Unusual combo of cuisines but really works great! Excellent charred crust pies with unique toppings that totally work together. Awesome service too
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
SNJP NYC
We tried different kinds of pizzas at The Onion Tree Pizza. The Spicy Masala Pizza looked tempting with all the masala on top, but it was served cold. The Paneer Makhani Pizza was quite watery and messy, and the Margherita DOP Pizza didn’t seem worth the price.
The Dosa Batter Onion Rings were tasty but too oily. We also ordered the Ringan Ola Pizza, but after waiting for about 35 minutes, we were informed that it wasn’t available which was quite disappointing.
They also don’t offer any kind of customization for kids, which makes it less convenient for families. The restroom is very small, and it’s not easy to get in and out, especially if you have kids with you.
Overall, the food presentation was nice, but the service and quality definitely need improvement.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
Isabela Evans
Did not have a great experience here. Saw good reviews online regarding Gluten Free options but then when I inquired, every server was unsure about what was GF. I think they had a recent change in management because the servers were all brand new, food took forever, and the menu was much more limited than what I read online. What we ate was okay but we didn’t receive our starter until we had finished our mains and the table next to us was receiving comped drinks because their food took so long. I will not be coming back.
Ashish Ani
Unique Food Experience ! Variety of options !
We tried following :- 1. Burrata Chaat - 5/5 A Must Try 2. Paneer Makhani - Napoletana - 4/5 ( Good) 3. Hand Cut French Fries - 1/5 (Avoid) 4. Masala Chai - 3/5 ( Good)
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Reecha
food was good but server repeatedly told us to leave after wed been seated bc another reservation was supposed to come. it was really rude and weird
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 2
Melodie Thurman
I’m sitting inside as I write this and my mouth is pleasantly on fire, as is my heart and soul. The atmosphere is ripe with color and history. From the wall art to the paint colors to the books on the shelf you’re invited in and you can’t help feel at home. We ordered the Tikka Masala pizza, the onion rings and wings. Once it arrived a comfortable silence settled over us as we dug in and our bellies and taste buds were ravished with pleasure. The crunchy onion rings were 10/10! The wings kept it hot and you just couldn’t stop. The pizza is out of this world. Crunchy crust, amazing toppings. Who knew Indian pizza would take the stage in this otherworldly performance.
Food was awesome. Our servers and Mr Apar took really good care of us. Will be back!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hadley S
Incredible flavors! So creative yet accessible!
Apaar is so friendly and welcoming! I love the space he’s created and he’s made it so that celiac and gluten free folks can enjoy life’s simple pleasures: onion rings & chicken tenders
The Hara Bhara kebab was to die for and I can’t stop thinking about the sauces
I left in food coma and still wanted to order more
Crispy Carma is popping up at the bar: Long live fried chicken! The crunch the sauce the marinade wow!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jannat Mazari
Went over to watch the India–Pakistan Asia Cup final and had such a wonderful time here! The owners and staff were incredibly sweet and welcoming — they made me feel right at home even though I was the only Pakistani cheering for my team (which sadly lost!). The hospitality, food, and atmosphere were all fantastic. Can’t wait to come back again.
Don’t get your hopes up if you’re a south Asian who eats good south Asian food. Their chicken tikka masala pizza is soggy and bland - absolutely no depth of flavor at all. It’s worse than the jar sauces you get at Target. The butter chicken sauce is equally as bland. This food was NOT made for our demographic. The service is great though. Vibe is good. Food is just not good. Very sad to say.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Zaid Khan
the burrata chaat was divine! we opted for the napoletana style paneer makhani (softer, fluffier crust vs the romana) & wow did it have a kick. a delicious meal & super kind server (shoutout Shivam). will definitely return.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jackie Rodrigez
Got the shahi paneer pizza and it was so delicious. The mango lassi was one of best mango lassi I’ve ever had!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Damian Lang
Great fusion pizza spot. Ordered the gunpowder fries, chicken tika pizza, and Marsala margherita. Great service and atmosphere.
However, the scissors provided with the meal were the best tactile experience of any pizza joint I’ve ever been to. I would come again just to slice with the pizza shears again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ian
Enjoyed the food, there was a rather long wait for the pizza which we didn’t mind. The bartender who was taking care of us also did a good job. Have to write a poor review because of the manager (Apaar) who was working tonight. Me and my boyfriend were excited to try this place, and unfortunately found ourselves treated differently by the manager. He was going around to every group at the bar and other tables introducing himself, asking questions, making sure everyone was enjoying their meal. Never once stopped to talk to us, or apologize for the long wait time (about an hour for one pizza). He just set it down in front of us and walked away. We honestly couldn’t think of any other reason he treated us differently aside from being a gay couple. It was clear he cared a lot about getting customers to come back—just not us.
