50 Best Sandwich Shops in Brooklyn

“If you're looking for an authentic Brooklyn sandwich experience, make the trip to Defonte's Sandwich Shop. The sandwiches are absolutely massive, loaded with fresh ingredients, and packed with flavor. Every bite tastes like a piece of old-school New York. The fried eggplant and hot salad are incredible, and it's easy to see why this place has been a neighborhood institution for generations. The staff is friendly, the service is fast, and the no-frills atmosphere just adds to the charm. Whether you're a local or visiting from out of town, this is the kind of place you'll be thinking about long after the sandwich is gone. One of the best sandwiches I've ever had. We'll definitely be back!“

“Ok, maybe I shouldn’t have picked marathon Sunday to finally hit up Frankel’s—it was packed! But what a great spot. I love their creative breakfast sandwich options, and the vibe was pure NYC energy. I got the pastrami, egg, and cheese on a challah bun, and it was exceptional. Perfectly balanced, rich, and just messy enough in the best way. 10 out of 10. I’ll definitely be back.“

“Smothered Mexican influenced sandwiches?! I mean.. it’s a yes from me. The bread is a wonderful French baguette that comes from another great spot in Williamsburg but you’ll have to ask them for their source I won’t spill it here. You can choose between 3 meats you want on your sandwich we picked chicken and spill the sandwich cause we also order nachos which were also great. I would give this place a visit I’ve never seen/had anything like it and it was very satisfying.“

“The BEST sandwich in NYC. Thank you for bringing fresh and homemade foods to Brooklyn.“

“This place ended up being such a pleasant surprise. The menu had a really nice variety without feeling overwhelming — plenty of different meat cuts, cheeses, salads, sandwiches, and lighter options, so it felt easy to find something that matched whatever mood you’re in.

We started with the French onion soup, and it was honestly one of the better versions I’ve had in a while. The cheese on top was perfectly melted and flavorful without becoming too heavy, and the balance between the broth and onions was done really well. A lot of places overload the onions to the point where the soup loses its depth, but this one kept everything balanced and comforting.

We also ordered a panini-style baguette sandwich, which was fresh, crisp, and packed with flavor. The bread had a great texture, and the mix of vegetables paired really nicely with the vinaigrette and mustard dipping sauces. The sauces actually stood out because they added flavor without overpowering the sandwich itself.

The atmosphere made the whole experience even better. The bright interior, cozy setup, and French snacks lining the walls gave the restaurant a charming café feel that felt both casual and inviting. It had personality without trying too hard to be trendy.

Another highlight was the staff. Everyone was incredibly polite, patient, and genuinely helpful when it came to recommendations. Even with the place staying busy, the food came out surprisingly fast, which made the experience feel smooth from start to finish.

And the Nutella crepe absolutely lived up to expectations. They definitely didn’t hold back on the filling, and it made for a really satisfying dessert to end the meal.

The only small downside is that indoor seating is limited, so I could see it becoming crowded during peak hours. Still, between the quality of the food, the welcoming atmosphere, and the friendly service, it’s definitely a spot worth returning to.“

“A local gem! They have the best Chicken Schnitzel in NYC! also one of the best pastrami in NYC!! Great sandwiches, fresh ingredients, and everything was delicious. Alyana was incredibly friendly, welcoming, and attentive and also very informative about the menu. Excellent service and a great overall experience. Will keep coming back!“

“Literally just got my sandwich minutes ago and I'm only half way through it but I couldn't wait to write this review lol. The bread is so fricking fresh, the amount of meats, cheeses and toppings was perfect and the customer service is top tier. What a great sandwich! I have absolutely found my new favorite spot!!“

“food was good. Checkout and payment were very questionable. Cash ONLY! NO RECEIPT. Unknown amount charged and paid. MAKE SURE YOU CHECK THE AMOUNT BEFORE PAYING WITH YOUR CASH !!“

“very warm and welcoming staff, DELICIOUS pizza and cocktails! my friends and i were seeing theatre in the area and were on a major time constraint (30 minutes to spare) and i told them i totally understood if they couldnt accomodate us but they really made it work even though they really did not have to. the espresso martini is ridiculously good as well“

“I read the service loan not because the service staff was an issue, but I am sick and tired of being penalized for using cash. I didn’t realize I went to the counter. I made my order selected everything and then I was told if I need to pay cash. I need to go to a kiosk. Annoying because now I have to go through all these menus to figure out what I just ordered feed cash into machine wait for that to come out. Totally unnecessary step and unfortunately something that would make me not want to stop here because they added a layer of complexity. It wasn’t necessary. Now I’m sure by the tone of my review that you could probably tell how old I am but that’s fine by me. I like walking into an establishment explaining what I want paying cash and walking out. It’s that simple but yet this isn’t. That being said, the food is fabulous so if the kiosk doesn’t bother you and you never pay cash then so be it.“

