Sugar Hill Cafe
410 W 145th St, New York
(212) 234-2024
Customers' Favorites
Btrain Egg Cheese & Bacon on Brioche Bun
Latte and Cream Cheese Bagel
House Coffee Single Origin
Build Your Own Oatmeal
OOO La La French Toast
Classic Eggs Benedict
New Yorker Sandwiche
Everything Croissant
English Breakfast
Advocate Toast
Brunch
Eggs Bennie
Two poached eggs over an English muffin, Canadian bacon homemade tarragon hollandaise sauce, home fries and house salad.
Norwegian Eggs
Two poached eggs over an English muffin, smoked nova salmon, homemade tarragon hollandaise sauce, home fries and house salad.
Eggs Blackstone
Two poached eggs and bacon on roasted rosemary plum tomatoes, homemade tarragon hollandaise sauce, home fries, house salad.
Platters
Oh! La La French Toast
French brioche loaf slices in a bed of organic California almond slices, blueberry compote, seasonal fruit, drizzled with powdered sugar and caramel
Sugar Hill Classic BKT
2 eggs any style, buttered toast, home fries and house salad.
Italian Omelette
Heirloom tomato and basil, egg whites omelette, buttered toast, homes fries and house salad
Eggsquisite Avo Toast
Homemade Guac on Freshly Baked Multigrain Toast topped with Sunflower Seeds and Crumbled Feta
Served with House Salad
Green Omelette
Open faced omelette with scallions and parsley, buttered toast, home fries and house salad
Cali Omelette
Organic spinach and feta cheese omelette with buttered toast, home fries and house salad
Avocado Toast
Housemade guac topped with feta cheese and pumpkin seeds on freshly baked multigrain pullman toast
Create Your Own omelette
Choose any two options from the "additional menu" with buttered toast, home fries and house salad
Sofishticated Avo Toast
Smoked Nova Salmon over Homemade Guac on Freshly Baked Multigrain Toast topped with Capers
Served with House Salad
Korean Omelette
Kimchi and Mozzarella Omelette served with Buttered Sourdough Toast, Home Fries, and House Salad
Beverages
Bottled Water
Sparkling Water
Artisanal Non-Coffee
Chai Latte
Seasonal - Pumpkin Spice Matcha
Matcha Latte
Hot Chocolate
Golden Tumeric Latte
Dona Brand Tumeric Latte
London Fog
Earl Grey Tea Latte with your choice of milk and a splash of vanilla !
Citrus Drinks
Lemonade
Arnold Palmer
Matcha Lemonade
Apple Juice
Loose Leaf Teas
Peach Blossom
Lemon Ginger
Morrocan Mint
Hibiscus
Chamomile
English Breakfast
Sencha Green
Earl Grey
Earl Green
Coffee
Cappuccino
Latte
Iced Coffee
Cold Brew
Coffee
Nitro Cold Brew
Americano
Macchiato
Cortado
Espresso
Sides
Bacon
Home Fries
Extra Egg (Single Egg)
Avocado
Fresh Pastries from Balthazar
Cheddar Scallion Scone
Savory triangular scone with cheddar and scallions baked in
Plain Croissant
Grab & Go
Lenka Bar
B Train Sandwich
2 Fried Medium or Scrambled Eggs, Cheddar, and Bacon on a Brioche Bun
Spicy Chipotle Mayo Optional
C Train Sandwich
Fried Medium or Scrambled Egg and Cheddar on a Brioche Bun
Chipotle Mayo Optional
Bagel Sandwich
Fried Medium or Scrambled Egg and Cheddar on Any Bagel of your choice
Croissant Sandwich
Smoked Ham and Mozzarella on a Plain Croissant
Bagel
Chia Pudding
House Made Chia Pudding made with Almond Milk.
