50 Best Sandwich Shops in New York

“Located in SoHo, Egg Shop is a cozy restaurant perfect for brunch with friends. The menu offers delicious options like Chai French Toast and Smoked Salmon Benedict. The Turkish eggs are a must-try, but make sure to order extra for lunch. The trendy spot might have limited seating, so reservations are recommended. The service is attentive, and the atmosphere is welcoming. Whether you're a fan of protein-packed dishes or simply looking for a tasty meal, Egg Shop is a great choice for a satisfying and enjoyable dining experience.“

“Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop is a beloved NYC institution that offers a traditional Jewish diner atmosphere. The menu features a variety of classic sandwiches, including the Lil Shonda, Chopped Liver with Beef, and Rouben, which boasts deliciously toasted and fatty bread. The pastrami is sliced thick and melts in your mouth. While prices may be a bit higher due to its Manhattan location, the quality and flavor of the dishes make it worth the visit. With good service and options for takeout, bar seating, or table service, Eisenberg's is a great choice for those looking to experience a classic NYC sandwich shop.“

“Tucked in FiDi, Best Sicily Bottega offers a taste of Sicily with a welcoming ambiance and friendly staff. Try their unique olive cake with orange or take home a Palermo sandwich. The cannoli, directly imported from Italy, are excellent. With more dishes like arancini to try, this spot brings a slice of Sicily to NYC.“

“All'antico Vinaio is a restaurant known for its satisfying and fresh sandwiches, with top-tier ingredients and generous portions. Popular choices include La District, Venice Beach, and La Favolosa. The sandwiches are reminiscent of those found in Rome. Some may find the prices high, but the quality of the food keeps customers coming back. However, opinions on the strength of certain flavors, like eggplant and spice, may vary.“

“Faicco’s Italian Specialties is an iconic Italian deli in Manhattan, known for its perfect sandwiches and friendly staff. Customers can enjoy fresh ingredients and generous portions, with a variety of groceries to explore. The store offers a range of Italian delicacies, including sausages and aranchini, all served with impeccable service. A must-visit for those craving authentic Italian flavors in a welcoming atmosphere.“

“Dark Side of the Moo Burgers, Sandwiches & Beer is a small, hip, and fun restaurant that serves delicious burgers, sandwiches, and sides. The restaurant is known for its signature burgers, including the Aporkalypse burger, and its tasty sides like chili fries, truffle fries, and moo fries. The bison burger and alligator sausage sandwich are also highly recommended. Customers praise the high-quality ingredients, fresh flavors, and excellent service, making this a must-stop for burger lovers in the area.“

“Joey Roses is a laid-back sandwich shop with delicious sandwiches and cocktails at affordable prices. The friendly staff and comfortable seating area with a projector screen create a welcoming atmosphere. Fans of Joe's podcasts will enjoy the Joe stories shared by the bartender/server.“

“Xe Máy Sandwich Shop offers a unique dining experience with a wide range of banh mi options. The shop serves delicious and filling sandwiches with generous portions of meats, pickled veggies, and sriracha. The bread is perfectly crispy and chewy, and the service is top-notch. The staff is accommodating, handling dietary restrictions with care, including dairy allergies. The shop also offers vegetarian options, clearly labeled, and kid-friendly takeaway options. With its incredible value for money, Xe Máy Sandwich Shop is a must-visit for a tasty and satisfying meal.“

“Pastrami Queen is a renowned restaurant that serves exceptional pastrami, often compared to the quality of Katz's Delicatessen. The meat is cooked to perfection, resulting in a tender and juicy texture with a delightful contrast of flavors from the spices and gherkins. The menu also offers a diverse selection of side dishes, such as garlic fries, coleslaw, and gravy, all of which are described as delicious. The small but cozy atmosphere and friendly staff contribute to the overall dining experience, making Pastrami Queen a true paradise for lovers of high-quality pastrami and a must-visit destination for foodies.“

“Regina's Grocery - Mulberry is a cozy and creatively decorated Italian sandwich spot in Nolita. The food is flavorful, with ingredients that complement each other well. Customers can enjoy a variety of sandwiches, including the popular tomato mozzarella and Italian tuna with arugula and peppers. The staff is attentive, and the prices, while on the higher end, are reasonable for the quality of the food.“

