Service was absolutely fine here but the food is not good. Like pre-frozen tomatoes in the ‘fresh’ chopped tomato sauce. Don’t waste your money!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Sara Doe
this has quickly become my girlfriend and I’s favorite restaurant!! We come in about 3-4 times and have always had a fantastic experience! The food is consistently delicious. The specials are the incredible! The staff is so is kind and we will be back very soon!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brittany Cella
Spaghetti Incident is the definition of a hidden gem. If you blink while walking or driving by, it's likely that you'll miss it! However, it is NOT to be missed! Super small & intimate, rustic with the exposed brick walls. I make it a point to visit whenever I happen to find myself on the Lower East Side. I've had brunch & dinner here on separate occasions, and if you happen to get a seat by the window on a breezy spring day - it's really delightful.
The pasta is made basically in front of you as they have an open area kitchen & your meal is super fresh. The burrata appetizer is wonderful, as is the flight of arancini & my go-to suggestion for your meal is Pesto di Cavolo Nero (Kale Pesto) but there really is no wrong choice on the menu - let your tastebuds be your guide! If possible, leave room for dessert & get the Budino al Caramello because it basically lives rent free in my head. Food is phenomenal, only to be outdone by their incredible & attentive staff.
They were once a cash only establishment, but after a recent visit, I learned that they are no longer cash only!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Edward Johnson
Chill Italian joint with a friendly atmosphere. The price was affordable for a dine-in restaurant and the food was delicious. A reservation is needed. Dessert is pictured below. Panna Cotta, chocolate cake and tiramisu.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rob H
Great pasta, great wine, great service. Loved the down to earth friendly vibe in the lower east side!
Magnus Hansvold
Super good food and friendly service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Taneum Bambrick
We got here with an enormous group super late. They not only got us drinks but fed us AMAZING pasta at 11:00pm. This place is delicious and everyone who works here is a literal angel. I love them.
Anna-Lisa Nguyen
A great visit to Spaghetti Incident. The servers were kind and patient while helping us decide on the menu items. I had the Tagliatelle di Porcini (which I can't see on the online menu). We sat outside, the tables were quite small for fitting our plates, water, bread, and other condiments.
Layla Navarro
I've been coming here to Spaghetti Incident for almost 7 years straight and the service is amazing, the food is so fresh, and the ambiance is very relaxing and old fashioned... it makes the whole restaurant feel like I'm back in Italy. I Love This Restaurant! And I know others will too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alexis Foster
From the moment you step inside Spaghetti Incident, you’re greeted with an atmosphere that feels as if you’ve walked into a cozy, rustic home, warm, welcoming, and far from pretentious. Over the past 10 years, this spot has remained a staple for me, not just for the amazing food, but for the genuine feeling of connection it provides. As someone who creates food videos for restaurants, I’ve been to countless places, but this one is hands-down my favorite.
I still remember when they went viral for their pasta cones all those years ago, and I’d drive all the way from New Jersey to New York City just to grab a to-go order. Sometimes, if it wasn’t too late, I’d stay and enjoy the meal in-house. That was the start of my love for this place. Since then, Spaghetti Incident has only cemented its place in my heart, it’s where my partner and I have shared countless meals, and we still make our way here together, just like we always have.
When the pandemic hit and there was a real risk of the restaurant closing, I felt devastated. It was heartbreaking to think that such a special place could be lost. But when they made it through, it gave me hope and inspired me to start a page supporting local businesses.
The food? Simply put, it's the same high-quality, comforting, and perfectly executed Italian dishes that made me fall in love with the place in the first place. Our go-to order is always the Chitarra and the Bucatini, and they never disappoint. It's hard for restaurants to maintain that level of consistency and passion, but Spaghetti Incident does so effortlessly.
This place isn’t just a restaurant; it’s a part of my story, and I’m grateful for every moment spent here. Whether you’re a first-timer or a long-time fan, Spaghetti Incident will always make you feel like you’re coming home.
Service was truly horrible. There was this young Italian waiter (who I always see smoking depressed outside when I walk by the place) who tried to start an argument with me about getting a drink. I had just paid for a wine, and was about to sit down. This place should treat their customers better.
Shame on them, people wont come if this young waiter is yelling at customers.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Bryan Pittman
Carbonara was the best I have ever had!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pasta Carbonara, Burrata, Spinach Fettuccine, Arancini Mix of 3
Kaya-Damali M.
This is honestly one of my favorites! 10 out of 10 experience every time go. I am partial to a carbonara but they have a plethora of other wonderful dishes. 🍝✨
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pasta Carbonara, Lasagna Bolognese, Polpette Della Nonna
Jack Eddings
Fantastic experience, gorgeous delicious dishes. Can’t wait to come back and try everything else!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Clayton Giovanni M.
I loved the cozy atmosphere and our server Tommy was the best example of the restaurant. He knew the menu fully and assisted us with choices. The menu was so exciting to read over. My meal was a sample of two dishes split with my companion. Both dishes had pasta that was aldente and was not to my expectations. I wish i knew so i could have asked for something else, sadly. I wish it was better to call it my favorite.
