Sutton Cafe
1026 1st Ave., New York
(212) 421-9184
Customers' Favorites
2 Egg Breakfast Plate
Toast
Eggs and Omelettes
1 Egg Any Style
1 Egg Any Style with Ham
1 Egg Any Style with Bacon
1 Egg Any Style with Sausage
1 Egg Any Style with Canadian Bacon
1 Egg Any Style with Turkey Bacon
1 Egg Any Style with Turkey Sausage
2 Eggs Any Style
2 Eggs Any Style with Ham
2 Eggs Any Style with Bacon
2 Eggs Any Style with Sausage
2 Eggs Any Style with Canadian Bacon
2 Eggs Any Style with Turkey Bacon
2 Eggs Any Style with Turkey Sausage
Corned Beef Hash and Eggs
Steak and Eggs
Plain Omelette
Veggie Omelette
Feta Omelette
Florentine Omelette
Greek Omelette
Spanish Omelette
Nova and Onions Omelette
Make Your Own Omelette
Griddle Specialties
Plain Griddle
Griddle with Ham
Griddle with Bacon
Griddle with Sausage
Griddle with 2 Eggs Any Style
Griddle with Canadian Bacon
Griddle with Turkey Bacon
Griddle with Turkey Sausage
Griddle with Blueberries
Lumberjack
Served with 2 eggs and ham, bacon or sausage.
Silver Dollar Pancakes
Chocolate Chip Pancakes
Walnut Pancakes
Belgian Waffle Sundae
Comes with scoop of ice cream, syrup and whipped cream.
Odds and Ends
Bagel with Cream Cheese
Bagel with Cream Cheese and Nova
Bagel Platter
Comes with cream cheese, nova, lettuce, tomato, onions and olives.
Danish
Turnover
Pound Cake
Plain, marble or carrot.
Bagel
Pita
English Muffin
Large English Muffin
Toast
Roll
Homemade Muffin
Jumbo Cookie
Hot Cereal
Oatmeal.
Hot Cereal with Walnuts
Hot Cereal with Raisins
Avocado Toast
Appetizers
Chicken Fingers
Homemade French Fried Onion Rings
Fried Mozzarella Sticks
Served with marinara sauce.
Buffalo Chicken Wings
Shrimp Tenders
With homemade marinara sauce, hot or mild.
Stuffed Grape Leaves
Homemade Chili
Salads
Greek Salad
Lettuce, tomato, green peppers, onions, cucumbers, olives, anchovies, feta cheese and stuffed grape leaves.
Grilled Chicken Salad
Grilled chicken breast on top of mixed greens and tomato.
Slim-Line Salad
8 oz. steak or turkey burger with a scoop of cottage cheese, lettuce and tomato salad.
Tuna Salad
On a bed of lettuce, tomato and cucumbers.
Chicken Salad
On a bed of lettuce, tomato and cucumbers.
Egg Salad
On a bed of lettuce, tomato and cucumbers.
Cantaloupe and Cottage Salad
Caesar Salad
Fresh romaine lettuce with croutons and our special Caesar dressing.
Chef's Salad
Julienne of ham, roast beef, turkey, cheese, hard boiled egg, lettuce, tomato and cucumbers.
Health Salad
Fresh fruit salad, cottage cheese and jello on a bed of lettuce.
Turkey Bowl
Fresh sliced turkey over mixed greens and tomato salad.
Large Mixed Green Salad
Tuna Fish Salad Platter
No celery. Served with potato salad, coleslaw, lettuce and tomato.
Chicken Salad Platter
No celery. Served with potato salad, coleslaw, lettuce and tomato.
Egg Salad Platter
No celery. Served with potato salad, coleslaw, lettuce and tomato.
Salad Nicoise
Chunks of tuna over mixed greens with hard boiled egg, olives, green beans, tomato and anchovies.
Horiatiki Salad
Tomato, cucumber, onions and feta cheese with grilled chicken.
Sutton Cafe Salad
Mixed greens, tomato, onions and olives with hamburger or turkey burger.
Vegetable Plate
Choice of 2 vegetables with baked potato or baked sweet potato.
