Prime Catch

140 W 46th St, New York
(646) 649-2288

Recent Reviews

mary wikswo

Fantastic food (lobster vodka pasta, seafood tower, surf and turf) and cocktails. Everything was delicious and well-proportioned. It’s expensive but worth the price. Location is right next to Times Square, but it was still quiet and not crowded. Our waiter Alex was the perfect mix of attentive without being overbearing. Overall we had an amazing dinner here!

Nydia Mendoza Otteni

We had a wonderful dinner here tonight. The atmosphere is lovely and the staff was friendly and our waiter was just the best! Our dinner was so delicious. The filet mignon was spectacular and so tender! Definitely will be coming back on our next visit to the city!

Sue Newman

We stumbled on Prime Catch because we were looking for a seafood restaurant. Prime Catch was sensational! The food was incredible the service, Leli, our server, was top notch. I would highly recommend it and I would eat there again in a heartbeat.

Walt A

An amazing experience from the moment you step int the door. The level of service given to everyone that walks in makes you feel like family. The food was superb with a great Happy Hour for fresh East Coast Oysters. The drink I had was a perfectly balanced Raspberry Moscow Mule which i will go back for again. The Surf and Turf selection item from the menu is to die for. A succculent Filet Mignon topped with Lobster tail. I was in heaven. Special thanks to Toli the Manager and Alex the bartender whose customer service were through the roof. Will definitely be back.

Arian Dumani

One of the best steakhouses I’ve had the opportunity to try. It is with great confidence that I will be coming back as everything was superb. Ranging from friendly and greeting staff, too the overall great ambiance the restaurant has to offer. Starting off the beautiful extended bar stretches to the end of the restaurant which has a huge variety of spirit selection, and eye catching decor. For starters we had the lobster tail which was filled with flavor and the shrimp with avocado is a must try for all who come. Following up was the highlight of the show, a dry aged tomahawk steak which we got medium rare with sides of cream spinach( which was a stand alone star), and Mac and cheese. If you’re looking for an excellent dinner with family and friends, too executive meals with clients I recommend you stop by.

OpenTable Diner

Was never told about the specials. Arrived at 615om no sign out front about specials. Waiter never told me about specials bill was almost $200 then we leave and there's a sign out front about specials which would have cut our bill in half. Plus I was chafed a $39 surcharge waiter couldn't explain will not go back


Food is delicious and the place is located close to Times Square which makes it easy to get there.

Joy Villa Buenaflor

food is really good , pasta and steak is the best. service is very excellent ?... the only problem the kids are screaming and running around at the restaurant the night we were there and no one talk to the kids parent to stop them.


Came here for a birthday dinner and the food was great. Server was great. The food runner dropped off an empty plate before the meals came out, but failed to mention the plate was EXTREMELY hot. I touched the plate to move it closer and burned my fingers. I ended up having a blister from the burn. When I mentioned it to the manager his response was “ohhh, ok” Not sure if he either misunderstood or didn’t hear me, but there was nothing else said or done after that not even an apology. Besides that, everything else was good especially the server who also happened to be bartending as well.

OpenTable Diner

Good dollar value!! The waitstaff were excellent !!


I've stayed at the Kimpton Muse many times and have walked past Prime Catch and never thought much of it. We decided to eat there prior to going to a show, because it was easy. Wow, I was so surprised at how good it was. I had a filet and my friend had the ribeye and both were excellent. Perfectly seared and cooked to our specifications. Sides were great for sharing. I'll be back!

OpenTable Diner

The food was not great. Dead flowers on the table.


actually didnt eat there. when we arrived they said their liquor licence had expired

opentable dinner

I made reservations for me and my boyfriend for his birthday I requested to be seated upstairs but when we got there they didn't acknowledge my reservations or my request. They wasn't serving alcohol that day either because their liquor license hadn't came in yet which was very upsetting because we didn't get a notification of this. Other than that the food and service was great.


actually didnt eat there. when we arrived they said their liquor licence had expired

Load More