Unusual combo of cuisines but really works great! Excellent charred crust pies with unique toppings that totally work together. Awesome service too
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
We tried different kinds of pizzas at The Onion Tree Pizza. The Spicy Masala Pizza looked tempting with all the masala on top, but it was served cold. The Paneer Makhani Pizza was quite watery and messy, and the Margherita DOP Pizza didn’t seem worth the price.
The Dosa Batter Onion Rings were tasty but too oily. We also ordered the Ringan Ola Pizza, but after waiting for about 35 minutes, we were informed that it wasn’t available which was quite disappointing.
They also don’t offer any kind of customization for kids, which makes it less convenient for families. The restroom is very small, and it’s not easy to get in and out, especially if you have kids with you.
Overall, the food presentation was nice, but the service and quality definitely need improvement.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 2
Did not have a great experience here. Saw good reviews online regarding Gluten Free options but then when I inquired, every server was unsure about what was GF. I think they had a recent change in management because the servers were all brand new, food took forever, and the menu was much more limited than what I read online. What we ate was okay but we didn’t receive our starter until we had finished our mains and the table next to us was receiving comped drinks because their food took so long. I will not be coming back.
Unique Food Experience ! Variety of options !
We tried following :-
1. Burrata Chaat - 5/5 A Must Try
2. Paneer Makhani - Napoletana - 4/5 ( Good)
3. Hand Cut French Fries - 1/5 (Avoid)
4. Masala Chai - 3/5 ( Good)
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
food was good but server repeatedly told us to leave after wed been seated bc another reservation was supposed to come. it was really rude and weird
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 2
I’m sitting inside as I write this and my mouth is pleasantly on fire, as is my heart and soul. The atmosphere is ripe with color and history. From the wall art to the paint colors to the books on the shelf you’re invited in and you can’t help feel at home.
We ordered the Tikka Masala pizza, the onion rings and wings. Once it arrived a comfortable silence settled over us as we dug in and our bellies and taste buds were ravished with pleasure. The crunchy onion rings were 10/10! The wings kept it hot and you just couldn’t stop. The pizza is out of this world. Crunchy crust, amazing toppings. Who knew Indian pizza would take the stage in this otherworldly performance.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Tikka Pizza, Chicken Tikka Masala Pizza, Dosa Battered Onion Rings
Food was awesome. Our servers and Mr Apar took really good care of us. Will be back!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Incredible flavors! So creative yet accessible!
Apaar is so friendly and welcoming! I love the space he’s created and he’s made it so that celiac and gluten free folks can enjoy life’s simple pleasures: onion rings & chicken tenders
The Hara Bhara kebab was to die for and I can’t stop thinking about the sauces
I left in food coma and still wanted to order more
Crispy Carma is popping up at the bar: Long live fried chicken! The crunch the sauce the marinade wow!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Went over to watch the India–Pakistan Asia Cup final and had such a wonderful time here! The owners and staff were incredibly sweet and welcoming — they made me feel right at home even though I was the only Pakistani cheering for my team (which sadly lost!). The hospitality, food, and atmosphere were all fantastic. Can’t wait to come back again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent Indian fusion Neapolitan style pizza.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Don’t get your hopes up if you’re a south Asian who eats good south Asian food. Their chicken tikka masala pizza is soggy and bland - absolutely no depth of flavor at all. It’s worse than the jar sauces you get at Target. The butter chicken sauce is equally as bland. This food was NOT made for our demographic. The service is great though. Vibe is good. Food is just not good. Very sad to say.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
the burrata chaat was divine! we opted for the napoletana style paneer makhani (softer, fluffier crust vs the romana) & wow did it have a kick. a delicious meal & super kind server (shoutout Shivam). will definitely return.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Got the shahi paneer pizza and it was so delicious. The mango lassi was one of best mango lassi I’ve ever had!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great fusion pizza spot. Ordered the gunpowder fries, chicken tika pizza, and Marsala margherita. Great service and atmosphere.
However, the scissors provided with the meal were the best tactile experience of any pizza joint I’ve ever been to. I would come again just to slice with the pizza shears again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Enjoyed the food, there was a rather long wait for the pizza which we didn’t mind. The bartender who was taking care of us also did a good job. Have to write a poor review because of the manager (Apaar) who was working tonight. Me and my boyfriend were excited to try this place, and unfortunately found ourselves treated differently by the manager. He was going around to every group at the bar and other tables introducing himself, asking questions, making sure everyone was enjoying their meal. Never once stopped to talk to us, or apologize for the long wait time (about an hour for one pizza). He just set it down in front of us and walked away. We honestly couldn’t think of any other reason he treated us differently aside from being a gay couple. It was clear he cared a lot about getting customers to come back—just not us.
Loading...