Fireside Caterer

513 Old Country Rd #4903, Plainview
(516) 433-4000

Recent Reviews

Patrick Fagan

All around great place for meals.??

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gardy Belizaire

Good food, great customer service. My go to spot for lunch during work. They offer all types of hot and cold foods, drinks and snacks.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cary Weinstein

Great food. Excellent fast friendly service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: BBQ Chicken, Chicken & Ribs, Meatball Parmigiana

Humberto Diaz

Ordered lunch for our office. Everyone liked the sandwiches. Nice staff. We would order again. Highly recommend. NY typical deli sandwiches. Awesome!!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jamie Bostrom

Outstanding egg sandwiches!

Lara Arcas

Love that their food us always delicious. We always get their potatoes and Mac and cheese.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

ste ve

Three different employees on three different occasions that were making my sandwichs used the same gloves that they were using on a dirty rag wiping counters. That's absolutely disgusting and three strikes you're out. Sorry done with this place.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Frederick Pascalli

Very good food always fresh nice employers very nice love it

Dennis Cravak

They're blue cheese tastes like dumpster juice! But I'm from Buffalo so I'm spoiled! The wings were actually comparable to wings in buffalo! Just need a few more mins they were a lil soggy but good!

Bob S.

We would get takeout from Fireside on many a Friday night when I was growing up in Plainview in the '60s, '70s, and '80s. We would usually get chicken and ribs, and I loved it. I'd like to go back to enjoy it again some day.

Joey Jennewein

The people they have working in the morning are just very rude and impatient. If they do not want to work or deal with people then they should stay home or find a new job.I highly recommend people to come here for lunch or dinner not breakfast.

Eddie Serrano

Terrible employees here. Came to order breakfast with a co worker. The lady making the breakfast sandwich kept going over the price of the sandwich we ordered like if we where asking. She was very unpleasant from the moment we walked in, the looks she would give us and kept saying it would cost an extra $2.00 to make an omelette instead of a fried egg. Just to beat eggs will cost more (Lol) The cashier was not friendly and looked disgusted like she didn’t even wanted to interact. I will never come to this place again. Just the vibe of these people that work here. We came on 8/7/23 around 9:30am. I will stay away from this place not a good experience. You want to have a successful business treat everyone customer with dignity because of us customers that is what keeps your business running.

Joseph Figueroa

Very rude staff, egg sandwiches were made very sloppy and soggy. eggs were undercooked and runny, would not recommend. Only came here because my favorite deli is temporarily closed. Never again!

Aaron F.

It's a sub par deli. Nothing to see here unless you're in a rush and really need something quickly.

Andy

Not bad big place . Went on a Sunday early morning so no food was out need to go back

Load More