“Panineria NYC offers quality meats and ingredients in their dishes. Customers highly recommend the peppe, white sangria, cannelloni pasta, and pesto panini. The portions are generous, and the food is described as absolutely delicious. The outdoor seating is a nice touch for a quick meal. The service is fast and friendly, making it a must-visit spot for incredible food.“

“Alidoro is a neighborhood Italian sandwich shop known for its unique charm and humor. It offers quality ingredients and large portions, with options like the Daniela and Pinocchio sandwiches. The service is efficient, and portions are generous enough to possibly split one sandwich into two meals. While the Italian sandwiches are tasty, some may find them to be not as impactful as those from Bensonhurst. The prices are on the higher side, and the prosciutto and soppressata combination can be quite salty. The roasted red peppers and fig spread on semolina bread, however, are highlights of the meal.“

“Olive's is a cozy spot with a variety of options. The breakfast sandwich, priced around $12, received mixed reviews, with some finding it pricey for the taste. However, the hot apple cider is a standout, with one reviewer calling it "incredible tasting." Vegetarians will find plenty of non-meat options to choose from. Note that the restaurant has limited space, making it less kid-friendly, but still accommodating for a single child.“

“TAP NYC | 100% Gluten-Free Sandwiches & Açaí Bowls | Upper West Side offers a delightful dining experience for those seeking gluten-free options. The restaurant's tapioca wraps are praised for being sturdy and tasty, with customers enjoying the tomato mozzarella and spicy tuna wraps, as well as the Brazilian cheese bread. The menu also features refreshing açaí bowls and a flavorful chicken sandwich. The staff is described as friendly and patient, and the indoor seating is spacious and modern. While the limited seating and lack of a bathroom are noted, the overall consensus is that TAP provides a high-quality, gluten-free dining experience with quick service and delicious menu items.“

“Smartwich is a hidden gem in a bakery, serving high-quality sandwiches that are large on flavor. The bread is exceptional, and the chef takes pride in using fresh and premium ingredients. The menu features unique options like the octopus sandwich, which is a refreshing and flavorful twist on seafood. Chef Michael is passionate about his craft and is always happy to make specials and recommendations. The bakery also offers delicious treats like Portuguese Pastel de Nata. With its commitment to using fresh and high-quality ingredients, Smartwich is a must-visit for sandwich lovers seeking a premium dining experience.“

“Carnegie John's is an affordable and friendly food cart offering delicious, made-to-order sandwiches and platters. The gyro, shish kebab, and chicken breast are standout menu items, with the chicken being fresh, juicy, and perfectly charred, complemented by a tasty white yogurt sauce. Located conveniently near Carnegie Hall, this iconic cart provides a quick and satisfying meal.“

“Shamas Deli offers the best sandwiches in NYC with flavorful, meaty options. Despite limited choices, the staff ensures a great experience. The small space doesn't hinder the top-notch service. Known for their juicy sandwiches, this spot is highly recommended for its quality, friendliness, and reasonable prices. Perfect for both adults and kids.“

“Bite, a cozy and inexpensive restaurant, offers a variety of delicious options, including abundant vegan and vegetarian choices. Customers praise the excellent service, friendly staff, and reasonable prices. The menu features favorites like vegan schnitzel, vegetable lentil soup, and a fried fish sandwich with za'atar fries. With a welcoming atmosphere and a wide range of dietary-friendly options, Bite is a great choice for a quick and tasty meal.“

“TAP NYC in Midtown East offers amazing, 100% gluten-free sandwiches and açaí bowls. The restaurant is highly recommended for those with celiac disease or gluten allergies. The friendly staff provides excellent service, making every visit a delightful experience. Fresh ingredients and fantastic flavors make the meals satisfying, especially the spicy cheese bread. The cozy and inviting atmosphere adds to the overall positive experience, perfect for starting the day right. It's a good choice for those looking for gluten-free options in the city.“

