Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop
$$ • Sandwich Shops, Burgers, VegetarianAbout Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop
Customers' Favorites
Sándwich de Pastrami
Eggs Cheese and Ham
Pastrami Reuben
Matzo Ball Soup
Pastrami on Rye
Chopped Liver
Hot Pastrami
Free Pickles
French Fries
Turkey Club
Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop Reviews
272 ratings
Share your opinion about Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop
Arrived around 12:30 and was seated immediately in the bar. Delicious pastrami delight. Not too heavy compared to other greasy pastrami sandwiches. Really liked how the pickle was really sour. Sadly they didn’t have the house fries that day.
Love Eisenberg’s Sandwich Shop! I come here often whenever I visit New York, and it’s always a pleasant experience. In my opinion, it’s a great alternative to Katz’s. I highly recommend either their famous Reuben or tuna melt. You won’t be disappointed!
There's a reason why they've been open for 98 years. Best pastrami ever! Best Reuben ever! A wonderfully home styled reminiscent Knish!
Hours
| Monday | 8AM - 8PM |
| Tuesday | 8AM - 8PM |
| Wednesday | 8AM - 8PM |
| Thursday | 8AM - 8PM |
| Friday | 8AM - 8PM |
| Saturday | 9AM - 8PM |
| Sunday | 9AM - 8PM |
Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop is a beloved NYC institution that offers a traditional Jewish diner atmosphere. The menu features a variety of classic sandwiches, including the Lil Shonda, Chopped Liver with Beef, and Reuben, which boasts deliciously toasted and fatty bread. The pastrami is sliced thick and melts in your mouth. The food is outstanding, and the team provides brilliant service, treating customers with kindness and welcome. Prices may be a bit higher due to its Manhattan location, with options like the Broccoli Reuben and tuna melt. While some dishes may feel pricey, the quality and flavor make it worth the visit. The venue has a great atmosphere, with options for takeout, bar seating, or table service. It is a tiny space that can get packed during lunchtime, especially on Fridays. When there are no seats available, customers stand by the wall and wait for someone to leave. Eisenberg's is just 2 minutes away from Madison Square Park, making it a great choice for those looking to experience a classic NYC sandwich shop.