17 Best Mexican Restaurants in Newburgh

Experience Newburgh's Mexican food at these fantastic spots.

La Mexicana Restaurant Mexican • $
109 Liberty St, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Sausage Chicken Steak
Chicken Quesadilla
Steak Burrito
Steak Taco
Taco Bowl
Soda

“I am disappointed that took away the option of ordering one or two tacos. (especially if you're just trying to t have a light lunch), Now it's three or more. BUT the tacos are delicious.“

4.7 Superb77 Reviews
Mi Pueblito Mexican • $
5326 Rte 9W, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Lengua Quesadilla Empanada Tacos Chile and Pineapple
Chicken and Steak Tacos
Chicharrones Fritos
Homemade Sauce
Beef Empanada
Empanadas
Burritos
Enchilada
Tamale
Salsa

“My new favorite place to eat everyday lol“

4.7 Superb62 Reviews
Chilito's Restaurant Mexican • $$
1401 NY-300, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Taco Enchilada & Chile Relleno
Birria Taco Dipping Sauce
Taco Enchilada and Burrito
Taco Enchilada & Tamal
Enchiladas Mole Poblano
Chips and Salsa 12oz
Enchiladas Veracruz
Sweet Chimichangas
Free Quesadilla
Chiles Rellenos

“My family and I had a great time at Chilitos. Great food, excellent and quick service, and the decorations are so cute! Highly recommended.“

4.4 Superb118 Reviews
Antojitos Mexicanos Mexican • $
779 Broadway, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Tlacoyos Con Carne Cecina
Quesadilla De Pollo
Chicken Burrito
Pollo Ajillo
Taco Plate
Huaraches

“I have a tradition of ordering tacos for my family every year for my birthday. Of course we missed last year due to Covid-19 shutdown. New owners now, but the tacos were even better than ever. My family couldn't get enough. Now I can get my son interested in eating there. (I grew up in Southern California and had one Mexican great grandmother so I take my Mexican food seriously. I also spent two summers in Mexico with my best friend's family.) So go and eat there....they are truly bilingual.)“

4.2 Good47 Reviews
Las Poblanas Deli and Juice Bar Mexican • $
50 Mill St, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Quesadillas Campechanas
Apple Strawberry
Carne Asada
Enchilada
Carnitas
Al Pastor
Burrito
Elotes

“Best tacos in the area, Freshly made tortillas“

4.6 Superb14 Reviews
Plaza azteca Mexican • $
49 Mill St, Newburgh

“Authentic and delicious Mexican cuisine. Absolutely loved our dinner! Featured on my grid of greatness; from top left Breaded Chicken Cemitas, Torta Cubana, Gorditas, Chicken Salad, Parilla Azteca, Molcajete, Guacamole, Shrimp Soup and Veracruzana Shrimp. Two thumbs up!“

4.4 Superb16 Reviews
Tacos Uriel Mexican • $
49 Mill St, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp Quesadilla Mexicana
Tacos Dorados
Mole Poblano
Carnitas
Huaraches
Puerco
Cueros
Cemita
Pollo

“Amazing fresh food from scratch! My favorite is the Pollo / Chicken Milanesa Cemita with mozzarella, jalapeno and their special pink sauce. Mexican style Shrimp Quesadilla is refreshing. Portions are generous! They changed the name to Plaza Azteca, but it's the same ownership... check them out, give them some love!“

4.3 Superb25 Reviews
Yummy Taco Mexican • $
50 Rt 17K, Target, Plaza Suite 8, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Super Fajitas Chicken Steak Shrimp 12
Grilled Chicken & Shrimp Special
Grilled Chicken & Tex-Mex Chili
Rice with Chili and Beans
10 Pieces Teriyaki Wings
Grilled Chicken Taquitos
Grilled Chicken & Steak
Grilled Steak Taco
Teriyaki Chicken
Tex - Mex Chili

“Been eating here since they opened this is my go to place since high school. My whole family eats here as well as my friends the tostada bowls are good as well as the chicken and steak nachos they also whale rice and beans meals that come with tortillas. This is the spot for when u wanna get a good bang for you buck! suki is great!“

