Nick's Pizza
61 State St, Otisville
(845) 386-2222
Customers' Favorites
Eggplant Parmigiana
Everything Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
W Pepperoni
Menu
Photos
+31 photos
+30 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
It was our first time in this specific area, and we just happened to find Nick's very close to where we were staying. There's a constant flow of customers, even at off times, so you know that's a good sign right off the bat.
Highly recommend the veggie pizza (it has chunks of eggplant parm on it!!!) along with the eggplant Parm itself, the lasagna (full of meat), the tortellini and the penne pasta. Their red sauce is out this world.
Everything...
Highly recommend the veggie pizza (it has chunks of eggplant parm on it!!!) along with the eggplant Parm itself, the lasagna (full of meat), the tortellini and the penne pasta. Their red sauce is out this world.
Everything...
The food was excellent! It was my first time here and I was shocked to see the lunch special posted two cheese slices and a soda for only $5. I haven't seen prices like that in years and years. I think this is the first time I will ever say this in. Probably the last that there was actually too much meat on the pizza LOL. The chicken bacon ranch. I took some off and moved it on to my cheese slice. Everything was so so so so so so good. I can't wait to go back.
You May Also Like
Pizza Mania - 9 Main St
![]()
Pizza, Burgers, Wraps
Yong He Yuan - 185 Grange Rd Suite 1
![]()
Chinese, Chicken Wings, Sushi Bar
The service here is consistently warm and welcoming, which is a testament to the care and dedication that comes from a family-run establishment....