Pizza and Shakes

209 W 57th St, New York
(347) 640-5040

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza with Extra Cheese
Choose Your Pizza Dressing
Columbus Circle Pizza
Classic Basil Pizza
Country Style Pizza
Make Your Own Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
Quatreto Pizza
Flatbread
Kansas BBQ

Menu

Featured items
Overload Pizza
Signature tomato basil sauce, shredded mozzarella, mushrooms, Italian sausage, meatballs, pepperoni, bacon, romano parmesan, and mango habanero sauce.
Classic Basil Pizza
Signature tomato basil sauce, fresh mozzarella, and basil.
Quatreto Pizza
White garlic sauce, shredded mozzarella, ricotta cheese, fresh mozzarella, parmesan cheese, and garlic parmesan sauce.
Columbus Circle Pizza
E signature tomato basil sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, bacon, and hot honey sauce.
Parmesan Cheese Twists
The Swift Pizza
Spicy tomato sauce, parmesan cheese, pepperoni, jalapenos, roasted red peppers, and Nashville hot sauce.

Chefs Selection Pizzas
Quatreto Pizza
White garlic sauce, shredded mozzarella, ricotta cheese, fresh mozzarella, parmesan cheese, and garlic parmesan sauce.
The Taylor
Overload Pizza
Signature tomato basil sauce, shredded mozzarella, mushrooms, Italian sausage, meatballs, pepperoni, bacon, romano parmesan, and mango habanero sauce.
Classic Basil Pizza
Signature tomato basil sauce, fresh mozzarella, and basil.
Columbus Circle Pizza
E signature tomato basil sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, bacon, and hot honey sauce.
Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza
Signature tomato basil sauce, cheddar cheese, bacon, beef, caramelized onions, cherry tomatoes, and chick in the dipping sauce.
OG_PapaFern Fugazzeta Remix
white garlic sauce, extra cheese, bacon, caramelized onions, red peppers, garlic aioli, oregano, olive oil drizzle
Buffalo Bill Pizza
Signature tomato basil sauce, shredded mozzarella, grilled chicken, and wild buffalo sauce.
Country Style Pizza
Signature tomato basil sauce, pepperoni, bacon, meatballs, mozzarella, and sweet onion sauce.
The Swift Pizza
Spicy tomato sauce, parmesan cheese, pepperoni, jalapenos, roasted red peppers, and Nashville hot sauce.
Powerhouse Pizza
White garlic sauce, feta, goat cheese, chicken, broccoli, mushrooms, and garlic parmesan sauce.
Farmers Blue Pizza
Basil pesto sauce, blue cheese grilled chicken, broccoli, mushrooms, caramelized onions, and blue cheese dressing.
Harvest Moon Pizza
Vegetables-signature tomato basil sauce, roasted mix vegetables, mozzarella, and garlic aioli.
Kansas BBQ Pizza
Spicy tomato sauce, BBQ chicken, mozzarella, caramelized onions, romano parmesan, and Nashville hot sauce.

Make Your Own Pizza
Make Your Own Pizza

Side Twists
Parmesan Cheese Twists
Cinnamon Twist
Garlic Twists
Spicy Cheese Twists

Ice Cream Shakes
Premium Cookies & Cream Ice Cream Shake
Made with organic milk.
Premium Vanilla Ice Cream Shake
Made with organic milk.
Premium Chocolate Ice Cream Shake
Made with organic milk.
Premium Strawberry Ice Cream Shake
Made with organic milk.

Gelato Shakes
Dark Chocolate Shake
Made with organic milk.
Strawberry Shake
Made with organic milk.
Vanilla Shake
Made with organic milk.
Ferrero Rocher Shake
Made with organic milk.
Rainbow Cookies Shake
Made with organic milk.
Banana Nutella Shake
Made with organic milk.
Espresso Chip Shake
Made with organic milk.
Tiramisu Shake
Made with organic milk.
Salt Caramel Shake
Made with organic milk.
Mint Chip Shake
Made with organic milk.
Stracciatella Shake
Made with organic milk.
Hazelnut Shake
Made with organic milk.
Flor Di Basco Shake
Made with organic milk.
Greek Cherry Yogurt Shake
Made with organic milk.
Coconut Shake
Made with organic milk.

Sodas
Coca Cola
Diet Coca Cola
Sprite
Bottled Water
Celsius
Poppi
Essentia
Spindriff

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: facebook
+41 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+40 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Nice place with very good pizza. I did not get a shake however they have way more than pizza and shakes. They offer sandwiches, gelato and cookies as well. The pizza came out quickly. I ordered carryout by the time I made it back to my spot the pizza was still fresh and delicous. Taste the gelato while you wait. I recommend the Overlord.
January 2025
I love that you can customize your own pizza & it still be the same price as their signatures. I haven't tried their shakes or gelato yet but I'm sure it's good & will try it next time. Plus, they have a birthday cake & red velvet waffle zone.

Dietary restrictions: Can be a good spot if you eat halal but obviously only eat the pizza with vegetables or create your own
January 2025
Open till 11 and good for after Carnegie Hall. Unpretentious gelato, fresh and crispy waffle cone. We’ll go back for the pizza. Minimal seating but it wasn’t crowded on a Saturday night
December 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Carnegie Diner & Cafe - 205 W 57th St
Diner, Burgers, Pet Friendly, Vegan, Vegetarian
P.J. Carney’s Pub - 906 7th Ave
Irish Pub, Pubs, Soup, American, Vegetarian
Brooklyn Diner USA - 212 W 57th St
Diner, American, Vegan, Vegetarian

Pizza and Shakes

209 W 57th St, New York, NY 10019
(347) 640-5040