Fireside Caterer

$ • Deli, Vegan

Hours today·

About Fireside Caterer

Fireside Caterer is a long-standing restaurant that has been serving the Plainview community for several decades. They are known for their delicious chicken and ribs, which have been enjoyed by customers for generations. The restaurant's wings are said to be comparable to those in Buffalo, although they may need a bit more time on the grill to prevent sogginess. The breakfast sandwich is described as "okay," and it is available fried by default or cooked differently upon request. Customers say the egg sandwich is good, and the coffee is decent too.

On special occasions, such as Mother's Day, Fireside Caterer has received high praise for their flavorful ribs, chicken, stuffing, spinach, and sweet potatoes. Customers have described their meals as "amazing" and "delicious," and have highly recommended the restaurant for this type of food.

The restaurant has been a local favorite for nearly 30 years, with customers praising the fresh and outstanding quality of the food, particularly the chicken cutlet Parmesan hero, which is considered the best in the area. Reviewers note that the chicken parm hero is tasty but can be too saucy, and the Captain hook hero and chicken caesar wrap are good. The prices are pretty decent compared to other bagel places and delis. The staff is friendly and inviting, and the counter service keeps the line moving quickly. Despite the slightly tight and disjointed parking, the ample space and variety of menu options make Fireside Caterer a welcoming and convenient dining destination.

Menu

Add a Menu
Fireside Caterer Menu
Fireside Caterer Menu

Customers' Favorites

Photos

Add a Photo
Fireside Caterer
Fireside Caterer
View All Photos

Fireside Caterer Reviews

3.8
153 ratings
5
59%
4
8%
3
5%
2
5%
1
23%
Food
4.1
Atmosphere
3.6
Service
3.6

Share your opinion about Fireside Caterer

I always find myself going here whenever im near...nothing to fear..try some beer
Have come here twice now. Place is clean, organized, tons of options and all the staff are very friendly. There’s a nice guy named Matt who patiently walked me through all their options, and struck some good conversation. Hospitality each time has been 10/10, food is good for the price and portion. No complaints so far. I’ll be coming back here regularly when I want a great sandwich or dinner meal.
Always Great!!! Staff is Great!!! Food Great!!

Read All Reviews(153)

Hours

Monday 8AM - 6:30PM
Tuesday 8AM - 6:30PM
Wednesday 8AM - 6:30PM
Thursday 8AM - 6:30PM
Friday 8AM - 6:30PM
Saturday 8AM - 6:30PM
Sunday 8AM - 6:30PM
Updated on: