The table of 8 next to us spent the dinner yelling and using foul language, ruining the dinner experience. The service was great, food taste were fair for the price
frank
First time here and will definitely be back .. white truffle was amazing and the service was impeccable
Katharine
Always love eating here. The service, food and ambiance is always perfect! Highly recommend!!
Grisel
Attentive service, excellent ambience, great food. Always visit when in NYC. A neighborhood gem Highly recommend
Maya
Fantastic food and service. Very very noisy. Had to ask them to turn the music down a bit.
Gus
Food was wonderful and the wine by the glass selection was a little pricy, but the wines were worth it. Pasta portions were smaller than I remember from prior visits, but the dishes were superb.
Katie
I actually made the reservation for my UK-based manager. He told me it was a great choice - so I'll be recommending it to others.
Diane
The experience for our 50th anniversary was beyond amazing We will return Our waiter was the best!!! Thank you for the experience!!! John and Diane
Coen
Had a great night, staff is really good. This time the pasta's were a bit bland. Vitello tonato and the artichoke salad amazing. Great wine selection
Julia Pyrina
Lovely service, amazing vitello tonnato, all we ate was great, would definitely come back. Thanks to reddit for this discovery 😅
Didn't have the best experience, dining room was open to the street even though it was muggy and loud outside. Said the restaurant week menu is no longer offered that Sunday even though someone on the phone confirm it was. Finally received this side of sad grilled veggies that's basically $1 a slice. The other food was ok, good rissoto and pasta.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
Daria Piccone
I am so bored of red sauce Italian-American food! I longed for a restaurant with interesting, delicious pasta dishes and found San Carlo. We had a salad and three different pastas, and each dish was thoughtful and balanced. Went back twice in one week for the spaghettone with anchovies. We even have a new favorite truffle pasta in the city! I no longer live here, but will make it a point to return every time I visit family. We loved it, food and service was impeccable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Oleg Vlasov
Excellent service, great food and good prices. Recommended!
P.S: By any means, I am not Italian, but the food felt like the most authentic Italian food I have tried so far in NYC.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Maria Mnatsakanova
Charming ambiance, great service and good quality food. Some of the items that we ordered were not super delicious, but I think the restaurant still deserves 5 stars, as some items were and the presentation was great. Lamb ragú was superb!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Ali Naderi
A bit generic, slightly upscale feeling Italian spot with really excellent dishes. Everything we had, from apps to entrees was truly delicious and very well made.
The table of 8 next to us spent the dinner yelling and using foul language, ruining the dinner experience. The service was great, food taste were fair for the price
First time here and will definitely be back .. white truffle was amazing and the service was impeccable
Always love eating here. The service, food and ambiance is always perfect! Highly recommend!!
Attentive service, excellent ambience, great food. Always visit when in NYC. A neighborhood gem Highly recommend
Fantastic food and service. Very very noisy. Had to ask them to turn the music down a bit.
Food was wonderful and the wine by the glass selection was a little pricy, but the wines were worth it. Pasta portions were smaller than I remember from prior visits, but the dishes were superb.
I actually made the reservation for my UK-based manager. He told me it was a great choice - so I'll be recommending it to others.
The experience for our 50th anniversary was beyond amazing We will return Our waiter was the best!!! Thank you for the experience!!! John and Diane
Had a great night, staff is really good. This time the pasta's were a bit bland. Vitello tonato and the artichoke salad amazing. Great wine selection
Lovely service, amazing vitello tonnato, all we ate was great, would definitely come back. Thanks to reddit for this discovery 😅
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Didn't have the best experience, dining room was open to the street even though it was muggy and loud outside. Said the restaurant week menu is no longer offered that Sunday even though someone on the phone confirm it was. Finally received this side of sad grilled veggies that's basically $1 a slice. The other food was ok, good rissoto and pasta.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
I am so bored of red sauce Italian-American food! I longed for a restaurant with interesting, delicious pasta dishes and found San Carlo. We had a salad and three different pastas, and each dish was thoughtful and balanced. Went back twice in one week for the spaghettone with anchovies. We even have a new favorite truffle pasta in the city! I no longer live here, but will make it a point to return every time I visit family. We loved it, food and service was impeccable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent service, great food and good prices. Recommended!
P.S: By any means, I am not Italian, but the food felt like the most authentic Italian food I have tried so far in NYC.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Charming ambiance, great service and good quality food. Some of the items that we ordered were not super delicious, but I think the restaurant still deserves 5 stars, as some items were and the presentation was great.
Lamb ragú was superb!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
A bit generic, slightly upscale feeling Italian spot with really excellent dishes. Everything we had, from apps to entrees was truly delicious and very well made.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...