Tuscany Steakhouse

117 W 58th St, New York
(212) 757-8630

Recent Reviews

yankeeblackhawk

Food was prepared well and the service was quite good.

Ermir

Quality the food was magnificent. The service was top-tier. Would definitely recommend for business meetings and even dinner with friends.

OpenTable Diner

The experience was lovely. The service was pretty exceptional. Both managers stopped by to ask about the experience. The meat was cooked perfectly. The sides were tasty. Everyone at the table was happy with the overall experience.

normap

It always feels like a special occasion when we dine here,and we do that quite often

MartyW

Every dish was exceptional. If you appreciate top-shelf steaks, Tuscany is the best in the area. The servers were excellent.

M5family

it was a wonderful meal. the service was unbelievably good.

OpenTable Diner

Tuscany Steakhouse is superb! I took my wife there for our final dinner of a 4 night stay in NYC. The ambiance is fantastic as the building is 1900s brown stone; the waiter was knowledgeable and friendly, and the waitstaff were attentive and quick. We had been served two courses, wine and water refills all in 50 mins. Wine list is superb, desert is classic Italian/European and to die for. The key lime pie is fantastic. Veal chop fans will be very satisfied, so too the rib eye for 2 or more aficionados. 5 stars!

Mr H.

I'm slightly overdue with my review. When something greatly impacts my experience (good or bad), I usually like to share immediately. Most traditional steakhouses have a certain vibe to them. This one falls into that category so not much to speak on in regards to aesthetics. What stands out is the service of the team that flows and is well organized. What is exceptional is the food. We stared with a seafood platter and chose the porterhouse steak to share. The seafood platter was fresh and generous. The steak was like butter and perfectly cooked. Then with the recommendation of one of our servers, we chose the pecan pie for dessert. I'm not a fan of pecan pies but this was one of the best desserts I ever had after dinner. Thanks to the staff and we hope to put this restaurant into rotation.

Antaya C.

Had a wonderful and quiet evening at the Tuscany Steak House last night and I have to say, the food was divine! The steak has a nice crust but was served medium rare melting in you mouth leaving a nice bold flavor behind making you want even more. The salmon was also very tasty. The end of the night we had a dessert sampler made for us by the restaurant consisting of assorted fresh fruit, some very tasty tiramisu, cheesecake, panna cotta and a delectable delicious homemade whipped cream that could be eaten alone it was so good. The staff was friendly and attentive. I highly recommend Tuscany Steakhouse if you are looking for a nice quiet high-end dinner in Manhattan.

Roger G.

Went here with wife and daughters on Saturday. Service was impeccable. 3 to 4 waiters keeping our drinks full and table clean full time. Great higher end atmosphere - suit and tie perfect yet dress down ok too. Steaks were delicious, sides were great - sautéed mushrooms asparagus etc.. Has bone-in ribeye with mashed and creamed spinach. A couple of apps and dessert.

OpenTable Diner

We had an excellent experience at Tuscany Steakhouse for a party of 6 for a Saturday night dinner. The service was outstanding and attentive. The food was excellent. I have walked by this restaurant a hundred times but never thought to go in…I am very glad we did. It was not cheap…but every steakhouse in manhattan is $$$$. The physical environment was good not great…feels like it needed to be updated a bit. But this is the only very minor critique in an otherwise exceptional meal. I should also say that we have eaten at many of the other steakhouses in NY, and this one stands out…both for food and service.

Chris

Excellent quality meal as always. The bacon was phenomenal as were the sauteed mushrooms and the tartufo.

SPMB

Second time in 2 weeks. Love it. Food, service amazing!!

SPMB

Great steak! Great service!

TrishM

Excellent service! Very attentive and accommodating to my daughter’s food restrictions.

Load More