Umberto's of Oyster Bay
CLOSED$$ •
About Umberto's of Oyster Bay
Umberto's of Oyster Bay Reviews
The pizza was excellent and just as good as the New Hyde Park location. We loved everything about both the Sicilian and Regular pizza.🍕🍕🍕. We highly recommend and will be back!!!!
Amazing! Tastes just as good as NHP. In my opinion, best pizza in the Oyster Bay area in a LONG time! The Thompson’s highly recommended! 💯 👍🏼
Best slice in town
Umberto's of Oyster Bay serves a variety of dishes, including Sicilian pizza slices, spaghetti, and vegetarian/vegan options. Many customers have praised the flavors and quality of their meals, especially the pizza, with highlights such as the Grandma's crust. Although some have noted small portion sizes and high prices, the overall experience is positive. Reviewers describe the pizza as delicious and the best in town, emphasizing the great customer service and welcoming employees. Visitors appreciate the cozy atmosphere and quality ingredients, making it a popular spot in Oyster Bay. Overall, it’s a place with a wide range of choices that many enjoy returning to.