolate
Matcha Latte
Hot Tea
Croissants
Plain Croissant
Chocolate Croissant
Almond Paste Croissant
Ham And Cheese Croissant
Spinach & Cheese
Bougatsa
Not-A-Bagel
Plain Sesame
Salmon w/ Cream Cheese
Bri Cheese
Greek Yogurt & Cucumber
Mozzarella, Tomato, & Pesto Sauce
Salami & Kasseri
Mini Not-A-Bagel
Salmon & Cream Cheese
Greek Yogurt,cucumber
Tomato ,Mozzarella and Pesto Sauce
Plain
Bri Cheese
Greek Specialties
Pastitio
Meatballs
Ground beef meatballs, in tomato sauce.
Gigantes (Beans w/ Spinach)
Dolmadaki
Mousaka Pi
Chicken
chicken breast, with mustard lemon sauce.
Briam
Dolmadakia (5 FOR 4.50)
Savory Pies
Chicken Vegetable Pie
Zucchini Pi
Frittata
Green Harvest Pie
Mince Pie
Appetizer Pies
Spanakopita
Tyropita
Mini Spanakopitaki
Mini Tyropitaki
[DEAL] 3 mini for $5
Triangle Pies
Salads
Horiatiki Salad
Green(Prasini) Salad
Lentil Salad
Bulgur Salad
Black Eyed Bean Salad
Yogurts
Plain Greek Yogurt
Desserts
[SMALL] Almond Pound Cake
Baklava Pi
Galaktoboureko (Sweet Milk pi)
Orange Pi
[Gf] Chocolate Pie
Single Cookie
Rice Pudding
Mini baklava/cookies by Ib
9" Tray Sweets
[LARGE] Almond Pound Cake
Walnut Pi
Apple Pi
Kormos
Kormos (3 FOR $5)
Mini Assorted Baklava 1/2 lb
All Dips
Hummus
Hummus M(8oz)
Hummus L(16oz)
Tzatziki S(3oz)
Tzatziki M(8oz)
Tzatziki L(16oz)
Spicy Feta S(3oz)
Spicy Feta M(8oz)
Spicy Feta L(16oz)
Eggplant/ Melitzanosalata S(3oz)
Eggplant/Melitzanosalata M(8oz)
Eggplant/Melitzanosalata L(16oz)
Dip Trio
Soups
Lentil
Chicken Lemon Soup\Avgolemeno
Catering Breakfast
Notabagel Platter
Morning Wake Up Breakfast Platter
Breakfast Pi Platter
Greek Frittata
Fresh Greek Yogurt Bar
Greek Yogurt Parfait
Box Coffee
Event Catering
Notabagel Platter
Mini Pi Platter
Mousakas/ Pastitio Full Tray 12 Pc
Mousaka/ Pastitio Half Tray 6 Pc
Dip Trio Catering
Pies
Mini Assorted Baklava
Baklava Large Tray
Traditional Salad Bar
Salads 80oz
Photos
+34 photos
+33 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I always order the same thing for lunch whenever I go here but sometimes they're sold out so today I decided to place the online pickup order earlier to ensure I would get my two favorite types of not-a-bagel. I got a text saying the order was ready but got waylaid at work for 40 minutes but it's not like the food goes bad so I knew it wouldn't be a problem to pick it up later. Unfortunately when I arrived and said my name they then tried to pick the two not-a-bagels...
February 2026
Food on display all looked very appetizing. Almond croissant and mozzarella pesto sandwich thing were ordered along with hot chocolate and tea (comes in a bag)
Hot chocolate was very rich, almost croissant was tasty. They had cookies in their separate outside building thing
Lots of families there having a good time
Hot chocolate was very rich, almost croissant was tasty. They had cookies in their separate outside building thing
Lots of families there having a good time
February 2026
We visited Pi Bakery on Cedar Street in Manhattan on a cold, snowy day, and it was the perfect cosy escape from the weather. The place was warm and welcoming, and we enjoyed a delicious warm apple pie that was absolutely gorgeous. They even whipped up some cream to go with it.
The staff were exceptionally friendly and helpful. We also had a hot chocolate and an Earl Grey tea, both of which were spot on. It was simply lovely to receive such genuinely excellent...
The staff were exceptionally friendly and helpful. We also had a hot chocolate and an Earl Grey tea, both of which were spot on. It was simply lovely to receive such genuinely excellent...
December 2025
You May Also Like
TEN THOUSAND Coffee - 14 Wall St
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee, Coffee & Tea, Coffee Roasteries
Five Guys - 80 Maiden Ln
![]()
Fast Food, Burgers, Hot Dogs