Service was absolutely fine here but the food is not good. Like pre-frozen tomatoes in the ‘fresh’ chopped tomato sauce. Don’t waste your money!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
this has quickly become my girlfriend and I’s favorite restaurant!! We come in about 3-4 times and have always had a fantastic experience! The food is consistently delicious. The specials are the incredible! The staff is so is kind and we will be back very soon!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Spaghetti Incident is the definition of a hidden gem. If you blink while walking or driving by, it's likely that you'll miss it! However, it is NOT to be missed! Super small & intimate, rustic with the exposed brick walls. I make it a point to visit whenever I happen to find myself on the Lower East Side. I've had brunch & dinner here on separate occasions, and if you happen to get a seat by the window on a breezy spring day - it's really delightful.
The pasta is made basically in front of you as they have an open area kitchen & your meal is super fresh. The burrata appetizer is wonderful, as is the flight of arancini & my go-to suggestion for your meal is Pesto di Cavolo Nero (Kale Pesto) but there really is no wrong choice on the menu - let your tastebuds be your guide! If possible, leave room for dessert & get the Budino al Caramello because it basically lives rent free in my head. Food is phenomenal, only to be outdone by their incredible & attentive staff.
They were once a cash only establishment, but after a recent visit, I learned that they are no longer cash only!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chill Italian joint with a friendly atmosphere. The price was affordable for a dine-in restaurant and the food was delicious. A reservation is needed. Dessert is pictured below. Panna Cotta, chocolate cake and tiramisu.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pasta, great wine, great service. Loved the down to earth friendly vibe in the lower east side!
Super good food and friendly service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We got here with an enormous group super late. They not only got us drinks but fed us AMAZING pasta at 11:00pm. This place is delicious and everyone who works here is a literal angel. I love them.
A great visit to Spaghetti Incident. The servers were kind and patient while helping us decide on the menu items. I had the Tagliatelle di Porcini (which I can't see on the online menu). We sat outside, the tables were quite small for fitting our plates, water, bread, and other condiments.
I've been coming here to Spaghetti Incident for almost 7 years straight and the service is amazing, the food is so fresh, and the ambiance is very relaxing and old fashioned... it makes the whole restaurant feel like I'm back in Italy. I Love This Restaurant! And I know others will too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
From the moment you step inside Spaghetti Incident, you’re greeted with an atmosphere that feels as if you’ve walked into a cozy, rustic home, warm, welcoming, and far from pretentious. Over the past 10 years, this spot has remained a staple for me, not just for the amazing food, but for the genuine feeling of connection it provides. As someone who creates food videos for restaurants, I’ve been to countless places, but this one is hands-down my favorite.
I still remember when they went viral for their pasta cones all those years ago, and I’d drive all the way from New Jersey to New York City just to grab a to-go order. Sometimes, if it wasn’t too late, I’d stay and enjoy the meal in-house. That was the start of my love for this place. Since then, Spaghetti Incident has only cemented its place in my heart, it’s where my partner and I have shared countless meals, and we still make our way here together, just like we always have.
When the pandemic hit and there was a real risk of the restaurant closing, I felt devastated. It was heartbreaking to think that such a special place could be lost. But when they made it through, it gave me hope and inspired me to start a page supporting local businesses.
The food? Simply put, it's the same high-quality, comforting, and perfectly executed Italian dishes that made me fall in love with the place in the first place. Our go-to order is always the Chitarra and the Bucatini, and they never disappoint. It's hard for restaurants to maintain that level of consistency and passion, but Spaghetti Incident does so effortlessly.
This place isn’t just a restaurant; it’s a part of my story, and I’m grateful for every moment spent here. Whether you’re a first-timer or a long-time fan, Spaghetti Incident will always make you feel like you’re coming home.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Service was truly horrible. There was this young Italian waiter (who I always see smoking depressed outside when I walk by the place) who tried to start an argument with me about getting a drink. I had just paid for a wine, and was about to sit down. This place should treat their customers better.
Shame on them, people wont come if this young waiter is yelling at customers.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Carbonara was the best I have ever had!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pasta Carbonara, Burrata, Spinach Fettuccine, Arancini Mix of 3
This is honestly one of my favorites! 10 out of 10 experience every time go. I am partial to a carbonara but they have a plethora of other wonderful dishes. 🍝✨
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pasta Carbonara, Lasagna Bolognese, Polpette Della Nonna
Fantastic experience, gorgeous delicious dishes. Can’t wait to come back and try everything else!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I loved the cozy atmosphere and our server Tommy was the best example of the restaurant. He knew the menu fully and assisted us with choices. The menu was so exciting to read over. My meal was a sample of two dishes split with my companion. Both dishes had pasta that was aldente and was not to my expectations. I wish i knew so i could have asked for something else, sadly. I wish it was better to call it my favorite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Loading...