Scarr's Pizza

35 Orchard St, New York
(212) 334-3481

Recent Reviews Order Online Reserve

Customers' Favorites

Sicilian Pie with Half Sausage and Onions
Sicilian and Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Pepperoni and Mushroom Pizza
Cheese and Pepperoni Pizza
Margherita Pizza Slice
Sicilian Cheese Slice
Pepperoni Jalapeño
Grandma Pizza Slice
Hot Boi Sicilian Pie
Cheese Pizza Slice

Menu

Featured items
Original Pie
Tomato sauce, cheese blend, and pecorino romano. 19 inches.
Vegan Caesar Salad
Served with cashew-based dressing.
Sicilian Pie
Tomato sauce, cheese blend, pecorino romano. 18 inches by 12 inches.
Side of Eggplant Parm
Contains eggs.
Vegan Original Pie
Tomato sauce, numu vegan cheese, and basil. Made with numu vegan cheese.
Side of Meatball Parm

Appetizers
Vegan Caesar Salad
Served with cashew-based dressing.
Side of Eggplant Parm
Contains eggs.
Side of Meatball Parm

Pizza ***TO ORDER 5 OR MORE PIES CALL 212-334-3481***
Original Pie
Tomato sauce, cheese blend, and pecorino romano. 19 inches.
Sicilian Pie
Tomato sauce, cheese blend, pecorino romano. 18 inches by 12 inches.
Hotboi Pie 🌶🍯
Beef pepperoni and jalapeños topped with Mike's Extra Hot Honey. 19 inches.
Beef Pepperoni Pie
Beef pepperoni, tomato sauce, cheese blend, and pecorino romano. 19 inches.
Margherita Pie
Tomato sauce, fresh mounceszarella, pecorino romano, and basil. 19 inches.
White Grandma Pie
Fresh mounceszarella, fresh garlic, whipped ricotta, pecorino romano, and extra virgin olive oil. 18 inches by 12 inches.
Grandma Pie
Tomato sauce, fresh mounceszarella, fresh garlic, basil, pecorino romano. 18 inches by 12 inches.
Hotboi Sicilian Pie 🌶🍯
Beef pepperoni and jalapeños topped with mike's extra hot honey. 18 inches by 12 inches.
DJ Clark Kent Sicilian Pie
Italian chicken sausage, fresh garlic, tomato sauce, cheese blend, and pecorino roman. 18 inches by 12 inches.
Sicilian Beef Pepperoni Pie
Beef pepperoni, tomato sauce, cheese blend, and pecorino romano. 18 inches by 12 inches.

Vegan Pizza
Vegan Original Pie
Tomato sauce, numu vegan cheese, and basil. Made with numu vegan cheese.
Vegan Sicilian Pie
Tomato sauce, numu vegan cheese, basil. 18 inches by 12 inches. Made with numu vegan cheese.

Soda & Water
Soda (Can)
Water
Just water. 16.9 fl ounces. Sustainably sourced spring water in a plant-based carton.

Dips
Side of Sauce
2 fl ounces side of sauce.
Side of Vegan Caesar Dressing
2 oz side of dressing.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+97 photos
Photo credit: foursquare
+96 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Overall, thought it was fine! The pizza wasn't exceptional but it was good for a late night dinner. We dined in and ordered beers and a small Hotboi. Maybe other pizzas are better? The staff were super nice and the vibe was cool!
February 2026
Busy pizza place, seating arrangement wasnt the best, not enough room to be comfortable and tables werent leveled and we were in a rough tight corner ounned againstthe other table behind us. Beyond that, service was great, food was tasty, and the beer cold and well prepared!
January 2026
I don't recall what kind of tomatoes they use for their sauce, but this is by far the best sauce I've had on pizza in NYC. The tomatoes had the right amount of sweetness and tangy. If you're with a large group a whole pie will work. Otherwise order by the slice. On Sunday night they were out of a number of types of pizzas as well as some soft drinks. Clearly it was a busy weekend for them. It's tiny and the music is loud, but it's a very fun spot and so...
January 2026

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Sam's Fried Ice Cream - 37B Orchard St
Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Ice Cream, Vegan
MJ (Manny Janeth) Café - 70 Hester St
Cafe
King Dumplings - 74 Hester St
Dumplings, Chinese, Pet Friendly, Vegetarian

Scarr's Pizza

35 Orchard St, New York, NY 10002
(212) 334-3481