“Subway, known for its delicious sandwiches, is a popular choice for many. The crew, particularly during nighttime shifts under the leadership of Moe, is commended for their great customer service and friendly demeanor. The store is consistently clean, with fresh veggies and stocked fridges. Moe is praised for his popularity and exceptional service, making it a standout Subway location in New York City. A favorite order includes a 6-inch steak sandwich, along with coffee or cookies for a satisfying meal.“

“Subway restaurant has a friendly employee named Nuru who provides excellent customer service, quickly preparing sandwiches to customers' preferences with a professional and high-energy approach. This Subway location is recommended for Nuru's attentive service and proper greetings, making customers feel valued.“

“Wolfnights - The Gourmet Wrap is a clean establishment with friendly staff, offering a variety of gourmet wraps made with healthy ingredients and freshly made dough. The menu includes options for meat lovers, vegetarians, and kids. The wraps are filling and reasonably priced, with highlights like The Beast Wrap featuring marinated steak, olives, and red chili mayo on a turmeric dough tortilla. The Carnivore Delight Wrap is another popular option with a unique date and pumpkin seed dough. While seating is limited, the aroma of freshly cooked dough is a highlight, and the sauces, including spicy and chipotle mayo, add an extra layer of flavor. This convenient and delicious spot is perfect for a quick meal on the go or a sit-down experience.“

“Sandwell is a fantastic restaurant serving fresh and delicious food. Their catering services are also impressive, with dishes like Mac and Cheese, flavorful sandwiches, and chicken pesto sandwich being a hit. They offer a kid-friendly atmosphere with a ramp entrance, wide open space, and accommodating staff. The Sandy Special breakfast sandwich is a favorite, and outdoor seating is available. Enjoy great food at the right price!“

“Wrap-N-Run Grill offers amazing food and shakes in a cozy, fast-paced environment. The service is excellent, with friendly and communicative staff. The restaurant provides unbeatable value for money, with generous portions. The welcoming atmosphere is ideal for families, with accommodating staff willing to accommodate special requests. Overall, it's a hidden gem that's worth trying.“

“Wolfnights - The Gourmet Wrap is a unique eatery offering a wide range of menu options that can be overwhelming, but in a good way. Their menu boasts creative dishes like the "Brother's Grimm Bowl" featuring grilled chicken, pickled shiitake mushrooms, and chipotle aioli. The food is fresh, flavorful, and surprisingly works well together. The restaurant is perfect for a quick grab, with super fast pickup options and a bit of seating available. The staff is nice, and the food is healthy and delicious, making it a highly recommended spot. Although it's a bit pricey, the large portions make it worth the cost. Note that the seating area is small, so be respectful of the two workers and clean up after yourself.“

“Toasties 43 is a great place to order food online, offering a convenient service for those in a rush. The restaurant provides quality food, with fresh ingredients and a friendly environment. With multilingual staff and ample seating, it's a great spot for lunch or dinner. Their sandwiches and rice bowls are delicious, and prices are low with generous portions.“

“The Picnic Basket serves high-quality, healthy, and satisfying meals, including fabulous sandwiches like the grilled Halloumi, made with fresh ingredients. This cozy lunch spot offers great sides and a friendly, helpful staff, who are enthusiastic about recommending specials like their delicious lentil soup. Perfect for a quick, tasty meal to-go or to enjoy in their small dining area.“

“Toasties is a charming spot perfect for an authentic dining experience. Their breakfast is simply delicious, and the cheesesteak is incredible. It's a nice place for a quick lunch with a lot of food choices at reasonable prices. The sandwiches are fresh and made to cater to everyone's taste. Be sure to avoid peak times for a more relaxed dining experience.“

“Croquant Pressed Paninis is a hidden gem on Fulton Street, serving tasty and clean paninis. The menu offers a range of options, including Roast Beef, Hangar Steak, and Cubano #2, all of which are delicious. The restaurant has a cozy, old-school vibe and offers pleasant and quick service at a reasonable price.“

“The Hungry Hero is a hidden gem in the neighborhood, offering fresh ingredients and delicious sandwiches. The pastrami and cheese with Russian dressing is huge and tasty, perfect for sharing. The chicken cutlets and chicken parmigiana hero are must-tries, with excellent quality and great taste. While the whole wheat bread could be better, the overall experience at The Hungry Hero is satisfying. Remember to go hungry and enjoy!“

