Golden Guernsey Ice Cream
15 Main St, Oneonta
(607) 432-7209
Customers' Favorites
Death by Chocolate
Black Raspberry
Peanut Sundae
Cotton Candy
Large Sunday
Strawberry
Brownie
Hotdog
Cannoli
Menu
Photos
+28 photos
+27 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Charming ice cream shop with old timey ambiance. We stopped because of east on/off on I-88. They use Perry’s Ice Cream, which is just OK ice cream. The flavor variety was disappointing. We shared a large and wanted 3 balance flavors - vanilla based, chocolate based and a special flavor. Out of 37 listed flavors, only 3 are chocolate based. The only one we considered (don’t like raspberry or mint) was the dregs at the bottom, which we did not want (we asked if they pull out...
So after you left the park we hung out up there a little bit longer tell Galaxy started showing signs of overheating then we went down to Golden Guernsey which was a disappointment compared to how it had been years prior. I mean yeah for a pup cup a milkshake a small cotton candy ice cream and med ice cream with sprinkles may have only cost a little over 20 bucks but they don't have the flavor that they used to and the customer service could use some touching up they treat...
The ice cream here is wonderful! I especially love the pumpkin pie flavor in the fall—it’s the perfect balance of pumpkin without too much nutmeg. The banana cream pie is another favorite of mine. They also offer soft serve, which is great on a hot day. Overall, it’s a solid spot for a sweet treat when you're craving something cool and delicious!
You May Also Like
Alfresco's Italian Bistro - 26 Main St
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Vegetarian
Dazzo's Kitchen - 42 River St
![]()
Wine Bar, Tapas/Small Plates, Modern European, Pizza
Bella Michael's Restaurant - 57 River St
![]()
Italian, Seafood