Thyme & Tonic

474 Columbus Ave, New York
(718) 344-4789

Recent Reviews

Sort by
janet hudson hagan

Literally no way to cancel your reservation on Tock. If you call them, you get a recording. No way to leave a message, no way to cancel. So they charge your card on file $10 for no cancelation. Do NOT make reservations through Tock. You will get no help from them or the restaurant at all.

Service: 1

Carley Hanna

A MUST for Gluten-Free Foodies!

I was visiting NYC with my two nephews, and all three of us have celiac — so finding safe, delicious food while traveling can be tricky. With just a few hours left before leaving the city, we stumbled upon Thyme and Tonic — and what a find!

From the moment we walked in, Alan made our experience unforgettable, going above and beyond to ensure everything was perfect. The food was absolutely chef’s kiss!

To top it off, he walked us next door to their sister restaurant, Modern Bread and Bagel, where the yumminess continued.

It was the perfect end to our trip! THANK YOU Alan!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Karen Rosenberg Botelho

We are from Boston and this was our first time here! It was amazing and unbelievable for celiacs Alan I think is the owner was amazing to us! Thank you Alan for the awesome experience and kindness! The onion rings were amazing and my husband had the duck which he said was the best he ever had!!! We order from Modern Bread and Bagel which is also totally GF. So amazing!!! We order all the time!

Ellie Kelly Gerbracht

I live out of state and have tried TWICE this year to come for a coveted GF soft pretzel. Despite being listed on their menu, they literally never have it. In January, I stopped by on a Sunday and they said they only make it on weekdays during the winter. Today (June) I stopped by on a Friday and they said they didn’t have it and “maybe would have it Monday”. We even tried to confirm before we trekked out from our hotel but they couldn’t be bothered to answer the phone. Take it off your menu if you’re not going to carry it. So disappointed.

Serena Yuvokzy

I very barely leave reviews, however this is one that is most deserve one. The service was outstanding! The staff were friendly, efficient, and made us feel right at home. Not to mention delicious drinks. We couldn’t have asked for a better experience. Excited to come back!

Hauke Sandhaus

Sad food

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

Ian Biggins

Great food nice for gluten free

Mitch Drabenstott

I’m not gluten or dairy free but my friend is so she chose this place. And she made a GREAT decision. The whole meal was incredible, all the way down to the still water which she described as “the best water I’ve ever had.” I had the chicken parm and she had the popcorn chicken, and we split a caesar salad. All three dishes were fantastic with enough food for leftovers. It all came out very quick too, I don’t think we waited more than 15 minutes for our entrees. The bill for our meal ended up being less than $100, even after a 20% tip. Highly recommend this place!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

julissa lopez

Our friend’s birthday Brunch this Sunday (3/16) was beyond what any of us expected! We had such an amazing experience from the food, (brisket hash, steak burger, chicken poppers and more) being all delicious, to the strong and tasty drinks! We had passion fruit margaritas the whole time and Sangria which was Perfection. The best part was Alan, the owner, coming over to check in and joking with us, making us feel very welcomed and special. Our server Junior was attentive and friendly smiling the whole time, putting up with all 9 of us Locas. We will definitely be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

samantha prince

The service is great! But the place is crowded & loud, sound really carries. The drinks are as good as any cocktail in Manhattan that costs 17$. The food…. It’s cool that they make everything gluten free, but don’t waste your money, it is flavorless.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 5

leanne poon

Delicious high quality food where everything is gluten free. I wanted to order everything in the menu.

I had the Baja salad with the crispy chicken and my boyfriend had the avocado toast. Everything tasted like it was made from scratch. The gluten free crispy chicken was crunchy on the outside and super tender on the inside. The salad dressing was very tasty. My boyfriend’s avocado and toast came with a delicious side salad, and the vegan brioche was tasty and substantial.

I would definitely be back to try other things in the menu. I really wanted to try the gluten free soft pretzel, but I was too full.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Juliadele Male

This a gluten free persons dream!! There are so many food options that are really hard to find gluten free. When I go here with people who can eat gluten, they are very happy with their meal and say they can’t taste the difference. They have one of the best gf buns I have ever tasted.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Leah Mahgerefteh

Food was good. Some things were a little bland and needed sauce but the staff was very nice and understanding. Service was amazing and the stuff was so nice and interactive. The drinks and cocktails were also fantastic. Overall the prices are a little high but the experience was very nice.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

nilly shahkoohi

Great food and great service!! The food came fast and the service was very accommodating, fun, and kind.

Kristine Anastacia

After our experience I have no idea why this place has any decent ratings. Wasted a night on our New York trip here. I was admittedly a little excited when we first got our starting dishes because the tacos and popcorn chicken tasted decent, but then the other things we got arrived and they were just awful. The onion rings were a greasy mess and had no “salt and vinegar” on them at all, not even any salt or seasoning - just grease, like so much grease that we were up all night not feeling well (similar to other reviews stating the amount of grease or possibly old grease made them not feel well). Then the “nashville hot chicken” sandwich was just a dry piece of fried chicken with pickles and onions - didn’t even have any hot sauce on it which was confusing, unless they just forgot to put it on they should just call it a fried chicken sandwich? It also smelt like it was fried in oil that was weeks old or something, both my friend and I had one bite and didn't even bother eating more of it because it tasted that bad and almost like it was spoiled. The cookie skillet was just raw cookie. Even though it’s a completely gluten free place if you’re sensitive when eating a lot of fats/oils/grease definitely stay far away or you will not feel well afterwards. Costs WAY too much for what they're offering. I usually don't leave negative reviews but this was the first time I've actually had a bad stomach after a restaurant experience and after reading other reviews it seems like I'm not the only one, so I feel like people need to be warned in case they'd rather stay safe.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...