German Restaurants near Oyster Bay, NY

“My Lodge. PM i would not have any other way. SMIB“

“An excellent menu, the food was terrific, a huge selection of tap beer and best of all the live band was awesome. We definitely recommend Prost for a memorial night out.“

“Ate at the restaurant back in July 2025. They were struggling. Decided to try it again tonight. We met Michael the manager. He has this place dialed in. The food was off the hook. Drinks outstanding. The staff very attentive. I had to go outside to check the sign make sure I was in the right place. Atmosphere was great and the establishment was family friendly. Rumor has it they'll be offering brunch in three weeks. I plan to return with my sister and brother in law. I'm happy to report the White Whale is back and better than ever. Well done Michael!!!“