The BBQ Shack
$ • Barbeque, Donuts
Hours:
2447 NY-54A, Penn Yan
(315) 531-8700
About The BBQ Shack
Customers' Favorites
The BBQ Shack Reviews
Share your opinion about The BBQ Shack
I just never thought their food was good. Sure it’s okay but you don’t get that good quality for the price.. plus the customer service is bland and dry. I don’t know just not my kinda place.
If you don’t get the triple b burger you are missing out! Their food is absolutely amazing and I’ve never had a bad meal. We stumbled upon the triple b burger over the summer and now every time we go we order 3! For me and my fiancé to share. It’s delicious and filling. A must have on the menu! I’ve had bbq in a lot of places but the bbq shack has the best ever. So glad it’s local to us.
So amazing!! Pulled pork is fantastic but my fav thing is the BBQ fries! And the Mac and Chz so freakin good!!
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 7PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 7PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 7PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 7PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 7PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 7PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
People in Penn Yan Also Viewed
The BBQ Shack is a popular local restaurant known for its delicious and satisfying barbecue dishes. The menu features standout items like the Triple B burger, which many consider a must-try; it is described as delicious and filling, often ordered multiple times by customers. The barbecue itself is highly praised, with many reviews calling it the best they have ever had. The pulled pork, in particular, is tender and melts in the mouth, with some customers noting that the pulled chicken can be a bit dry but is easily improved with extra sauce. Ribs are also highly recommended, described as fall-off-the-bone and with great bark.
Sides such as french fries fried with beef tallow and coleslaw are appreciated for their quality. The french fries are considered probably the best ever, while the sides like mac n cheese and salt potatoes are generally good, though some find the mac n cheese a bit peppery or similar to scalloped potatoes. The sampler platter offers a variety of options, including macaroni salad, salt potatoes, chicken wing dip, and mac n cheese, providing a good overall meal.
Though the building is understated and interior ambiance could be improved with music or a more inviting atmosphere, the staff and ownership are friendly and attentive. The restaurant offers generous portions at affordable prices, making it a favorite for those seeking tasty, hearty barbecue with lots of food to share.