“Cappone's Italian Sandwich Shop and Salumeria in Manhattan is a top-notch deli with fresh bread and authentic Italian ingredients. The Altar Boy sandwich is a standout, and the Cappone is a must-try with its flavorful mix of meats and cheeses. Established in 1969, this cozy spot offers a welcoming atmosphere with a few tables and a counter. Don't miss out on their daily specials like the Aldo sandwich or the delicious white lasagna. A gem not to be missed for Italian food lovers.“

“Olympia Star Deli and Juice is a delightful deli and juice bar offering excellent service and a wide variety of food options. Customers can enjoy well-seasoned meals, such as the turkey bacon egg and cheese on a roll, as well as bagels, sausage egg and cheese, sandwiches, and breakfast platters. The staff is incredibly friendly and accommodating of dietary needs. The spot is perfect for starting the day with a nutritious smoothie, coffee, or tea.“

“Lil' Frankie's Grocery offers a charming atmosphere with excellent sandwiches and attentive service. The sandwiches are well-priced and well-portioned, with standout options like the chicken parm and the Ricky, a unique broccoli rabe and sausage sandwich on soft semolina bread. Another must-try is "The Fran," an Italian spin on the classic bacon, egg, and cheese, featuring eggs, crispy guanciale, fontina cheese, and arugula on a ciabatta roll. The quality of ingredients is notable, and the front of house staff and chef are both hospitable and friendly, often going the extra mile for their customers. The deli space upfront is where the sandwiches are made, and there's a large communal table for seating. In the evening, the menu shifts to focus on pizzas, and the narrow space also offers Italian groceries like olive oils, tomato sauces, and pastas. With quick and friendly service, Lil' Frankie's Grocery is a delightful spot for both a daytime sandwich and a late-night pizza slice.“

“Pier Market Place offers great breakfast options, sandwiches, and perfectly cooked eggs. The friendly staff provides excellent service, with coffee that impresses even picky drinkers. It's a popular spot among locals and visitors alike, providing a pleasant dining experience at reasonable prices.“

“Montagu's Gusto is a cozy restaurant with limited seating, offering excellent food and service. The Godmother chicken cutlet hero and George's style sandwich are popular choices, with fresh, high-quality ingredients. The C2 Special, featuring chicken cutlet and avocado on focaccia with chipotle mayo, is another delicious option. The restaurant is suitable for take-out or eating in, though parking can be challenging. Additionally, they offer a build-your-own sandwich option, with the skirt steak sandwich recommended for a future visit.“

“d Elici is a hidden gem in the Financial District, offering a wide selection of sandwiches, bagels, and breakfast items at reasonable prices. The Italian sandwich is a work of art, while the Tomato Bisque Soup is described as life-giving. The service is speedy, attentive, and friendly, creating a delightful atmosphere. Whether you're in for a quick bite or a leisurely meal, this breakfast spot is highly recommended for a delicious and satisfying experience.“

“Jersey Mike's Subs is a reliable spot for a quick and satisfying meal. The staff at this location take great care in preparing orders, especially for customers with dietary restrictions. They demonstrate excellent teamwork, attention to detail, and kindness. The team is efficient, getting orders out quickly without sacrificing accuracy. The customer service is top-notch, with staff members like the general manager Niña going above and beyond to accommodate special requests and food allergies. Overall, Jersey Mike's Subs is a great choice for a hassle-free meal that's made with care.“

“Le Petit Parisien is a charming French-inspired sandwich and coffee shop offering a variety of delicious baguette sandwiches and fresh juices. The staff is friendly and welcoming. Their daily specials, such as the chicken sandwich with blue cheese and mustard, are a highlight. They also offer vegetarian options like the Jeanne D'Arc Sandwich, which is vegan-friendly. The baguettes have a beautiful crust and a perfectly balanced flavor. Additionally, they serve good coffee and offer a variety of sandwiches, including the Gainsbourg, which can be customized with additional toppings and sides.“

“Barney Brown is a take-out restaurant that offers a convenient and customizable sandwich experience. Customers can order on a device and select their preferred bread, toppings, and portion sizes. The food is consistently fresh and delicious, with a gluten-free bread option available. The staff is friendly and attentive, making it a welcoming environment, especially for those facing health challenges.“

