Stafili Wine Cafe

796 Greenwich St, New York
(917) 261-4283

Recent Reviews

Sort by
J. Foster

Met a friend for coffee and walked together to Stafili so she could have a glass of wine while I had to run to take a call. Stafili was nearly empty so she had her pick of tables. As I said goodbye, I asked to use the restroom and was quickly denied access because I wasn't "a seated customer". I was literally with a customer who was actively being seated. Heaven forbid Stafili treat others with respect and offer true service. Funny enough, I was actually thinking about staying or even coming back after my call. Not this time, and frankly not in the future either.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Jay Gor

if you’re a person of color, don’t bother. sat for 25 minutes and not a single waiter bothered to stop by our table. meanwhile, every other party who entered after us was serviced immediately. too many other options in the area where you won’t be treated like a second class citizen.

Service: 1

Alex Walling

Go to spot for a chill glass of wine

david rozas

Loved it. Stumbled across walking back to hotel from high line. Great win!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

samantha walker

We are locals who collectively have been coming here for a couple of years now and have always appreciated the more relaxed atmosphere compared to other wine bars in WV- which is why I am at lost for words for the experience I had last night. We arrived and ask the waitress how long for a table for a party of our size, where she told us reservations could only be made through Resy. Ok fair enough we thought, and found a reservation for our party size available in 15 minutes on the app and booked it. We showed the waitress and stood outside to wait. 2 of us tried to go use the bathroom while we waited to be seated and were chased down by the waitress who told them only seated customers could use the bathrooms and blocked them from going any further into the restaurant. At this point it’s about 5 minutes until our resy reservation so we approach the hostess again to plead if they could please use the bathroom as we only had a few more minutes until time. Not only did she deny them entry to the bathroom, she told us she would actually not be able to accommodate the reservation we had made. Meanwhile, we had seen at least 4 groups enter and be seated while we waited outside. At this point we decided to leave, where we saw a whole row of empty bar stools that would have fit our parties size. I truly have never experienced more disrespectful treatment.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jordan Howard

Loved Stafili until last night! Have been coming here for drinks with my boyfriend and friends for years. We put our name on the waitlist and waited outside. We walked in to use the bathroom while we were waiting for our table where we were all about to buy a bottle of wine. We were chased by the hostess that only “seated guests” could use the bathroom to which I responded, “I am About to be?”

Natalie Seitz

Not upset, just confused by the poor hospitality. We have been locals coming here for 2 years, you could always walk in for wine and receive chill relaxed service with excellent selections. When local residents come to enjoy your business, and you let in influencers with no remorse, you are no longer a local establishment.

Avinaash K

Wonderful WV Greek wine bar - plenty of Greek cheese and wine options. The staff was super knowledgeable and helped us choose a wine we’d love. Definitely would come back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Goat Cheese Panini

David Cymer

This wine bar is my favorite go-to in the summer and fall months. They offer a genuine selection of Greek wines and some finger food to go with them. But what I come here for most is the atmosphere. Cozy and quaint vibes you can get lost in for a while and forget you’re in one of the busiest cities on Earth.

Go relax, bring with you a friend. Or a good book.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Goat Cheese Panini, Orange Wine

Nike Zooms

young server curly hair guy - one of the rudest experiences i’ve had with a server. completely unnecessary and strange. also stopped two women from playing an innocent quiet game at their table (even though we were the only other people in there). to make it worse, when i went up to pay (and tip) I heard him laughing and gossiping about us. truly bizarre. not sure what we did apart from politely order a drink and promptly leave. hate to judge a place based on one unlucky experience but he was a jerk, plain and simple.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Karina Vozniuk

This Greek restaurant in West Village is a real gem. The food is outstanding, with fresh and flavorful dishes, I loved tuna tartare and Stafili salad a lot!. The orange wine is a must-try, as well. The service is friendly and attentive, making for a great dining experience.10/10

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Goat Cheese, Greek Panini, Orange Wine, Burrata

Amit Kohn

Beautiful place with great atmosphere.
And of course Panos is the best ❤️
I trusted him with the wine and he picked a great bottle for us (and one of the cheapest in the menu)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

James Thomas

Very cool Greek wine bar. Cosy vibe. Interesting to try Greek wines with some natural options.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jessica Y

They have amazing selection of wines and happy hour on a red, white, and rose, and sparkling. The ambiance interior was nice with outdoor seating during great weather. Great explanation of the wine flight we received, however, felt rushed when we didn't finish our wines yet and gave us our check. We received a look that seemed judgmental prior to leaving, possibly due to the time we took in calculating the tip. I may be wrong, but I didn't appreciate the person's vibe.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 4

Anna S

This place is great. You really couldn’t ask for more. Awesome wines (love the unique focus on Greek wine), yummy food, the place itself is so cute with fun details (like the wine cork ceiling) and the service was just perfect. 10/10 would recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...