50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Oyster Bay

“This place is a well kept secret. The food is great. We have had pizza, calzones, garlic knots and various pasta dishes. All were excellent. Prices are reasonable, servings are large, staff is friendly, the place is clean and there is plenty of parking. I highly recommend LaBell Pizza!“

“I absolutely loved their Burrata Slice. Delicious! My husband loves both the BBQ and Buffalo chicken slices and my kids can’t wait for Pizza Fridays now!! As a long time local I am so happy they made the change and have you in Oyster Bay!“

“We catered our Easter dinner from Pizza Cucina in Westbury. The food was fabulous, especially the Shrimp Scampi, which is something we have not ordered as yet. The meal was on time and everyone made comments about how good the food was. Thank you for a great Easter dinner?“

“The absolute best pizza in the surrounding towns. The vegetable sides, heroes, and salads are wonderful too—we especially love the eggplant parm hero and the broccoli rabe with garlic. Just fantastic.

What makes Mario’s in Oyster Bay especially wonderful, though, are the people. Everyone is always warm, friendly, and welcoming. Even when you’re simply picking up an order, there’s a genuine sense of hospitality that somehow makes the already delicious food taste even better. A neighborhood gem.“

“Hands down, one of the finest restaurants on the North Shore. Be sure to make a reservation, as it's intimate. Top notch Chef with a staff to match.“

“We celebrated my dad’s 80th bday in one of the igloos. We had such a nice time. My dad loved the unique experience and the food was absolutely delicious.“

“Great pizza and very hospitable! Sincerely, a Jersey girl.“

“Amazingly flavorful pizza with fresh ingredients! I loved the Metro East, cant wait to try some of the others!!!“

“Today we had my daughter’s high school graduation party at Red Volpe ! it housed 50 people in their aide party room- we chose buffet style- we did cash bar - and it was AH amazing ! Salvatore (the owner) and his staff were on point ! Thirty teens plus the rest of the crowd can’t stop raving about the food - chicken francais- chicken parm - vodka pasta- caesar salad- rolls - mozzarella sticks- meatballs- we got to choose what we wanted and we designed the menu ! Sal scooped italian ices for dessert and I also brought in NoFoDoCo custom mini doughnuts. I sat in the bar area and Sal made amazing drinks- blueberry smash is one of my new faves ! We also created a little space for photo back drop ! This local place is a great addition to Bethpage and cannot wait to frequent it for dinners and lunches. I have also had their pizza which is delicious as well !“

“Was just there Friday night for the first time, visiting from Saratoga Lake. They had a great menu, delicious food, and the staff were incredible. I think the woman talking to my friends who had a newborn baby may have been Flora.. Never asked. :) You're going to have a great time here, and try the Limoncello!“

“DELISH!! Uriel & staff are so nice ! Hands down the BEST PIZZA! WELCOME to EAST MEADOW!!“

“creativos algo diferente...es más que pizzas.“

“Staff was incredible and the food was delish! Highly recommend! Did I tell you the drinks were awesome?!“

“Amazing and very friendly staff“

“Ate at this establishment in Farmingdale yesterday evening! Best pizza we have ever had! Fast friendly service will definitely be returning when I come back area“

“Kira was amazing! She was attentive and so kind! I was beyond grateful for her wonderful service. Kira took the time to ensure that we were confortable and she did a great job sharing the restaurant’s specials! The food was really good and filling! Wonderful summer specials and the desert was delicious! I would def go back to try other plates! Also the atmosphere was great!“

“They make the absolutely best Pizza 🍕 the GRAMMA PIZZA US JUST THE BEST!!!“

“Great food and outstanding services. Highly recommended.“

“Unbelievable gem. Red pie was outstanding, goes toe to toe with any New Haven style (speaking from ample experience). Service was courteous, timely, and down to earth. If you have a soul and love pizza, Nico’s Charred is a MUST have.“

“The Pizza here is some of the best on LongIsland“

“This is pizza to drive miles for!! 😋“

“great host,excellent waitstaff fantastic food a great dining experience very attended. nice fresh food love this place going there since opening day.“

“Absolutely outstanding experience at Galleria of Merrick. The Italian food is exceptional fresh, authentic, full of flavor, and prepared with a level of quality you can immediately taste. From the ingredients to the presentation, everything was excellent. Joey made the experience even better. His professionalism, hospitality, and genuine attention to his customers truly stand out. He makes you feel welcomed and appreciated from the moment you walk in. If you’re looking for incredible Italian food paired with exceptional service, Galleria of Merrick is absolutely worth visiting. Joey and the entire team have earned my highest recommendation and future business.“

“I loved the pizza truck the food and the service was amazing I recommend everyone who loves great food should hire them. They are a family owned business with the friendliest people we really enjoyed having them ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“pass it every night on my way home from work. and decided to meet a friend there sat night. my parents come from Italy and I spent all my summers there as a kid. it is the closes I have ever had to pizza in Italy, my only very small complain is. I wish maybe a few more choices for apps.“

“We're a picky family when it comes to Pizza. Thin crust is important and the sauce should not be boring. We got a Neapolitan Pie yesterday and it was DELICIOUS! I highly recommend their pizza“

“If you’re looking for a caterer, Felico’s is the One! Excellent customer service, delicious food and amazing servers that go above and beyond so your party can be a success.“

“We have a family member in hospice care not too far away, three of us who were staying there quite a bit needed to order dinner. We bought from this place. The food was outstanding. The portions are huge. We ordered three dinners for three of us, there was enough food for 8 people and the taste was incredible. The Italian sauce was delicious. We highly recommend.“

