Prime Catch
CLOSED$$$ •
About Prime Catch
Prime Catch Reviews
Myron was the BEST!
We went to Prime Catch 2 days in a row..12/30/2022 and 12/31/2022. With both experiences, we couldn't have asked for a better time. The waiter (Myron) treated us like we were the only 2 people there (which we ere NOT). Incredible service from start to finish. Not at all rushed, but also accommodated us when we needed to leave to catch a Broadway show. Manager checked on our table more than once each time. The food was EXCELLENT (had lobster, lamb chops, French onion soup, wedge...read full review
My 5 time on this restaurant
The bast steak 🥩 house
Good service good for party 🎉
I recommend the trying this place
Prime Catch in the ♥️ of New York
Thanks 🙏
Prime Catch is a welcoming restaurant with quick and friendly service, exceptional food, and a classy atmosphere that offers a wide variety of dishes. The restaurant is known for its late-night hours, often staying open until around 11:45 PM, making it a rare find in NYC. The ambiance is relaxed with good music that isn’t too loud, allowing guests to enjoy their meals comfortably. The menu features fresh and flavorful options like lobster ravioli, lobster bisque, tuna tartare, and wedge salad, all beautifully presented. The lobster bisque is particularly rich, full of lobster pieces, and offers great value. The fried calamari is considered some of the best, served with cocktail sauce and tartar sauce, though the tartar sauce may be more than needed. Drinks such as lychee martinis and spicy margaritas are popular for their strength and flavor. The service is generally friendly and attentive, with staff members like Tolly making guests feel like family. Despite occasional slow service at the bar, the overall experience is highly recommended for those seeking great late-night dining, top-tier hospitality, and a cozy atmosphere. Visitors returning to NYC often choose Prime Catch again for its quality food and welcoming vibe.