New Yorker
Smoked Nova Salmon and Cream Cheese on any bagel of your choice
Hamilton Classic
Smoked Nova Salmon, Fried Medium and Scrambled Egg, Cheddar on your choice of any bagel
Brown Sugar Oatmeal
Platters
Oh! La La French Toast
French brioche loaf slices in a bed of organic California almond slices, blueberry compote, seasonal fruit, drizzled with powdered sugar and caramel
Sugar Hill Classic BKT
2 eggs any style, buttered toast, home fries and house salad.
Italian Omelette
Heirloom tomato and basil, egg whites omelette, buttered toast, homes fries and house salad
Eggsquisite Avo Toast
Homemade Guac on Freshly Baked Multigrain Toast topped with Sunflower Seeds and Crumbled Feta
Served with House Salad
Green Omelette
Open faced omelette with scallions and parsley, buttered toast, home fries and house salad
Cali Omelette
Organic spinach and feta cheese omelette with buttered toast, home fries and house salad
Avocado Toast
Housemade guac topped with feta cheese and pumpkin seeds on freshly baked multigrain pullman toast
Create Your Own omelette
Choose any two options from the "additional menu" with buttered toast, home fries and house salad
Sofishticated Avo Toast
Smoked Nova Salmon over Homemade Guac on Freshly Baked Multigrain Toast topped with Capers
Served with House Salad
Korean Omelette
Kimchi and Mozzarella Omelette served with Buttered Sourdough Toast, Home Fries, and House Salad
Hot Sandwiches
Jalapesto Chicken Sandwich
Chicken Breast, Jalapeno Pesto, Onion, and Mozzarella on a Ciabatta
Served with Chips
Caprese Panini
tomato, fresh mozzarella, basil pesto on ciabatta bread
Grilled Cheese
Cheddar cheese and Swiss cheese on pressed sourdough!
Ham & Cheese Panini
Smoked ham, mozzarella cheese, heirloom tomato, mixed green on pressed sourdough!
Salmon on Bagel
Open faced bagel, cream cheese, topped with smoked nova salmon, red onion, capers and house salad.
Turkey & Cheese Panini
Smoked Turkey, Swiss Cheese, Tomato, and Mixed Greens on Sourdough
Pressed and served with Chips
Coffee
Cappuccino
Latte
Iced Coffee
Cold Brew
Coffee
Nitro Cold Brew
Americano
Macchiato
Cortado
Espresso
Artisanal Non-Coffee
Chai Latte
Seasonal - Pumpkin Spice Matcha
Matcha Latte
Hot Chocolate
Golden Tumeric Latte
Dona Brand Tumeric Latte
London Fog
Earl Grey Tea Latte with your choice of milk and a splash of vanilla !
Loose Leaf Teas
Peach Blossom
Lemon Ginger
Morrocan Mint
Hibiscus
Chamomile
English Breakfast
Sencha Green
Earl Grey
Earl Green
Citrus Drinks
Lemonade
Arnold Palmer
Matcha Lemonade
Apple Juice
Beverages
Bottled Water
Sparkling Water
Sides
Bacon
Home Fries
Extra Egg (Single Egg)
Avocado
Photos
+56 photos
+55 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Sugar Hill Cafe is one of those hole in the wall coffee shops you’ll miss is you’re not looking for it so GO LOOK FOR IT. The staff is always warm, welcoming, and ready to make their customers smile. They have a surprisingly delicious and expansive menu. And the real draw is the coffee— it’s the BEST coffee in the area. Always brewed or steamed to perfection, they get it perfect every time. It’s good vibes all around
September 2025
Not only is the environment incredibly welcoming, but the service is speedy and efficient. The charisma from each member of the staff truly shifted my desire from eating in the park to dining in.
September 2025
Great local place! The breakfast items are fantastic. Love the Hamilton. The kind of place I take my mom to for a quick brunch bite when she visits the city or grab a quick local cup of coffee.
September 2025
You May Also Like
Briciola Harlem - 398 W 145th St
![]()
Italian, Pizza, Wine Bar
Checkers - 695 St Nicholas Ave
![]()
Fast Food, Burgers