Homemade Wraps
Turkey Club Wrap
Delicious, fresh roasted turkey with bacon, romaine lettuce and tomato.
Turkey Club Wrap with Side
Delicious, fresh roasted turkey with bacon, romaine lettuce and tomato.
Sutton Cafe Wrap
Thin sliced Virginia ham, Swiss cheese, lettuce and tomato.
Sutton Cafe Wrap with Side
Thin sliced Virginia ham, Swiss cheese, lettuce and tomato.
Hot Roast Beef Wrap
Hot roast beef with melted cheese and sauteed mushrooms.
Hot Roast Beef Wrap with Side
Hot roast beef with melted cheese and sauteed mushrooms.
Roast Beef Wrap
Delicious homemade roast beef with Swiss cheese, lettuce and tomato.
Roast Beef Wrap with Side
Delicious homemade roast beef with Swiss cheese, lettuce and tomato.
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled chicken with Caesar salad.
Chicken Caesar Wrap with Side
Grilled chicken with Caesar salad.
Chicken Salad Wrap
Our own chicken salad with lettuce and tomato.
Chicken Salad Wrap with Side
Our own chicken salad with lettuce and tomato.
Grilled Chicken Wrap
Grilled chicken with melted cheese and sauteed onions.
Grilled Chicken Wrap with Side
Grilled chicken with melted cheese and sauteed onions.
Nova Wrap
Thinly sliced nova with cream cheese, red onions, lettuce and tomato.
Nova Wrap with Salad
Thinly sliced nova with cream cheese, red onions, lettuce and tomato.
Tuna Fish Salad Wrap
Tasty homemade tuna fish with lettuce and tomato.
Tuna Fish Salad Wrap with Side
Tasty homemade tuna fish with lettuce and tomato.
Veggie Wrap
Eggplant, mushroom, onion and spinach.
Veggie Wrap with Side
Eggplant, mushroom, onion and spinach.
Sandwiches
Fried Egg Sandwich
Western Egg Sandwich
Bacon, Lettuce and Tomato Sandwich
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Cheese Sandwich
Tuna Fish Salad Sandwich
No celery.
Chicken Salad Sandwich
No celery.
Egg Salad Sandwich
Roast Turkey Sandwich
Carved to order.
Roast Beef Sandwich
Virginia Ham Sandwich
Ham and Cheese Sandwich
Hot Pastrami Sandwich
Meat Loaf Sandwich
Turkey Meat Loaf Sandwich
Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich
Chicken Cutlet Sandwich
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Sandwich
Fried Filet Sandwich
Individual Tuna Sandwich
Individual Salmon Sandwich
S and S Sardines Sandwich
Triple Decker Clubs
1. Turkey Triple Decker Club
Fresh sliced turkey, bacon, lettuce and tomato.
2. Roast Beef Triple Decker Club
Served with Swiss cheese, lettuce and tomato.
3. Grilled Chicken Triple Decker Club
Grilled breast of chicken with cheese, lettuce and tomato.
4. Chicken Salad Triple Decker Club
Chicken salad with bacon, lettuce and tomato.
5. Tuna Salad Triple Decker Club
Tuna salad with sliced egg, lettuce and tomato.
6. Egg Salad Triple Decker Club
Egg salad with bacon, lettuce and tomato.
Sutton Cafe Specialties
House Chicken Breast
Grilled breast of chicken, topped with sauteed onions and melted cheese on pita.
Chicken Pita Pizza
Grilled chicken breast with marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese on pita.
First Avenue
Thin sliced roast beef topped with sauteed mushrooms and melted cheese, garnished with potato salad or french fries.
Monte Cristo
Thin sliced turkey with ham and melted Swiss cheese over challah French toast.
Chicken Salad Melt
Served with french fries or potato salad.
Tuna Salad Melt
Served with french fries or potato salad.
Open Reuben
Pastrami or corned beef with sauerkraut, topped with melted Swiss on grilled rye bread, garnished with potato salad or french fries.
Pastrami Grill
Grilled hot pastrami on rye with melted cheese.
Grilled Eggplant
Grilled eggplant, peppers, red onion and melted mozzarella on a bun with french fries.
Chicken Nuggets
Served with french fries in a basket.
