We have come here several times, and the food is always fresh and well prepared. I am writing this review today specifically about the service level, which is exceptional. On what might be the busiest weekend of the year in Patchogue (St. Paddy’s Day), the servers and bar staff were attentive and fast! In addition, I left my card in the restaurant and the owner himself came after us and hand delivered it. Consider us regulars each time we visit the village. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
GlowCast
Not their fault but it was so loud. Need some sound dampening panels in
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 5
Aamir B
First time experience in this part of Long Island and it was suggested to me by a random person to visit this place to see Jonathan and I must say that he did not disappoint. The experience he gave was not only above and beyond but unexpected. This is my new favorite place as a new resident of Suffolk county. Thanks Jonathan!
We loved WhiskeyNeat. The food was delicious, ample and well-priced (special shout out to the Caesar Salad, hah), the service was very friendly and fast and the overall vibe was great. Music choices mostly good. Will absolutely return.
Rosemary Noto
We were there on a Tuesday afternoon. Happy Hour the bartender was so nice. We had two apps. Wings and duck tacos they were delish. We will be back menu looked great.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
DANALYNNE
The dinner would have been delicious but the skirt stayed came out cold. There were 2 large parties and it appeared that the weight staff could not handle it. We were still in the middle of our appetizers when our entrees came out and again the food was cold. Too much balsamic on burrata salad and grilled octopus. There was also a seating issue so the manager bought us short rib croquet (those were good) but an overall feeling of being rushed out. Our main server was very sweet. Not sure I will return.
The dinner would have been delicious but the skirt stayed came out cold. There were 2 large parties and it appeared that the weight staff could not handle it. We were still in the middle of our appetizers when our entrees came out and again the food was cold. Too much balsamic on burrata salad and grilled octopus. There was also a seating issue so the manager bought us short rib croquet (those were good) but an overall feeling of being rushed out. Our main server was very sweet. Not sure I will return.
Edward Hengeveld
Great food and not too busy at lunch. Very
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Brittany Jenkins
Sania and her raspberry espresso martinis are dynamite. A must try!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kelli Hess
My experience a few Sundays ago at Whiskey Neat was a touchdown, and it had nothing to do with the game on the screens. Let me tell you, the real MVPs of the night were the bartenders, Sonia and her partner (whose name I shamefully forgot, apologies!). These two were a dynamite duo, pumping out high-energy vibes and contagious smiles.From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with genuine warmth and playful banter. The guy whipped up espresso martinis, while Sonia kept the conversation flowing like a seamless handoff. Their chemistry was infectious, their enthusiasm bubbling over with each pour and witty remark. They weren't just serving drinks; they were crafting an experience, one that made us feel like regulars even on our first visit.I can't remember the final score of the game (and honestly, who cares?), but I vividly recall the laughter echoing through the bar, Sonia and her partner were right there with us, riding the emotional rollercoaster of the game, adding their own brand of commentary and keeping the spirits high.By the end of the night, we weren't just leaving a bar; we were leaving a party. We felt like we'd made new friends, all thanks to the magic of the two of them. They turned a casual Sunday night into something truly special, proving that sometimes, the best entertainment comes not from the escreen, but from the people behind the bar.
We had no idea what to expect and I have never heard of the restaurant but apparently we were the last to know. Place was packed and continued to be busy throughout the night. Food and service were excellent. We will definitely go back
Siobhán Mulligan
Excellent food and amazing staff! If you haven’t been here you are missing out. I’m obsessed with their brunch, their drinks and their excellent menu! Fair prices and I’m never disappointed. Don’t forget to check out their happy hour it’s awesome! If you don’t know where to start get the fingerling potatoes and bees knees!!!Vegetarian options: There are many great options. Deviled eggs, potatoes dishes, man and cheese etc and all delicious.Parking: There are lots of paid and unpaid spots available behind whiskey neat.Kid-friendliness: No kids menu but kids are more than welcome and the staff has always been super nice and accommodating to my 3 kids, which I appreciate.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Crispy Short Rib Croquettes, Hot Honey Chicken, Hand Cut Fries App, Deviled Eggs
Alison Kennelly
Best spot in town for food and drinks. Has a great late night vibe too, a nice alternative to the over crowded/super young spots. Highly recommend!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alec OLeary
Great food and cocktails, friendly staff. Will definitely be
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ashley C
Bartenders were super friendly and the food was obviously fresh. The drink menu was fun and had options for everyone in our party. We had the hummus, pastrami sandwich, and the chicken sandwich. All 3 were amazing and we left very happy and satisfied. We will definitely be back!!!
