Tanner Smith's

204 W 55th St, New York
(646) 590-2034

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Chris

Terrific spot! Great vibe with creative drink menu. Lots of interesting food choices and the 90's music playlist is fantastic. Great for date night, hang out, friends, solo. Love it!

Tiffany

Overall, a fantastic spot for dinner! We love the cocktails, staff, ambiance, and overall feel of everything! For dinner we kept it reasonably light; Oxtail Arancini, and Chicken spring rolls for our appetizers, followed by the delicious and generous Tuna Niçoise salad and Pastrami Melt sandwich with a delicious side salad! Drinks as always are amazing, I had The Winona and my husband had an Aperol Spritz. Fantastic dinner, would seriously be in trouble if this place was in Philadelphia!

Sara

Our server had a great Irish accent and was super helpful with our questions and very friendly! Was a bit loud due to a few business gatherings happening but not intolerable.

Mira

Wonderful waitress named Natalie. We were running to a show after and she accommodated us and made sure our food came out quickly. I had one of the Prosecco based cocktails and it was amazing. It wasn't too noisy and was decorated very tastefully. I think the food is a little overpriced for what it is, but it is Manhattan after all. All in all a win for a last-minute dinner.

Maureen

Loved our lunch dining experience before a Broadway afternoon show. Food options were great and service staff were friendly and responsive. Live music at noon on a Saturday was an added bonus. We'll be back!

Amanda

If you're looking for a nice date or chill ambiance this is the place to go! Definitely order a tea pot for drinks if you are out with a group of friends. Great place and food is delicious !!

Careein

It was our first visit and first date for the starting of the New Year. It was very nice, service was good only thing is that they automatically assigned you to a table instead of letting the paying customer choose where they would like to sit from the empty tables! Food was good for what we ordered. We might very again!

Shala

Dinner service: The restaurant overall has a great vibe! It is laid back complete with rustic decor and dim lighting - very comfortable. The food was prepared well, but unfortunately, lacked a little flavor. The drinks were good. Love the options for brunch and live music. Most likely will return to try brunch.

lysee

We stumbled upon this gem and will absolutely be back. Food was incredible. Highly recommend the avocado toast.

Beverly

I enjoyed this place very much pub style. Great look to it. Great vibe food was very good. Service was great. Great energy in the place. I would recommend it for sure.

Rachelle

Such a treat to eat here during the Christmas season as it's festively decorated. Request dining room if you want a chair with a back, otherwise it's stools at high tops in the bar area. Lovely jazz band played during brunch. Our Irish waitress was delightful. Be sure and get a short stack of delicious pancakes!

Carolyn

A bit noisy, but good service & food at a very reasonable price. Other than a hair on my husband's plate, the experience was pleasant.

Stephanie

Nice holiday dinner with the family. We love how they are decorated for the holidays and the food is always consistent.

Erin

Used to be one of my favorite spots in Midtown, unfortunately not anymore. Arrived for Friday brunch reservation at a busy time in December only to be told kitchen was closed. They had my contact info so fully could have alerted me before I traveled there. Really bad form. Never allowed us time to make other plans so we're left scrambling. If you're not open for Friday brunch, change your website and reservations so no one books. Stop opening new venues when the others are clearly faltering.

Ivy

We had a great date here! Great upscale tavern environment with history. Very festive and energetic without too much noise. Food was very good with unique takes on tuna poke, deviled eggs, truffle fries and more.

Loading...