Mama Mia’s Pizza & Pasta (Formerly Pietro’s Oyster Bay)
342 Lexington Ave, Oyster Bay
(516) 226-1243
Customers' Favorites
Brooklyn Sicilian Pie Slice
Sausage and Peppers
Eggplant Rollatini
Chicken Alla Vodka
Margherita Pizza
Pepperoni Bites
Sugar Knots
House Salad
Rice Ball
Meatballs
Featured items
20 oz. Bottle
Mozzarella Sticks (6)
Breaded Mozzarella Served with Marinara Sauce.
2 Liter Bottle
Fresh Filled Cannoli
Regular Pizza 10"
San Marzano Tomato Sauce. Grande Whole Milk Mozzarella.
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Golden chicken cutlet, Crispy bacon ranch dressing whole milk mozzarella
Sanpelegrino
Garlic Knots (12)
Delicious mini pizza dough knots tossed in garlic, parmesan, oregano and olive oil
NY Style Cheesecake
Vodka Pizza
Large Pellegrino
Campagnola
Crumbled sausage, sun dried tomatoes, broccoli rabe, a touch of fresh mozarella & a whisper of garlic & oil.
Prosciutto
San marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, proscuitto & basil.
French Fries Small
Buffalo
Thin crust, tender buffalo chicken , sprinkled lightly with mozzarella.
Vegetable
Green peppers, onions, broccoli, & mushrooms.
Late Night Menu
Garlic Knots (12)
Delicious mini pizza dough knots tossed in garlic, parmesan, oregano and olive oil
Mozzarella Sticks (6)
Breaded Mozzarella Served with Marinara Sauce.
French Fries Small
To Good To Go Box
Brick Oven Pizzette (10" Pie)
Pizza Margherita
San marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, garlic & basil drizzled with virgin olive oil
Vodka Pizza
Regular Pizza 10"
San Marzano Tomato Sauce. Grande Whole Milk Mozzarella.
Buffalo
Thin crust, tender buffalo chicken , sprinkled lightly with mozzarella.
Prosciutto
San marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, proscuitto & basil.
Vegetable
Green peppers, onions, broccoli, & mushrooms.
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Golden chicken cutlet, Crispy bacon ranch dressing whole milk mozzarella
Rustico
Crumbled sausage, dried tomato, & mozzarella drizzled with a virgin olive oil.
Campagnola
Crumbled sausage, sun dried tomatoes, broccoli rabe, a touch of fresh mozarella & a whisper of garlic & oil.
BBQ
Thin crust, plum tomatoes, sprinkled lightly with mozzarella.
Ultra Thin Cheese Pizza
Paper Thin Cheese Pizza
Melanzana
Diced eggplant, roasted peppers, mushrooms, & homemade mozzarella over marinara sauce.
Ultra Thin Peperoni Pizza
Whole Wheat Bar Pie
Thin Crust, Plum Tomatoes Grande mozzarella
Pepperoni Americano Pizzetta
Meat Lover Pizzetta
Shrimp Pesto Pizzetta
Beverages
2 Liter Bottle
20 oz. Bottle
Small Pelegrino
Sanpelegrino
Water
Large Pellegrino
Dessert
NY Style Cheesecake
Fresh Filled Cannoli
Sugar Knots (6)
Cinnamon Mini fried pastries!
Sugar Knots (12)
Featured items
Cheese
Neapolitan Round Crust with Grande Mozzarella and Plum Style Tomato Sauce made with Basil and Olive Oil Fresh and simply unforgettable!
Pasta Alfredo (Most Loved)
Parmesan infused cream sauce. Served with garlic knots
Mozzarella Sticks (6)
Breaded Mozzarella Served with Marinara Sauce.
2 Liter Bottle
Traditional Pasta Alla Vodka (Best Seller)
Vodka pink cream sauce, prosciutto, and Romano cheese.
Fresh Filled Cannoli
Minestrone
Drunken Style Chicken Hero
Golden fried chicken cutlets in vodka sauce topped with melted Mozzarella.
Pasta Salvatore
Broccoli rabe, Italian sausage, sun-dried tomatoes In A Garlic And Oil Sauce.