“the roast beef sandwiches are out of this world yummy“

“Walked to Shelskys on a cold windy Brooklyn Friday afternoon, but when I say it was worth it....it was worth it. After about 5 min of browsing, we decided on the Tuna Salad, which is served with sliced jalapeños and a spicy shrimp paste. It's got some heat, but nothing a Mexican from Chicago cant handle! Everything you see is fresh, and you can taste it. Prices aren't cheap but sometimes you gotta treat yo self!!! 10/10!“

“Classic Brooklyn joint serving one of the best roast beef sandwiches in town! But I would have to say the western burger also packs a solid punch. You can’t go wrong with any of the items here honestly. But our go to’s are always the roast beef sandwich, western beef burger, crown fritters, chicken wings, and orangeade drink! You also have the option to put cheese on anything! If you have a young one, ask one of the cashiers for a free ballon. If happens to be your birthday, you get to spin the giant wheel for a chance to win $5-$20 prize for next time use. Also, if you spend more than $45 per order, you can get a free pizza. The inside dining area seems like it’s still stuck in the 1990s, but I’m fine with that!“

“This place is incredible. It's peak Chicago in all the best ways. An absolutely immaculate vibe with an amazing array of Chicago memorabilia, a very lively and friendly staff, and delicious food. I would live here if not for the legality of it all.“

“Great local spot built from the ground up by locals! Great ambiance (esp with new outdoor seating section), genuinely friendly service, and food is 10/10. I ate half of the Philly hero for lunch and saved half for dinner. Highly recommend adding garlic aioli. My boyfriend ate half of the Turkey and Avocado. Delicious and filling without the mess. They rewrapped our heros for us to-go. Lovely neighborhood spot right next to Public House and historic Clinton Hill/ walking distance to Fort Greene Park and Downtown Brooklyn / Citypoint.“

“Delicious Breakfast Poutine!!!“

“We got the Aji egg Sando and tonkasu sando with melted cheese on top. Highly recommended to get both to share, because egg sando is cold and the other is warmed so it’s a great combo to eat together!

When the weather is nice, make sure to get seating at backyard where is very quiet and peaceful!“

“These sandwiches are the real deal! Had a chicken cutlet hero made by Jonathan and it goes toe to toe with any sandwich shop out there. Jonathan was awesome. He was nice, professional and most importantly made an amazing sandwich! This place is a must go to and I most definitely will be going back!“

“Omg the sandwiches are great and big 20$ it’s worth every penny!!!!“

“Vegan food that makes love to your mouth! My first time having Jerked Seitan. OMG! Definitely worth getting with the avocado.“

“Excellent Sandwich!! Def check it out Over 100 to choose from“

“Great food! Had lunch catered to my business and everything was superb!! Thanks Guys!“

“My first time here, some friends and I came for trivia on one of the most bitter cold nights in January.

The place was a haven from the bitter outdoors. The food was warm and hearty, service was kind and speedy, and the atmosphere was just perfect.

Great place to take some friends for a bite and a drink or two.“

“Great food! Had lunch catered to my business and everything was superb!! Thanks Guys!“

“This is a wonderful shop with really delicious food and friendly service. I’ve ordered a lot of great sandwiches there but the 06 French Onion with roast beef is AMAZING. It may be the best sandwich I’ve ever had in my life.“

“Tasty Burgers - Great host! Thanks for the nice evenings 😊“

“sandwiches were delicious and so was the macaroni salad and the workers could not be nicer“

“This place is truly under appreciated. We walked in thinking it was just going to have basic foods. Nothing visually matches in terms of it's appearance but the food is good. Wife and I stopped mid meal to leave this review. Also the cheese has a VERY NICE pull.
Highly recommend a egg, cheese and mushrooms on a brioche bun.“

“oh my God, how have I not been here before. Iced coffee for less than two dollars and it’s so good. The barista was so sweet as well. Great vibe in there.
update. Could you guys please post your hours anywhere? On the front of the store or on Google maps.“

“The #7 CHE Si DICE is off Da Hook!! Now THIS SANDWICH is the real “HAYA DO’N”“

“Great food. Fast service.“

“My lady recovering from a cold and was craving some soup. Wanted to get something a little different than chicken noodle... explore a little we like to spice things up. Pho for her and a classic sandwich for me. Do you know you what Vietnamese ham is? Neither do I, but it set me right..try it sometime. Great service fast and sat in a nice chair while my order was ready. Great at home date night we watched Gilmore Girls never seen it but its good“

