Best Pizza

$ • Pizza

Hours:
1038 1st Ave., New York
(212) 644-8400

Customers' Favorites

Best Pizza Reviews

Restaurantji Rating
4.2 (44)
Restaurantji Rating

The name says it all! By far my favorite pizza spot in Midtown East. The pizza is consistently delicious. My favorite is the baby pepperoni on the bright white mozzarella. Plain cheese—YUMMY!! Love the Buffalo chicken and salad slices too. The Philly cheesesteak sandwich is totally awesome. I love the chicken fingers and salads. I come regularly and have never had a disappointing meal here. The place is definitely best for taking out, not eating in, but there is some room to...read full review

Restaurantji Rating

As much as I hated staying in New York for 2 months for me to sell art work, I do have to say that this was a good place to go if you didn't have any options. However, I'm a little concerned about the smell at the back of the place. You could smell it everytime you passed by on the sidewalk. Like a dead animal? Maybe they should get a pest control for that alleyway. Something probably got stuck in the dumpster.

Restaurantji Rating

Amazing food. The chicken vodka was great, and the pizza, oh the pizza! The name doesn't lie. There was one downside, however. It was amazing, but when I stepped outside, I smelt a disgusting, putrid smell. I'm assuming this was because of the fact that it is in NYC though. other than that, the food, and the restaurant itself were amazing! You guys should relocate, or open more stores, the smell is horrible. Also, I live in NJ, so I never get to come here. When I did come though,...read full review

More Reviews(139)

Ratings

Hours

Monday 10AM - 10:45PM
Tuesday 10AM - 10:45PM
Wednesday 10AM - 10:45PM
Thursday 10AM - 10:45PM
Friday 10AM - 10:45PM
Saturday 10AM - 10:45PM
Sunday 11AM - 9:45PM
Updated on: