Benny’s Brown Bag

Name: Benny’s Brown Bag
Address: 1100 Elm St, Peekskill, New York, 10566, US
Telephone: (914) 600-8848
Price range: $
Rating: 4.9

$ • Sandwich Shops

Hours:
1100 Elm St, Peekskill
(914) 600-8848

About Benny’s Brown Bag

Benny's Brown Bag, nestled in Westchester County, is a hidden gem serving up unique and fresh sandwiches. The restaurant offers a variety of signature sandwiches, permanent menu items, seasonal specials, and daily/weekly limited items. With slightly higher prices than standard sandwich fare, the taste and quality make it worthwhile. The atmosphere is kid-friendly, with vintage skate videos and punk music playing in the background. The chili crisp turkey sandwich is a must-try, featuring fresh tender turkey between crispy, lightly toasted bread, seasoned with chili crisp mayo, pickled onions, and arugula. It's a complimenting combo of sweet and savory with just the right amount of heat. The bacon grilled cheese and mac salad are also highlights, with the latter being ample for two sides. While there is no seating, the place is fun to explore with its selection of chips, beers, and soft drinks. The staff is super friendly, and there's a school park across the street with picnic benches. Benny's Brown Bag is a Foodie Sandwich destination spot.