Supper

Name: Supper
Address: 156 E 2nd St, New York, New York, 10009, US
Telephone: (212) 477-7600
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.2

$$$ • Italian, Wine Bars, Vegan

Hours:
156 E 2nd St, New York
(212) 477-7600

Menu Order Online Reserve

About Supper

Supper, a cozy Italian restaurant in NYC, has been a favorite for over 15 years, offering superb food that rivals Italy's best. The friendly staff and relaxed atmosphere make it a popular choice for diners. Watching the chefs at work adds to the charm of the place. Many customers appreciate the incredible, comforting Italian food, full of flavor. The grilled polenta is particularly noted as amazing, while the short rib tortellini is described as unbelievably delicious, especially when enjoyed on a Sunday.

Guests love the option to dine outside with a nice plate of pasta or a perfectly cooked piece of salmon paired with a glass of wine. The brunch menu features delightful vegetarian options, including a polenta cake grilled and covered in mushroom sauce and a classic eggplant parmesan dish. The complimentary bread, butter, and spicy olive oil with beans as an appetizer are also praised. However, some customers mention that the restaurant's cash-only policy can be inconvenient.

While many appreciate the attentive service and the generous nature of the waitstaff, a few reviews indicate that the experience may have changed recently, with some feeling that the prices are quite high for the simplicity of the dishes, like the $33 wild mushroom pasta. Despite this, Supper remains a great spot for a romantic date or special occasion.