Kacie and Drew are fantastic hosts and bartenders for this fine, authentic Irish pub. Just spending a few days in Patchogue and can safely say that this evening I have spent here chatting will last in my memories forever Hope to return over the holidays!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Michelle Formisano
Food was very good...I had the meatloaf,my husband had fish and chips for dinner. Cozy little place ..you get that nostalgic feel while being in such in old building.Atomsphere was pretty pleasant. Menu options were descent, we will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Anna Ciralli
Owner judged us when we walked in gave us an attitude before we sat down made us feel uncomfortable. Will never be back again. Save your money and go somewhere else
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ivan martinez
Dined In with friends or family my previous two times here . Went solo today because I been wanting to go back . Sitting at the bar I realized how much of a local bar this is . The bartender knew everyone who came in. I believe his name was joe or John I can’t remember. Really nice guy & checks up on you regularly & gives you the best experience. I wouldn’t say I’m a local since I live 10-15 mins west but I plan on coming here more often because I’ve enjoyed all 3 experiences here . Okay onto the food .. 1900 burger doesn’t miss. The bacon is so crispy & compliments the delicious burger Perfectly. You have the option of Swiss cheddar or American to which I go with American . Each bite is super tasty. The fries are great as well, not your average shoestring fries like you’re used to but still great . Also had a French onion soup which was great as well. My only complaint is the coleslaw . It’s too watery for my liking . Feels like it’s drowning in it. Other than that I love this place a lot . Great vibes .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jerome Curreri
Always a great place for lunch...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pickles, Burgers
Thomas Liguori
Great food Great service reasonable prices
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rosemary Noto
It was terrible I has the burger because the reviews were great... the burger was horrible the french fries if that's what u call them were cold hard and taste old. The onion rings cold sent both back ... they came back out even worse microwaved. Never again
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Kris Hulse
Since I was little Reese's has always been a Patchogue landmark in my opinion. As an adult I love its ol' pub feel, nostalgic. No fancy drinks or IPA beer selection. Just true honest Pub food and spirits! Always has remained true throughout the enormous face-lift the town has gone through and that's what make this place special. Not to mention their Burgers are Delicious and Coleslaw is top notch. True Patchogue Treasure!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pickles, 1900 Burger, Burgers
anthony favichia
Good food and waitstaff,nice atmosphere, friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 1900 Burger, The Rachel, Reuben Sandwich, French Onion Soup
Jackie Balcerak
Super friendly vibe, packed house yet we were seated promptly and with a smile. Drinks came quickly, the food was great. We weren't rushed out the door and we liked how cozy it was.
Awesome place we went to the food is delicious its my first time
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike B
Saturday night had to wait a bit for a table that wasn't any issue. Pot roast special was not good more like sliced roast beef. While finishing dinner the waiter asked if we wanted another drink and we accepted. Five minutes later the manager is harassing us to leave. "I have people waiting why did you order more drinks!". We explained that we were offered drinks and he should talk to his staff if he isn't happy with that. The manager continued to be rude until we left.
Nostalgia gives it 4 stars..this used to be a great place, A REAL IRISH BAR. Quiet now.......
Barbeque Chef
Reeses for lunch...11/28/23Had the burger, with blue cheese, medium rare, cooked to how I like it..very juicy...Crispy fries were great, just way I like emIt's a very good burger..It's in MY top 10-15, no higher...I know people rate this as one of the best around, which it is, but my thinking is there are better burgers out there..I would never diminish, or talk negative about it, it's very good.I would definitely order it againBartender was great...Old school...My favorite kind
Kacie and Drew are fantastic hosts and bartenders for this fine, authentic Irish pub. Just spending a few days in Patchogue and can safely say that this evening I have spent here chatting will last in my memories forever
Hope to return over the holidays!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Food was very good...I had the meatloaf,my husband had fish and chips for dinner.
Cozy little place ..you get that nostalgic feel while being in such in old building.Atomsphere was pretty pleasant. Menu options were descent, we will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Owner judged us when we walked in gave us an attitude before we sat down made us feel uncomfortable. Will never be back again. Save your money and go somewhere else
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Dined In with friends or family my previous two times here . Went solo today because I been wanting to go back . Sitting at the bar I realized how much of a local bar this is . The bartender knew everyone who came in. I believe his name was joe or John I can’t remember. Really nice guy & checks up on you regularly & gives you the best experience. I wouldn’t say I’m a local since I live 10-15 mins west but I plan on coming here more often because I’ve enjoyed all 3 experiences here . Okay onto the food .. 1900 burger doesn’t miss. The bacon is so crispy & compliments the delicious burger Perfectly. You have the option of Swiss cheddar or American to which I go with American . Each bite is super tasty. The fries are great as well, not your average shoestring fries like you’re used to but still great . Also had a French onion soup which was great as well. My only complaint is the coleslaw . It’s too watery for my liking . Feels like it’s drowning in it. Other than that I love this place a lot . Great vibes .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always a great place for lunch...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pickles, Burgers
Great food Great service reasonable prices
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It was terrible I has the burger because the reviews were great... the burger was horrible the french fries if that's what u call them were cold hard and taste old. The onion rings cold sent both back ... they came back out even worse microwaved. Never again
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Since I was little Reese's has always been a Patchogue landmark in my opinion. As an adult I love its ol' pub feel, nostalgic. No fancy drinks or IPA beer selection. Just true honest Pub food and spirits! Always has remained true throughout the enormous face-lift the town has gone through and that's what make this place special. Not to mention their Burgers are Delicious and Coleslaw is top notch. True Patchogue Treasure!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pickles, 1900 Burger, Burgers
Good food and waitstaff,nice atmosphere, friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 1900 Burger, The Rachel, Reuben Sandwich, French Onion Soup
Super friendly vibe, packed house yet we were seated promptly and with a smile. Drinks came quickly, the food was great. We weren't rushed out the door and we liked how cozy it was.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 1900 Burger, Reuben Sandwich
Restaurantji Recommends
Awesome place we went to the food is delicious its my first time
Food: 5
Service: 5
Saturday night had to wait a bit for a table that wasn't any issue. Pot roast special was not good more like sliced roast beef. While finishing dinner the waiter asked if we wanted another drink and we accepted. Five minutes later the manager is harassing us to leave. "I have people waiting why did you order more drinks!". We explained that we were offered drinks and he should talk to his staff if he isn't happy with that. The manager continued to be rude until we left.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Pub w good food. Great meatloaf and mashed
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pickles, 1900 Burger, Reuben Sandwich
Nostalgia gives it 4 stars..this used to be a great place, A REAL IRISH BAR. Quiet now.......
Reeses for lunch...11/28/23Had the burger, with blue cheese, medium rare, cooked to how I like it..very juicy...Crispy fries were great, just way I like emIt's a very good burger..It's in MY top 10-15, no higher...I know people rate this as one of the best around, which it is, but my thinking is there are better burgers out there..I would never diminish, or talk negative about it, it's very good.I would definitely order it againBartender was great...Old school...My favorite kind
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 1900 Burger
Loading...