Sagaponack in Flatiron District

4 W 22nd St, New York
(212) 229-2226

Recent Reviews

Emily Lin

Really delicious seafood. Great for oyster lovers. Recommend getting the scallops.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Marzouki

My server Alex from Louisiana gave me the southern hospitality professional polite attentive service that we used to have back in the day. He is very passionate about the food & what the place has to offer! I miss that as restaurants nowadays have thoughtless waiters & servers. I actually got a dozen & a half of oysters coz the various condiments are delight! $2 best quality Wellfleet oysters are a bargain & a deal not to be missed. My fried fish fillet Sammy was scrumptious. Dig the vibe, def recommend. Will be back for more happy hour oysters for sure ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mira Ciganek

Delicious and unique menu - a mix of Mediterranean and Asian flavors. We tried a bunch of small plates, our favorites were the salmon tartar, oysters and ironically the chicken bites. Plus their lychee cocktail and thai milk tea cake were incredible. Good deal during happy hour, will definitely be coming back!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

MJ Johnson

It is one of our favorite places to eat in New York. We always eat here when in NYC. Delicious food and great service. The owner is awesome!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Parmesan Fries, Risotto, Hanger Steak, Seafood Paella, Coconut Squash Soup

Wenxin L.

Awesome experience! We went for the restaurant week menu and it didn't disappoint. Every dish was so well prepared, and tasted delicious. I had the fish dish that came in a broth, it was so special and I've barely ever had fish presented like that from a restaurant, so I was surprised. The matcha panna cotta was to die for, I loved it so much that I went home and tried to replicate the panna cotta, so good. Service was amazing as well, my boyfriend is from east hamptons so he asked where the restaurant name came from as it's a town in the hamptons. The owner came and talked to us and we really appreciated that along with the great experience!

Dewitt Thornton

We highly recommend this restaurant. Great location in the flatiron district of New York. The seafood was very fresh and deliciously prepared. The atmosphere was pleasant and the owner was extremely friendly and the waitress staff was also very kind. We are from out of town and would definitely visit this restaurant again when we return!!!Wheelchair accessibility: Easy to access from the sidewalk.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Raw Oysters Half Dozen, Parmesan Fries

Frank Samuel

I love this place! My campus is close by so I come by for lunch and more often dinners. The bartenders are suuuper friendly and knowledgeable. The owner is always very friendly and passionate about the place and would answer any questions you have about the food. Definitely come by for drinks and food!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Raw Oysters Half Dozen, Parmesan Fries, Salmon Crudo, Fluke Tartare DF, Roasted, Thai Milk Cake

Andrew G.

Enjoy the bounties of the ocean here with some great oysters and some delicate and tasty scallops! Came here for a quiet dinner with some relatives, and when we called ahead and asked for the quietest table, they certainly delivered. The service here was really great. Our server was super friendly and everything from drinks to dessert was super timely. I started with the yuzu surprise, and I really, really liked this drink. It was tangy and fresh, really great citrus notes to highlight the seafood. The raw bar has some really, really great oysters. Fresh, sweet and a bit salty, really enjoyed some west coast bivalves. The table got the roasted quad so we could try every combo. The brown butter and the gochujang butter roasted oysters were entirely worth coming back for. The brown butter bite was the bite of the night - I could've had an entire entree of just these perfectly baked and buttered oysters. The dayboat scallops were absolutely delicious. Perfectly cooked, sweet and tender scallops paired well with polenta and oyster mushrooms. The polenta could've been a touch thicker and a little more seasoning, but those scallops were a dream. Very cool place in Flatiron that is great for out of town guests, a business dinner or a nice date with a great happy hour!

Jinny C.

Came for a work lunch and had a good time thanks to the friendly and attentive service. We got Brussels sprouts and Parmesan fries for the table which were easy crowd pleasers. I ordered the lobster rolls which were good, but smaller than I expected. Overall, the restaurant has a great ambiance and you're in for an enjoyable meal, but the food is short of being memorable.

Jasmine C.

The food and service here is always incredible. The garlic shrimp and the Brussels sprouts are amazing. My favorite section is the small bites. The drinks always hit on the first glass!

Salina X.

Fav restaurant, everything was tasty from the oysters to the fluke tartare to the pasta to the thai cake at the end. So yummy I could cry. I don't even like pasta and I loved the pasta from this place. Fluke tartare was unforgettable as well as the Thai cake.

Andrea

A perfect RW lunch--wonderful garlicky gambas to start, then spicy mussels--all with lots of bread for dipping. Will definitely be back to try the lobster roll.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kathleen Z.

Came during restaurant week. Started with a dozen oysters, which were super fresh - the mignonette was fabulous! We had the shrimp Al Ajillo which was a wonderfully soft yet flavorful garlic lemon broth- yum! We also had the tuna crudo which was served at a perfect temperature. Flavors were good and chips were awesome. My daughter had the Shoyu salmon. I don't like cooked salmon but I took one bite and would actually eat the entire dish as the flavors were perfectly balanced. I had the Miso Hake, which was prepared perfectly. The charred leeks offered a smoke essence that was a great counterpoint to the luxurious hake. Desserts included matcha panna cotta and a Thai milk cake and both were delicious! Staff was super nice with just the right amount of attention- we wanted for nothing as staff came just we needed. DEFINITELY recommend!

Erin McNabb

Have been here 5+ times and will continue to come-I bring everyone here. Easily one of my favorite restaurants in all of NYC. Excellent service no matter the day/time and fun drink variations as well as food.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Oysters on the Half Shell, Parmesan Fries, Thai Milk Cake, Coconut Squash Soup

Kevin Xu

Happy hour and restaurant week 2024 lunch menus were both top notch. Great flavors and beautiful space too.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More

Sagaponack in Flatiron District

4 W 22nd St, New York, NY 10010
(212) 229-2226