Chicken Francese Dinner
Boneless chicken breast sauteed in a lemon, butter & wine sauce
Pasta Bolognese
Slow braised ground beef, our marinara sauce, tossed with al dente pasta and topped with our parmesan blend.
Pasta With Meatballs
Our famous beef meatballs braised in our house marinara sauce topped with parmesan blend.
Upside Down Sicilian
the way it's done in the old neighborhood
Pasta With White Clam Sauce
Clams in you choice of garlic wine sauce or marinara sauce.
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Baked Ziti
Meat Lover's
Sauteed Broccoli Rabe
Pasta With Pesto Sauce
Regular Pizza 10"
San Marzano Tomato Sauce. Grande Whole Milk Mozzarella.
Appetizers
Broccoli Bites (6)
Garlic Knots (6)
Delicious mini pizza dough knots tossed in garlic, parmesan, oregano and olive oil
Pepperoni Bites
Pepperoni bites are savory, bite-sized treats featuring pepperoni, melted mozzarella, and a crispy sesame seed topping.
Garlic Knots (12)
Delicious mini pizza dough knots tossed in garlic, parmesan, oregano and olive oil
Zucchini Sticks
Panko breaded zucchini served with tomato sauce.
Mozzarella Sticks (6)
Breaded Mozzarella Served with Marinara Sauce.
Chicken Fingers
with fries
Chicken Bites
buffalo or BBQ served w/ blue cheese dressing
Fried Calamari
Golden Fried Calamari served with side of marinara sauce
Garlic Bread
French Fries Small
Stuffed Mushrooms
Baked Clams (6)
Baked clams oreganata, 1/2 dozen
Buffalo Calamari
tossed in hot sauce, served w/ blue cheese dressing
Zuppa de Mussels (cultured mussels)
marinara: plum tomatoes, basil & garlic, Posillipo: garlic & white wine sauce
Garlic Knots (6)
Italian Sampler
Fried calamari, Zucchini sticks, mozzarella sticks, stuffed mushrooms
Marinara sauce on the side.
Insalate (Salads) Dinner
Cobb Salad
Mixed greens, chicken, tomato, bacon, hard boiled egg, red onion
Antipasti Salad
Salami, pepperoni, cucumber, olives, tomatoes, mozzarella, pepperoncini
House Salad
Iceberg Lettuce, fresh tomato, cucumber, shredded carrots red onions olives
and Balsamic Vinaigrette On the side.
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, garlic-herb croutons, and Caesar dressing.
Caprese Salad
Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes & basil, served with our homemade balsamic vinaigrette
Buffalo Chicken Salad
iceberg lettuce, romaine, Cherry tomato, Red Onions, Shredded carrots, Spicy Buffalo chicken creamy blue cheese dressing on the side.
Greek Salad Lg
ceberg Lettuce, Fresh Tomatoes, Cucumber, Onions, Olives, Shredded Carrots Feta Cheese. dressing on the side.
Heros
Chicken Parmigiana Hero (Most Liked)
Chicken Cutlets in tomato sauce with melted mozzarella on Italian bread.
Drunken Style Chicken Hero
Golden fried chicken cutlets in vodka sauce topped with melted Mozzarella.
Paesano Hero
Grilled Chicken, Broccoli Rabe, Fresh Mozzarella.
Shrimp Parmigiana Hero
Golden Fried Shrimp, Our delicious homemade tomato sauce whole milk mozzarella.
Grilled Chicken Cutlet Hero
Iceberg lettuce, tomato, mayo
Sausage Parmigiana Hero
Italian Sausage tomato sauce with melted mozzarella on Italian bread.
Eggplant Parmigiana Hero
Fried Eggplant tomato sauce with melted mozzarella on Italian bread.
Meatball Pamigiana Hero
Homemade meatballs, tomato sauce, Whole milk mozzarella.
Veal Parmigiana Hero
Veal Cutlet in tomato sauce with melted mozzarella on Italian bread.
Cold Italiano Hero
Ham, salami, provolone, iceberg lettuce, tomatoes & our signature house dressing, provolone
Sausage, Peppers & Onions Hero
Sausage, peppers & Onions In Garlic oil.
Pasta Specialties Dinner
Traditional Pasta Alla Vodka (Best Seller)
Vodka pink cream sauce, prosciutto, and Romano cheese.
Pasta Alfredo (Most Loved)
Parmesan infused cream sauce. Served with garlic knots
Pasta Bolognese
Slow braised ground beef, our marinara sauce, tossed with al dente pasta and topped with our parmesan blend.
Pasta With Pesto Sauce
Pasta With Marinara Sauce
Pasta Meat Sauce
Pasta With White Clam Sauce
Clams in you choice of garlic wine sauce or marinara sauce.
Pasta With Meatballs
Our famous beef meatballs braised in our house marinara sauce topped with parmesan blend.
Pasta With Broccoli
Pasta With Tomato Sauce
Pasta With Sausage
Pasta With Red Clam Sauce
Clams in you choice of garlic wine sauce or marinara sauce.
Pasta With Garlic & Oil
Pasta With Broccoli Rabe
Garlic & Oil.
Pasta Ala Carbonara
Pancetta, peas, and shallots in a cream sauce.
Pasta Salvatore
Broccoli rabe, Italian sausage, sun-dried tomatoes In A Garlic And Oil Sauce.
Pasta Campagnola
Fresh garlic, sweet crumbled sausage, broccoli rabe and cannellini beans in a garlic & oil sauce.
Rigatoni Fiorentina
Grilled chicken, Fresh Spinach in a creamy vodka sauce topped with melted mozzarella. Side salad on the side.
Whole Wheat Penne Pasta Rustica
Grilled chicken, artichoke hearts, mushroom, sun-dried tomatoes in a garlic oil sauce. Mama Mia delicious!
Served with a side salad.
Pasta With Chicken & Broccoli
Grilled chicken, Chopped tomatoes, broccoli Garlic oil.
Linguini With Shrimp & Broccoli
Shrimp, broccoli, Chopped Tomatoes, Garlic Oil
Pasta Al Forno (Baked Dished) Dinner
Baked Ziti (Popular)
Creamy ricotta, tomato sauce. Topped with Grande mozzarella and a parmesan blend. Served with bread.
Baked Ravioli
Served with tomato sauce. Served with bread
Lasagna
Our homemade lasagna features layers of slow braised beef, creamy ricotta, al dente pasta sheets, our marinara sauce, our parmesan blend, and stretchy mozzarella. Served with bread.
Baked Ziti Siciliano
Manicotti
Ricotta stuffed Mini-rolls topped with tomato sauce and Mozzarella.
Stuffed Shells
Ricotta stuffed shells, topped with tomato sauce, and mozzarella. Served with bread
Specialita Di Pollo (Chicken Entrees)
Chicken Parm Dinner (Top Seller)
Golden fried chicken cutlets with tomato sauce with melted mozzarella. Served with bread and with your choice of pasta.
Chicken Francese Dinner
Boneless chicken breast sauteed in a lemon, butter & wine sauce
Chicken Sorrentinno Dinner
Boneless chicken breast with eggplant, prosciutto & mozzarella in a red sauce
Chicken Marsala Dinner
Boneless chicken breast sauteed with mushrooms in marsala wine sauce
Grilled Chicken Bruschetta
Topped with fresh mozzarella, fresh chopped tomatoes, onions & Topped with balsamic glazed.
Chicken Cutlet Milanese
Breaded chicken cutlet
Chicken Piccata Dinner
Boneless chicken breast sauteed in a lemon white win caper sauce
Chicken Verdi
Egg battered chicken, white wine lemon butter sauce, broccoli, and mozzarella cheese.
Chicken Alla Vodka
Breaded chicken, melted mozzarella, and creamy vodka sauce.
Breaded Chicken Bruschetta
Topped with fresh mozzarella, fresh chopped tomatoes, onions & topped with balsamic glazed.
Grilled Chicken And Broccoli Rabe Dinner
Served with your choice of pasta and a side salad. Bread on the side.
Chicken Monte Carlo
breast of chicken topped with eggplant, mozzarella cheese and peppers with marinara sauce.
Chicken & Eggplant Tower (Popular)
Breaded chicken cutlet, eggplant in a creamy vodka sauce topped with fresh mozzarella. Choice of pasta with tomato sauce and side salad.
Specialita De Melanzane (Eggplant Entrees)
Eggplant parmigiana Dinner
Baked eggplant in tomato sauce topped with mozzarella
Eggplant Rollantini Dinner
Baked eggplant stuffed with ricotta & mozzarella
Eggplant Rollatini with Spinach Dinner
Baked eggplant stuffed with ricotta, sauteed spinach & mozzarella
Specialita Di Vitello (Veal Entrees)
Veal Piccata Dinner
Veal sauteed in a lemon white wine caper sauce
Veal Cutlet Milanese Dinner
Breaded veal cutlet served on bed
Veal Cutlet Parmigiana Dinner
Breaded veal cutle topped with tomato saue & mozzarella
Veal Marsala Dinner
Veal sauteed with mushrooms in marsala wine sauce
Veal Francese Dinner
Veal Sauteed in a lemon, butter & white wine sauce
Veal Sorrentinno Dinner
Veal with eggplant, prociutto & mozzarella in a red sauce
Veal Alla Pietro Dinner
Veal topped with fresh grilled eggplant & roasted peppers in a sherry wine sauce
Specialita De Pesce (Seafood Entrees)
Seafood Platter
Clams, mussels, shrimp, calamari served with a mild or spicy marinara sauce
Shrimp Francese
Shrimp sauteed in a lemon, butter & white wine sauce
Shrimp Marinara or Fra Diavolo
Shrimp sauteed in marinara sauce (mild or hot)
Shrimp Scampi
Delicately seasoned shrimp sauteed in a light butter, garlic & white wine sauce
Shrimp Oreganata
Breaded shrimp in a garlic, white wine sauce topped with seasoned breadcrumbs
Shrimp Parm Dinner
Breaded shrimp with sauce & melted mozzarella cheese
Brick Oven Pizzette (10" Pie)
Pizza Margherita
San marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, garlic & basil drizzled with virgin olive oil
Vodka Pizza
Regular Pizza 10"
San Marzano Tomato Sauce. Grande Whole Milk Mozzarella.
Buffalo
Thin crust, tender buffalo chicken , sprinkled lightly with mozzarella.
Prosciutto
San marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, proscuitto & basil.
Vegetable
Green peppers, onions, broccoli, & mushrooms.
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Golden chicken cutlet, Crispy bacon ranch dressing whole milk mozzarella
Rustico
Crumbled sausage, dried tomato, & mozzarella drizzled with a virgin olive oil.
Campagnola
Crumbled sausage, sun dried tomatoes, broccoli rabe, a touch of fresh mozarella & a whisper of garlic & oil.
BBQ
Thin crust, plum tomatoes, sprinkled lightly with mozzarella.
Ultra Thin Cheese Pizza
Paper Thin Cheese Pizza
Melanzana
Diced eggplant, roasted peppers, mushrooms, & homemade mozzarella over marinara sauce.
Ultra Thin Peperoni Pizza
Whole Wheat Bar Pie
Thin Crust, Plum Tomatoes Grande mozzarella
Pepperoni Americano Pizzetta
Meat Lover Pizzetta
Shrimp Pesto Pizzetta
Round Specialty Pies
Cheese
Neapolitan Round Crust with Grande Mozzarella and Plum Style Tomato Sauce made with Basil and Olive Oil Fresh and simply unforgettable!
Special Pie (Everything)
Buffalo Chicken
Margherita
Hawaiian
Meat Lover's
White Pie
Thin crust topped with melted mozzarella and ricotta cheese.