Chicken Fingers
Served with french fries in a basket.
Fish and Chips
Served with french fries in basket.
Fried Fish Filet Deluxe
Served with french fries, lettuce and tomato.
Open Sliced Steak Sandwich
Sliced steak on toast, open faced, with lettuce, tomato and french fries.
Sutton Meat Loaf
Served with mashed potatoes, crispy onions and barbecue gravy, served open-faced on thick egg bread.
Gyro on Pita
Served with lettuce, tomato, onions and tzatziki sauce.
Gyro Platter
Served with Greek salad, french fries and tzatziki sauce.
Chicken Souvlaki on Pita
Served with lettuce, tomato, onions and tzatziki sauce.
Chicken Souvlaki Platter
Served with Greek salad, french fries and tzatziki sauce.
1/2 lb. Steak Burgers
Steak Burger
Steak Burger Deluxe
Includes french fries, lettuce and tomatoes.
Garden Burger
Garden Burger Deluxe
Includes french fries, lettuce and tomatoes.
Chili Burger
Chili Burger Deluxe
Includes french fries, lettuce and tomatoes.
Turkey Burger
Turkey Burger Deluxe
Includes french fries, lettuce and tomatoes.
Pizza Burger
Pizza Burger Deluxe
Includes french fries, lettuce and tomatoes.
Steak Cheese Burger
Steak Cheese Burger Deluxe
Includes french fries, lettuce and tomatoes.
Greek Burger
Sauteed spinach, feta cheese and onion.
Greek Burger Deluxe
Includes french fries, lettuce and tomatoes.
Cali Burger
Avocado, bacon and cheddar cheese.
Cali Burger Deluxe
Includes french fries, lettuce and tomatoes.
Mex Burger
Avocado, jalapeno peppers and cheddar cheese.
Mex Burger Deluxe
Includes french fries, lettuce and tomatoes.
Rodeo Burger
Mushrooms, onions and muenster cheese.
Rodeo Burger Deluxe
Includes french fries, lettuce and tomatoes.
Italian Burger
Roasted red peppers, onions and mozzarella cheese.
Italian Burger Deluxe
Includes french fries, lettuce and tomatoes.
Hot Pressed Paninis
Eggplant Parmigiana Panini
Topped with mozzarella and tomato sauce.
Grilled Chicken Panini
Sliced chicken breast, mozzarella cheese, basil and roasted red peppers, sprinkled with balsamic vinaigrette dressing.
Roast Beef and Mozzarella Panini
Sliced roast beef topped with mozzarella.
Turkey Panini
Sliced turkey topped with Swiss cheese and grilled tomato, served with a side of honey Dijon dressing.
Chicken Parmigiana Panini
Pan fried chicken topped with mozzarella and tomato sauce.
Italian Panini
Grilled chicken, roasted peppers, balsamic vinaigrette and fresh mozzarella.
Greek Panini
Grilled chicken, feta cheese, tomato and spinach, served with tzatziki sauce.
Hot Open Sandwiches
Hot Open Freshly Sliced Roast Beef Sandwich
Hot Open Freshly Carved Turkey Sandwich
Off the bone.
Mediterranean Specialties
Pasta with Marinara Sauce
Pasta with Meat Sauce
Pasta with Meatballs
Lasagna
Vegetarian Lasagna
Spinach Pie
Eggplant Parmigiana with a Side of Pasta
Chicken Cutlet with a Side of Pasta
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana with a Side of Pasta
Stuffed Pasta Fiesta
Imported Cheese Ravioli
Homemade ravioli stuffed with ricotta and Pecorino Romano with homemade marinara sauce.
Beef Ravioli
Homemade ravioli stuffed with sauteed beef and a blend of spices and cheese with homemade marinara sauce.
Spinach Ravioli
Homemade ravioli stuffed with spinach, ricotta and Pecorino Romano with homemade marinara sauce.
Stuffed Rigatoni
Homemade rigatoni stuffed with ricotta and Pecorino Romano with homemade marinara sauce.
Stuffed Shells
Homemade jumbo pasta shells stuffed with ricotta and Pecorino Romano with homemade marinara sauce.