4.2 Good72 Reviews
El Gran Toro Mexican Brasserie Tacos • $$
118 Broadway, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Chipotle Chicken Burrito
Tres Leches French Toast
Enmoladas De Huitlacoche
Chorizo Con Gnocchi
Guacamole and Chips
Quesadilla Mexicana
Quesabirria-Ramen
Beef Quesabirria
Steak Ranchero
Cochinita Pibil

“Went with door dash and food was amazing. Pork burrito was full of flavor. the regular beef taco was full of flavor too and awesome shell. Even their chips and salsa was tasty lol. Nice to see this place in business.“

4.8 Superb85 Reviews
El Gallo Dorado Deli Restaurant Mexican • $
53 Mill St, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Rotisserie Chicken

“The roasted chicken in this place is delicious ?.
El pollo a la brasa en este lugar es delicioso ?

I paid $16.00 for the chicken. A little expensive but good.

The area it’a not the greatest but it is worth it to go if you want good chicken. Ask for the salsa verde to go with the chicken.“

3.8 Good6 Reviews
11

Juarez

Juarez Mexican • $
124 Broadway, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Taco De Car Nitas Pork Taco
Quesadillas
Huarache

“This is as close to Mexico as you can get—not only the food but also the friendly and helpful service. Tacos, fajitas, tortas, chilaquilies are excellent, and after a hiatus for Covid, tamales are back on the weekends and as good as ever. Eat there or bring it home, the food's delicious anywhere.“

3.8 Good17 Reviews
Los Amigos Mexican Restaurant + Bar Mexican • $
640 Broadway, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Torta Milanesa De Pollo Breaded Chicken
Enchiladas Verdes Green Enchiladas
Three Milk Cake 3 Leches
Lengua Taco Tongue Taco
Pollo Taco Chicken Taco
Shrimp Taco
Guacamole

“The food at Los Amigos Mexican Restaurant + Bar was absolutely delicious—full of flavor and served fresh. 🌮🌯 Everything tasted authentic and well-prepared, and the portions were generous.

The service was excellent! The staff was friendly, attentive, and made sure everything was just right throughout the meal.

The atmosphere was lively and welcoming, making it a perfect spot to enjoy with friends or family. 🎶🍹 The vibe really added to the experience.

Overall, I had a fantastic time here. Highly recommend if you’re looking for great Mexican food, great service, and a fun atmosphere!“

3.9 Good55 Reviews
Los Portales Mexican • $
295 Broadway, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Quesadilla Tex
Carnitas

“Letitia is absolutely amazing! My daughter always has a great time!“

3.8 Good38 Reviews
BJ's Deli Cafe’ Cafe • $
174 Broadway, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Mojarra Frita
Tacos Pizza

“best Mexican food I've ever had. the burrito and quesadilla are the bomb“

4.5 Superb25 Reviews
Tulum Mexican Restaurant Tex-Mex • $$
136 Lake St, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Steak and Shrimp Fajitas
Chicken Tacos Dordas Tacos
Tulum Sopa de Mariscos
Passion Fruit Shot
Chicken Fajitas
Shrimp Ceviche
Refried Beans
Lime Ceviche
Chicken Taco
House Salad

“I eat here with friends often and live fairly close. However the four times I have ordered at night to have food delivered, there is ALWAYS something missing. Tonight I got NO flour tortillas for my fajitas! Usually they would bring the missing item out to me but tonight all I got was "the mailbox on this number has not been set up yet". I can't drive at night so I had home delivery but I think I'm finally done with them.“

3.7 Good87 Reviews
Alejandra's Mexican • $$
388 12550, 390 Broadway, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Tostas Cubanas

“Deliciosos platillos y económicos“

3.4 Good39 Reviews
Taco Bell Fast Food • $
1412 NY-300, Newburgh

Customers` Favorites

Cheesy Bean and Rice Burrito
Mtn Dew Baja Blast Freeze
Chicken Quesadilla Combo
Cheesy Gordita Crunch
Chalupa Cravings Box
Ground Beef Burrito
Crunchwrap Supreme
Chicken Quesadilla
Nachos Bellgrande
Cinnamon Twists

“Excellent, the tacos & the burritos were great. Quite tasty & quick for a tasty bite.

Wheelchair accessibility: They had two wheelchair tables available for sitting. One table had flowers on it. Very pleasant & inviting.“

3.1 Average105 Reviews

Newburgh’s Other Flavors

You May Also Like