Pizza Mania

9 Main St, Otisville
(845) 386-1010

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Robert Sagala

Unfortunately we will no longer go here for a quick local meal. Chicken parm sandwich was made of small chunks of "chicken" which were mostly gristle and fatty parts of what should have been a full chicken breast, that is pounded out and breaded etc. Nope. Never seen a chicken parm made this way because it is NOT the way chicken parm has ever been made. This was leftover chunks that I wouldn't feed my dog. It didn't even taste like chicken which was weird. The amount of salt used for the sandwich seemed like it was intentional to cover up the fact the chicken was inedible. Then the french fries were totally dried up and wrinkled and soggy. I was going to bring the food back but life is too busy to waste that time and gas money, so I just wont waste my money there again. This type of food should NEVER be allowed to leave the restaurant and force people to write a Zero Star review. Quality Control would help this issue, but I will not have to worry about that again. Now ill go to a place a little farther away but never a bad meal and they deserve good customers.

Food: 1

Tammy Haggerty-Borrillo

Brian and the crew are always so friendly when we go there and it's like a family atmosphere ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Well Done Cheese Pizza

guymard

So friendly, good people good food!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Brianna Best

Not only is the food amazing but the owners are incredible! Super family friendly atmosphere at a great price. We have been going since before our daughter was born and now she loves our Friday tradition. She lights up the second she realizes we are there. Thank you Pizza Mania for always being consistently amazing!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Janine greer

Food was fantastic. Ordered a calzone, Stromboli and sides of meatballs and sausage Portions were enormous family size! They sent large cups of extra sauce. Delivery prompt and polite. Amazing dinner!

Food: 5

Service: 5

charlotte woeckener

I got 2 pizzas today an boy thay were awesome thank you

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brian Pulos

Place looked very empty an u better bring cash they do have ATM inside but honestly I won't go back ppl were ok pizza not great when it was over by train station years ago it was best pizza I ever had but now no but that's my

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Chiamani Accogliente

Gets the job done

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Andrew

Good Food Great People

Krys Id

Out of the two pizza places in town, this is definitely the one you want to go with. Friendly staff, affordable prices, fast delivery times. Overall just great customer service, where Nick’s just always acts like you’re inconveniencing them by calling.

Anthony Schifano

Love the pizza, love that they deliver, but will never understand how they wouldn’t be open on Super Bowl Sunday, probably the biggest money maker of the year. I get they’re closed on Sunday’s, but that day…that’s our place and that’s where I wanted to order from.

Mike DePolito

Love the Christian ✝️ atmosphere. Food very good and Brian and Cindy very nice

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Krysta Idel

Out of the two pizza places in town, this is definitely the one you want to go with. Friendly staff, affordable prices, fast delivery times. Overall just great customer service, where Nick’s just always acts like you’re inconveniencing them by calling.

L Gage

I have always said that pizza should be its own food group I love pizza but the past few years I have not been able to find a good pizza my favorite pizza place changed hands and that was the end of that well I went to Pizza Mania today OMG what a awesome Pizza the best pizza I have had in years I just moved into the area and I am so happy I have a pizza place that I love a bar that I have to try out and a liquor store that I love in the same Corner OMG I am so happy try Pizza Mania it is awesome and the guys are really nice

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gammy Gage

I have always said that pizza should be its own food group I love pizza but the past few years I have not been able to find a good pizza my favorite pizza place changed hands and that was the end of that well I went to Pizza Mania today OMG what a awesome Pizza the best pizza I have had in years I just moved into the area and I am so happy I have a pizza place that I love a bar that I have to try out and a liquor store that I love in the same Corner OMG I am so happy try Pizza Mania it is awesome and the guys are really nice

Loading...