“Really good pizza ! ordered the upside down Sicilian and it was perfect. ordered it well done. The bottom was crispy and the dough was perfect ! Really good pizza sauce ! Also had a plain slice and it was very good! Fried calamari were Very good !“

“Excellent restaurant! Food was delicious, compliments to the chef. Our server Carlos was great! Joe the owner was attentive and accommodating! Would highly recommend!“

“Wanted some authentic NY pizza during my stay. They nailed it! Antipasto is amazing and they couldn’t have been nicer. Kind of want to move to NY just for the food 🤣“

“Just had our 5th grade graduation dance and it was absolutely amazing. The staff, the food and the attention to detail was spot on. Can't wait to have another reason to throw a party at Bar Grazi!!“

“Honestly, this place is so slept on... Krave It has the best pizza in Bayside— by a LANDSLIDE. I love that they use unbromated flour and I appreciate that every piece (even the specialty slices with many heavy toppings) has great structure, no flop. Thin & crispy crust, great ratio of sauce and cheese. I also love how clean the restaurant is. They have some incredible specialty slices that I never knew I needed in my life until I tried them! Especially the “Desi Boy” slice and the “white truffle chicken cutlet” slice. I also have to mention their vodka slice with sesame crust 🤤 Everything in this place is high quality, even their regular slices. Their sandwiches are pretty incredible too, and you can tell that the bread is fresh made in house— you don’t feel bloated or overly stuffed after eating them! The owner is super friendly and even gave us a couple extra slices to try to complete our “pie” when we had already ordered a small variety of slices. The staff are all very friendly and it feels very comfortable and less stuffy than some of the other pizzerias in the area. Happy to give this place my business. Give them a try, you will be back for more!“

“We tried Rosa’s for the 1st time last night & loved it! We’ll be going more often. Very different from the other local pizza shops. Besides the pizza being amazing, I had the best spinach pinwheel ever. So fresh & full. Can’t wait to try more on their menu. Everything we ordered was delicious & ready when we arrived👌“

“Legitimately the best pizza I ever had. I look forward to every pie she makes and I’ve never had one I didn’t like! The calzones and cannolis are ridiculously good too. 11/10 every day“

“My wife and I have ordered from Previti for several years now thru Door Dash. the food has always been excellent. The other day I had a call from Previti. It was the owner, Joe. He told me that my mother had wandered in after having her car bumper come completely loose on Marcus Ave. She had no phone, and was shaken up by the whole ordeal. Joe called me for her, and gave her a cup of hot tea. I went over, picked her up and got her home. Later my wife and I returned to pick up her car. We decided to eat dinner there and take advantage of the pasta night specials. The lasagna and the rigatoni with meat sauce were both excellent. Thank you Joe and staff for taking good care of my mother, and providing us with an excellent meal! All the best!“

“So, I have to admit that after moving to Mineola 2 years ago from Queens, we have been eating our way through the neighborhood. We finally tried Spaghettini and boy, were we upset that we didn’t try them sooner.
Everything I have tried so far from pizza to paninis has been amazing. I cannot recommend them enough.
They are a wonderful neighborhood spot and from what I can tell, many people agree with me as they always seem busy.
We will continue to support this wonderful restaurant.“

“Always A Great Experience here. Food is Great. Staff is Excellent. Best Specialty Pies in the neighborhood. If you have not tried Pappardelle's. You Should !!“

“Food was amazing. Service was excellent, especially Grace and Jay.“

“GET THE KALE CEASAR SALAD!!! I love their pizza but I go for the salad. This restaurant has such a great atmosphere and their menu is very accommodating. Everything on the menu is delicious and if you are strong enough to leave room for dessert, you will be extremely happy. Their cookie and their brownie come in a cast iron skillet and tase homemade and the ice cream and whipped cream make it even more delicious.“

“I live down the block so I'm happy this is a quality pizza place. Their regular, square vodka and chicken bacon ranch slices are great and you get good value for your dollar. The chicken bacon ranch is the best i have ever had. I would have given this place 5 stars if they made the Buffalo chicken and bbq chicken slices like they do the chicken bacon ranch. Unfortunately, those are usually my go to slices but for some reason they take a very different approach than they do the chicken bacon ranch and it definitely doesn't work. I recommend giving this place a try especially if you live in the neighborhood.“

“Crispy Chicken Sandwich 🔥“

“We used Pizza Cucina to cater our daughter's baptism party in our backyard last month! Food was delicious, delivered without an issue and the owner of Pizza Cucina was very nice to work with. All of our guests enjoyed the spread as well and continue to compliment it!“

“Great Food and great service! Buffalo chicken slice is the go-to!“

“Just went there today with the family. I enjoyed my food very much. Got the Manicotti , Chicken fingers w/fries, 2 slices of Cheese pizza, and the Anthony panini. Went home with 2 slices of cheesecake. Food was great waitress was so nice. The staff is super friendly.“

“The best thin crust margarita!“

“Large gluten free menu. Lasagna was delicious, and they seem to try to keep the gluten free food as safe as possible.“

“Love this place ! Always a great meal ! Thanks Daniella !“

“A crispy delight! Delicious sauce. Quality cheese. Amazing crisp. The Sicilian was primo too! Not overly thick. The staff friendly! A great hot slice!“

“Even though I have to travel from 5 towns over, I will do it time and again because I LOVE everything about Mama's. Their Chicken a la Mama, as well as their Granma Vodka pizza brings me to my knees without fail. I'm a bit picky (like extra lemon butter sauce and garlic knots please) but the staff always gets it right. You KNOW a restaurant is top notch when the staff smiles from the moment you walk through the door until you leave. Thank you for everything Mama's. I'll see you again VERY soon. Dont change a thing....“