“food is delicious. chopped chicken grinder. sooooo good.“

“Delicious sandwiches and cute outside patio in the back for good weather days! Plus the owner is awesome and I love supporting good people launching great neighborhood/local businesses!“

“I’m salivating just thinking about their 🥪!!! They offer huge portions, fresh and high quality ingredients and now I’m hungry. 😋“

“I’m salivating just thinking about their 🥪!!! They offer huge portions, fresh and high quality ingredients and now I’m hungry. 😋“

“Fabulous shop and catering group! We have enjoyed several events catered by Campbell & Co. since their start up and they have always exceeded our expectations. It’s hard to say which we appreciate more, the fantastic food and cheese selection or their creative event displays. It is a pleasure to know that every detail will be attended to.“

“This place is everything 💜👍🏾“

“They make a great sandwich, but their prices are getting out of hand. It’s almost $15.00 now for a medium sub. I went to get a sandwich the other day and decided to have made on a wrap and they still charge $ 15.00. So for now I’m making my sandwiches at home. Goodbye.“

“I’m leaving this review for my free cookie.
It’s an honest review though.
Buffalo chicken sub was delicious.
Customer service was top notch, bubbly bright personalities. I loved that.

Vegetarian options: I’m not sure“

“Best tuna in Williamsburg, with lot of mayonnaise!! (not like others that are putting little mayonnaise cuz it's expensive).And sandwiches are low priced (tuna sandwich is 6.50!), not like others that are charging for a tuna sandwich 9 or even 10 dollars..“

“WOW

so I alwsys heaed about jimmy johns but never gotren to try it until today!. i got the texas roast beef sub via door dash and if i could give a huge review rating id give it 1000000/1000000 ! growing up i always had subs from a compeitor but today changed it . The texas roast beef reminds me of kprean bulogi how it was marinated and the mayo I dont always use delivery apps but this one is amazing“

“There was a misunderstanding but it was dealt with in a cordial manner. I appreciate it ??

Vegetarian options: Veggie delight without cheese toasted and avocado ?

Dietary restrictions: I chose not to have cheese or any animal by product on my sandwich ? and was accommodated.“

“Mandy helped us host a virtual event with our clients. Absolutely incredible cheeses and she was perfect at hosting everyone on zoom. We’ve done a lot of virtual sessions and this was by far the best. Mandy is beyond knowledgeable without being pretentious, and strikes the right balance of leading the event while allowing everyone else to connect and ask questions. Thank you Mandy!!!“

“Harishne Perera is super amazing! I come here a lot for many years and this is the first time I have met such a warm, helpful and detail oriented person. She just stands out. She walked me through each and every step of the process explained to me the deal of the day which was chicken sub, chips and a drink. Attaching photos guys! Make sure you go when she is there and day hi. She is very social/people oriented and genuine. I hope her superiors get to see this and she is promoted soon! Shes a gem to have on subway team.“

“First time getting coffee here and it was great. So nice to have a new shop in Dyker where the coffee isn't burnt!! Inviting atmosphere, clean, bright, and beautiful friendly people. Welcome to the neighborhood!!!“

“The baguette was amazing, but besides that the food tasted pretty bland…. I wanted to like this place more but to be frank… it’s just like other generic Asian tea spots…. Nothing on this menu really sticks out to me, yes there is Vietnamese sandwiches and dishes but it lacks any love aka proper seasoning, even the fish sauce to eat with the noodle dishes are bland. Prices were ok I guess. $2.50 for a can of Soda….“

“Came back to my husbands hometown to watch the NY GIANTS GAME, stopped here for lunch to visit with the owner ( friend we grew up with) to have a REAL HERO ON A SEEDED ITALIAN BREAD FROM BROOKLYN! MY HUSBAND WAS IN HEAVEN & SO WAS I LOL Definitely coming back when I revisit!!!!“

“Things are popular for a reason, the only complaint is that yes the lines are long and you have to seat yourself. But come on folks. This is an iconic Jewel that for me was a foodie destination of a lifetime. Maybe things have changed recently, we went a few years ago but do you really finish one of those sandwiches?“

“This might be one of the most refreshing drinks I’ve had in a while. Unlike the Dunkin’ Refreshers, this isn’t a cup full of sugar pretending to be juice. It’s light, hydrating, flavorful, and actually makes you feel good after drinking it. 10/10 💕“