“Madman Bakery offers friendly staff and the best coffee in the neighborhood. The baked goods are good but a bit overpriced compared to other bakeries in the area. Customers enjoy the cozy atmosphere and delicious food options like the gonzola sandwich and potato pizza.“

“Sandwicherie of New York is a gem in the heart of the city. The service is exceptional, with friendly staff who cater to your every need. The food is fresh and homemade, with a vast array of options to choose from. From breakfast to lunch and beyond, Sandwicherie of New York has something for everyone. Enjoy made-to-order sandwiches, salads, and macaroni dishes, all made with fresh ingredients. The menu is diverse, with options to suit every taste. The upstairs seating area provides additional space for diners, and the bathrooms are surprisingly clean. Overall, Sandwicherie of New York is a must-visit destination, with a reputation for excellent food and service.“

“Delmonico is a great place to experience the diverse flavors and cultures of New York City. The restaurant offers a delicious breakfast menu, perfect for fueling up before a day of exploring the city's attractions. While the dinner hours may have recently changed, the lunch and daytime offerings are still a hit, with a wide selection of sandwiches and snacks at reasonable prices for the area. The restaurant's location in midtown Manhattan makes it a convenient option, though parking can be a challenge. Delmonico may not be the most kid-friendly or wheelchair-accessible establishment, but it provides a satisfying dining experience for those seeking a taste of the city's vibrant culinary scene.“

“Absolutely amazing experience, always come here, very nice people, very quick service and food is always fresh and delicious, they make best vegetarian pizza ?. Give it a try ?. Best of all is they have prayer room

Vegetarian options: Vegetarian pizza ?. And sandwiches“

“Sandwich House is a lunch spot that offers high-quality food at reasonable prices. Their sandwiches are a customer favorite, made with delicious bread and fresh ingredients. The menu also includes pastas, soups, and salads. The service is friendly and the atmosphere is welcoming. In addition to their tasty food, they also offer clean facilities. This humble restaurant is a great option for those seeking a homemade meal in the area.“

“Diso's Sandwich is a popular food truck serving a variety of Italian-style sandwiches. Their dishes are known for being generously portioned and affordable. The Big Pauly sandwich features chicken cutlet Parmigiano, while other popular options include Sallyz Ballz and Fat Pete. With cash-only transactions, customers can enjoy a filling meal at a competitive price.“

“LAZZARO BOWLS offers fresh and healthy options, perfect for a satisfying start to the day. The Caribbean Sweet acai bowl with granola, pineapple, coconut, mango, and peanut butter is a highlight. Portion sizes are massive, and the smoothies, like the peanut butter, strawberry, and banana combo, are delicious and reasonably priced.“

“Pickler Sandwich Shop offers delicious, high-quality sandwiches with a cozy, small-town atmosphere. Located in NYC, it's a perfect spot for a quick and satisfying lunch. Their menu includes the Rachel sandwich, a lighter alternative to the Reuben, and a popular breakfast sandwich with scrambled eggs, pepper jack cheese, tomato, avocado, and chipotle mayo on fresh-baked sourdough. Don't miss their tuna melt and other deli sandwiches. With friendly service and a selection of good pickles, Pickler Sandwich Shop is a hidden gem worth supporting.“

“Lenwich is a reliable spot for a fresh and flavorful meal. With top-notch service, the staff is always friendly and attentive. The menu offers unique combinations to keep things interesting, and the food is always of high quality. From sandwiches to salads and breakfast items, there's something for everyone. The restaurant is clean and has plenty of seating. While there may be some room for improvement in organization, the overall experience is consistently positive. Whether dining in or taking out, Lenwich is a great choice for a satisfying meal.“

“Lenwich is a restaurant known for its fresh ingredients, sweet staff, and cool atmosphere. They offer a variety of sandwiches, salads, and fries that are highly praised by customers. The breakfast sandwich is a popular choice, and their classic Lenwich and chicken Caesar wrap are particularly delicious. The restaurant has a clean establishment and offers a convenient online ordering option for coffee. Although some customers find the prices slightly high, they believe the portion and fresh toppings make it worthwhile.“