Baked Ziti
Eggplant (Ricotta)
Chicken Marsala
Vegetable
Chicken Ricotta
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Broccoli Pie (Ricotta)
BBQ Chicken
Chicken & Broccoli
Chicken & Tomato
Francese
Special Pie (Ricotta)
Square Specialty Pies
Grandma Pizza
thin crust topped covered with mozzarella & splashed with imported san marzano
Brooklyn Sicilian
thick crsut topped with crumbled sausage
Crispino Mushroom
thin crust toped with fresh mozzarella and sauteed mushrooms
Gorgonzola
thin crust with mesculin lettuce, sundried & fresh-dices tomatoes, red onions sprinkled with gorgonzola cheese
Upside Down Sicilian
the way it's done in the old neighborhood
Crispino
thin crust topped with sliced tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers & basil
Regular Sicilian
Grandma Rustico (grilled chicken or crumbled sausage)
thin crust with either chicken or crumbled sausage & broccoli rabe
Marinara (old world favorite)
thin crust with a zesty marinara sauce topped with basil, no cheese
Grandma Tuscana
thin crust with homemade crumbled sausage and vodka sauce topped with a sprinkle of pecorino romano
Vodka
Sicilian Eggplant (ricotta)
Whole Pie
Zuppe (Soups)
Chicken Noodle
Minestrone
Pasta Fagioli
Lentil
Verdura
Sauteed Spinach
Sauteed Broccoli Rabe
Sauteed Broccoli Florets
Sauteed Mushrooms
Mixed Veggie Plate
Calzones, Rolls & Knotts
Chicken Roll
Cheese Calzone
Spinach Roll
Rice Ball Parmigiana
Pepperoni Pinwheel
Ham & Cheese Calzone
Rice Ball
Buffalo Roll
Eggplant Roll
Sausage Peppers & Onion Roll
Paesano Panini
Grilled chicken, Broccoli Rabe Fresh mozzarella.
House Panini
Fried chicken, lettuce, tomato fresh mozzarella bacon mayo.
Beverages
2 Liter Bottle
20 oz. Bottle
Small Pelegrino
Sanpelegrino
Water
Large Pellegrino
Dessert
NY Style Cheesecake
Fresh Filled Cannoli
Sugar Knots (6)
Cinnamon Mini fried pastries!
Sugar Knots (12)
Sides
Side Of Meatballs
Simmered In our delicious Pomodoro sauce
Side of Italian Sausage
With Tomato sauce
Pizza By The Slice
Cheese Slice
Sicilian Slice
Grandma Slice
Upside Down Sicilian
Brooklyn Sicilian Slice
Sicilian Slice topped with crumbled sausage
Crispino Slice
Thin crust topped with fresh tomatoes, fresh mozzarella and roasted red peppers.
Crispino with mushrooms slice
Thin crust fresh mozzarella mushroom
Crispino Slice with eggplant
Thin crust fresh tomato fresh mozzarella red peppers and breaded eggplant
Chicken Francaise Slice
Chicken Marsala Slice
Grilled Chicken Caesar Slice
Baked Ziti Slice
Rigatoni Ala Vodka Slice
Grandma Ala Vodka Slice
Pepperoni Slice
BBQ Chicken Slice
Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice
Buffalo Chicken Slice
Veggie Delight Slice
Margaritha Slice
Cheese Slice with Sausage
Cheese Slice With Bacon
Chicken Chipotle Slice
Chicken Chipotle With Bacon Slice
Sweet Chili Chicken Slice
Photos
+46 photos
+45 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
My family and I were in the oyster bay area and we were in the mood for some pizza. We came to Mama Mia's because of the 4.5 rating and we were not disappointed. We ordered a pizza pie for the kids. I got Penne alla vodka w. Chicken. My husband ordered Penne Alfredo w. Shrimp. It was all so delicious. The food was cooked perfectly and the service was amazing! We left full and happy. I definitely recommend. If you are in the area stop at Mama Mia's !
September 2024
Love this pizza, crispy crust and great seasonings. Large selection of specialty slices. I had the sauteed mushroom and the Bruchetta. Both were delicious. I've been there twice very recently. I understand that it is under new ownership. They are doing a great job!
June 2024
I've ordered food from Mama Mia's for both my office and family, and let me tell you, they never disappoint. Whether it's takeout or delivery, they are consistently great - always on time, and the food tastes fresh and delicious. Marlo, the new owner, is truly the best!
March 2024
You May Also Like
AMERICAN HOUSE SALAD AND AMERICAN HOME BREAKFAST - 103 Pine Hollow Rd
![]()
Salad, Wraps, Mexican
Del's Bar & Grill - 129 Pine Hollow Rd
![]()
Bar & Grill, Beer Bar, American
Home Sweet Home Cafe - 19 Summit St
![]()
Latin American