Quality Italian

57 W 57th St, New York
(212) 390-1111

Recent Reviews


We had several friends recommend Quality Italian before our trip. It was our last day in town and I was able to get a lunch reservation. This is a very nice restaurant. The staff was welcoming. Our waiter was great and took the time to help us pick out our perfect meal. They are obviously known for the Chicken Parm Pizza and it is definitely a must have! My daughter got the Potato and Robiola Gnocchi. She said it was the best dish she's ever had. She's still talking about it 2 weeks later! For dessert, I highly recommend the Ferrero Rocher Gelato and Tiramisu Luci. Both were top notch! Without question, this will be a stop for us on future visits!


Amazing food! It was very loud but it was to be expected. Expensive so be prepared.. would definitely go back!


Best calamari of my life! Bread so fresh and warm. Spicy lobster rigatoni 😋


Always great food. Get ready for a very energetic environment. At times, pace was too fast and noise level not conducive for a conversation. Service is outstanding!

Joe Krause

Excellent restaurant. My steak was perfection and they have probably the best french fries I’ve ever had. All of our food was delicious from start to finish.


This is always a great spot for Italian dishes. I’ll go back.


The restaurant was packed at 6:30 PM on a Tuesday -- some very large parties which made the space cramped and very loud. Perhaps the music can get turned off, or at least down, when it's that loud. Truly impossible to talk with my dinner partner above the din. Also, we ordered 3 things: little gem caesar, sautéed mushrooms and Tuscan fries and they were all fairly spicy. My recommendation would be to prepare some dishes without all that heat - my mouth needed a break!

OpenTable Diner

Quality Italian was very good quality.


Nice place for pre/ theatre!

OpenTable Diner

Always an excellent choice

OpenTable Diner

Very good food, very loud not conducive if you’re looking for a nice place to sit and talk. But good NYC vibe. Reservations highly encouraged.


Very positive experience. Been a number of times...

OpenTable Diner

Manager was not nice. Did not give us the marathon special even though we had proof one of the diners had run the marathon.


What an amazing meal. The filet mignon was to die for…make sure to add the truffle butter. Appetizers were great and our waiter was wonderful. Really delicious meal!

OpenTable Diner

It was great.

Load More