Entrees
Turkey
Carved roast turkey breast, served with cranberry sauce, vegetables and potatoes.
Grilled Chicken Breast and Athenian Style
Marinated in fresh garlic, lemon and herbs, served with vegetables and potatoes.
Poached Chicken Breast
With a balsamic black bean and pepper salsa, served with potatoes or vegetable.
Chicken Breast Florentine
Broiled breast of chicken stuffed with imported feta cheese, spinach and herbs, served with potatoes or vegetable.
Chicken Kabob
Chunks of chicken breast sauteed with bell peppers, onions and tomatoes, served over rice.
Southern Fried Chicken
Honey dipped Louisiana style fried chicken, served with vegetables and potatoes.
Turkey Meatloaf
Slowly baked turkey meatloaf, served with homemade mushroom gravy, vegetables and potatoes.
Baked Meatloaf
Served with mushroom gravy, mixed vegetables and potatoes.
Broiled Rib Eye Steak
Topped with garlic flavored sauteed mushrooms, served with vegetables and potatoes.
Chopped Steak
Topped with sauteed onions or bacon, served with vegetables and potatoes.
Broiled Norwegian Salmon
Served with vegetables and potatoes.
Fish Filet Ala Maison
Cooked in white wine and garlic, served with vegetables and potatoes.
Shrimp Primavera
Gulf shrimp and diced vegetables, sauteed in garlic and herbs, served over pasta or rice.
Stuffed Baked Potato
Stuffed Baked Potato with Broccoli and Cheese
Add bacon for an additional charge.
Stuffed Baked Potato with Garden Salad
Stuffed Baked Potato with Caesar Salad
Side Orders
French Fries
Cheese Fries
Sweet Potato Fries
Baked Potato
After 12 pm.
Baked Sweet Potato
After 12 pm.
Home Fried Potatoes
Home Mashed Potatoes
Rice
Pasta with Marinara Sauce
Pasta with Olive Oil and Garlic
Small Mixed Green Salad
Caesar Salad
Sauteed Vegetable
Side of Ham
Side of Bacon
Side of Sausage
Side of Canadian Bacon
Side of Turkey Bacon
Side of Turkey Sausage
Side of Corned Beef Hash
Coleslaw
Potato Salad
Cottage Cheese
Cranberry Sauce
Tzatziki Sauce
Marinara Sauce
Salad Dressing
Desserts
Jello
Layer Cake
Creamy Cheese Cake
Assorted Fruit Pie
Fruit Pie a la Mode
Creamy Rice Pudding
Ice Cream
Fresh Beginnings
Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice
Tomato Juice
Apple Juice
Individual Pineapple
V-8
1/2 Grapefruit
Fresh Fruit Salad
Melon
Beverages
Coffee
Tea
Decaffeinated Coffee
Herbal Tea
Hot Chocolate
Hot Chocolate with Milk
Espresso
Double Espresso
Cappuccino
Milk
Chocolate Milk
Iced Cappuccino
Iced Coffee
Iced Tea
Ice Cream Soda
Fresh Lemonade
Fountain Soda
Egg Cream
Milkshake
Thick
Photos
+35 photos
+34 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I had a moment shared with my family and Sutton cafe made it very enjoyable with their quality service and warm welcome. The staff are attentive and do everything on time. We really liked the atmosphere. The new menu was a good discovery, can't wait to try it. Thank you everyone for your hard work
September 2024
Classic greasy spoon with really friendly staff. It was such a nice, relaxed old school Cafe with delicious breakfast food and a coffee cup that's never empty. Will be going back often! The only tip I would give is to bring cash as there is an upcharge with credit
January 2024
You May Also Like
Best Pizza - 1038 1st Ave.
![]()
Pizza, Vegetarian
Marathon Coffee - 1042 1st Ave.
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee, Coffee & Tea, Tacos
Dunkin' - 1006 1st Ave.
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee, Donuts, Coffee & Tea
Its one of my favorite breakfast spots . The staff are the nicest people ever. The food is always incredible. There pancakes and omelette are my go to. They make the old school milkshake that never misses and the iced latte is the best in NYC. Ask for nick when you go!!