We have come here several times, and the food is always fresh and well prepared. I am writing this review today specifically about the service level, which is exceptional. On what might be the busiest weekend of the year in Patchogue (St. Paddy’s Day), the servers and bar staff were attentive and fast! In addition, I left my card in the restaurant and the owner himself came after us and hand delivered it. Consider us regulars each time we visit the village. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not their fault but it was so loud. Need some sound dampening panels in
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 5
First time experience in this part of Long Island and it was suggested to me by a random person to visit this place to see Jonathan and I must say that he did not disappoint. The experience he gave was not only above and beyond but unexpected. This is my new favorite place as a new resident of Suffolk county. Thanks Jonathan!
We loved WhiskeyNeat. The food was delicious, ample and well-priced (special shout out to the Caesar Salad, hah), the service was very friendly and fast and the overall vibe was great. Music choices mostly good. Will absolutely return.
We were there on a Tuesday afternoon. Happy Hour the bartender was so nice. We had two apps. Wings and duck tacos they were delish. We will be back menu looked great.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
The dinner would have been delicious but the skirt stayed came out cold. There were 2 large parties and it appeared that the weight staff could not handle it. We were still in the middle of our appetizers when our entrees came out and again the food was cold. Too much balsamic on burrata salad and grilled octopus. There was also a seating issue so the manager bought us short rib croquet (those were good) but an overall feeling of being rushed out. Our main server was very sweet. Not sure I will return.
The dinner would have been delicious but the skirt stayed came out cold. There were 2 large parties and it appeared that the weight staff could not handle it. We were still in the middle of our appetizers when our entrees came out and again the food was cold. Too much balsamic on burrata salad and grilled octopus. There was also a seating issue so the manager bought us short rib croquet (those were good) but an overall feeling of being rushed out. Our main server was very sweet. Not sure I will return.
Great food and not too busy at lunch. Very
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Sania and her raspberry espresso martinis are dynamite. A must try!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My experience a few Sundays ago at Whiskey Neat was a touchdown, and it had nothing to do with the game on the screens. Let me tell you, the real MVPs of the night were the bartenders, Sonia and her partner (whose name I shamefully forgot, apologies!). These two were a dynamite duo, pumping out high-energy vibes and contagious smiles.From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with genuine warmth and playful banter. The guy whipped up espresso martinis, while Sonia kept the conversation flowing like a seamless handoff. Their chemistry was infectious, their enthusiasm bubbling over with each pour and witty remark. They weren't just serving drinks; they were crafting an experience, one that made us feel like regulars even on our first visit.I can't remember the final score of the game (and honestly, who cares?), but I vividly recall the laughter echoing through the bar, Sonia and her partner were right there with us, riding the emotional rollercoaster of the game, adding their own brand of commentary and keeping the spirits high.By the end of the night, we weren't just leaving a bar; we were leaving a party. We felt like we'd made new friends, all thanks to the magic of the two of them. They turned a casual Sunday night into something truly special, proving that sometimes, the best entertainment comes not from the escreen, but from the people behind the bar.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
We had no idea what to expect and I have never heard of the restaurant but apparently we were the last to know. Place was packed and continued to be busy throughout the night. Food and service were excellent. We will definitely go back
Excellent food and amazing staff! If you haven’t been here you are missing out. I’m obsessed with their brunch, their drinks and their excellent menu! Fair prices and I’m never disappointed. Don’t forget to check out their happy hour it’s awesome! If you don’t know where to start get the fingerling potatoes and bees knees!!!Vegetarian options: There are many great options. Deviled eggs, potatoes dishes, man and cheese etc and all delicious.Parking: There are lots of paid and unpaid spots available behind whiskey neat.Kid-friendliness: No kids menu but kids are more than welcome and the staff has always been super nice and accommodating to my 3 kids, which I appreciate.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Crispy Short Rib Croquettes, Hot Honey Chicken, Hand Cut Fries App, Deviled Eggs
Best spot in town for food and drinks. Has a great late night vibe too, a nice alternative to the over crowded/super young spots. Highly recommend!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food and cocktails, friendly staff. Will definitely be
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bartenders were super friendly and the food was obviously fresh. The drink menu was fun and had options for everyone in our party. We had the hummus, pastrami sandwich, and the chicken sandwich. All 3 were amazing and we left very happy and satisfied. We will definitely be back!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Buttermilk Fried Chicken Sandwich, Pastrami Sandwich