Prime Catch

$$$ • Steak House, Seafood

140 W 46th St, New York
(646) 649-2288


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Prime Catch

Unassuming from the outside, surprisingly warm, inviting and cozy inside. Toli, the maitre d', was very accommodating, friendly and on top of his game. He and his staff checked in often on us and ensured we enjoyed our food and dinner experience. They also seemed to enjoy working each other which made for a very funny evening. We ordered the filet mignon and grilled salmon. The filet was cooked perfectly, lightly seasoned with a crisp fatty sear on the outside with a pink, juicy, full review
I definitely recommend this restaurant to anyone wanting to experience great food and drinks. The staff are attentive and know how to create a great experience. My friend and I went to NY to visit and on our last day, before leaving we tried to eat somewhere for lunch. We walked to 3 places that wouldn't take us and as we thought of giving up. One of the managers took notice and stopped us and invited us in. By the grace of god the place was better than where we would have full review

This place was amazing. From the food to the service, I’m so happy I brought my girlfriend here. The lamb chops were cooked perfectly to our liking and the lobster pasta was so delicious! Don’t even get me started on the raw oysters. We have oysters at every place we go to, and these were by far, the best. The host saw how happy we were and gave us shots to celebrate us! Amazing experience overall and we are looking forward to coming back!

More Reviews(101)


Monday 11AM - 11PM
Tuesday 11AM - 11PM
Wednesday 11AM - 11PM
Thursday 11AM - 11PM
Friday 11AM - 12AM
Saturday 11AM - 12AM
Sunday 11AM - 11PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.