Barbeque Restaurants in Ontario, NY

Heintzelman's BBQ Pit Barbecue • $$
6361 Knickerbocker Rd, Ontario

Customers` Favorites

Half Rack of Ribs with Smoked BBQ Beans
Smoked Mac and Cheese
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Smokey Baked Beans
Garlic Parm Fries
Hour Pulled Pork
Pit Style Wings
Sampler Platter
Macaroni Salad
Pulled Chicken

“Long review since there were 5 of us!! Had a taste for bbq and our original plans fell through so decided to try this place after seeing pictures and Facebook posts. We were definitely not disappointed. The kids all got milkshakes that were creamy and delicious. We then started with the corn bombs that came with a spicy cream dip which went great with the sweetness of the corn. Two of us also got the clam chowder, which is one of the best I've had in a while - creamy, chunky, and a great taste.Boy 1 got the prime Philly sandwich with the garlic parm fries and pork Mac and cheese. The sandwich was stacked with plenty of steak and toppings. The fries were loaded with the garlic parm. The side of Mac was decent size which was very good, but wished it was a bit creamier.Boy 2 got the charbroiled wings with the dawn special sauce. He doesn't like blue cheese, but I loved it.Youngest got the hot dog Mac and cheese with fries, and it was a huge portion for a kids meal. Again, just wish it was a little creamier.Wifey had the plate and it was huge!! She really enjoyed the sides and smoked Cheeseburger, even the meat sauce which she never eats.I went with the 16oz prime rib - call and reserve if you want it as they were almost out before 6, and you absolutely need to try this. The crust seasoning was exceptional and the meat was cooked perfectly. My sides were the Cajun corn and the baked beans, which were both amazing. I would request a bigger dish of au jus and horseradish.Sadly we didn't have enough room for dessert but it's on the list for next time.Parking: To both sides of the restaurant and some in the back around the next door buildingKid-friendliness: Great kids menuWheelchair accessibility: Easy access“

4 Good68 Reviews