Fireside Caterer
513 Old Country Rd #4903, Plainview
(516) 433-4000
Customers' Favorites
Meatball Parmigiana
Roast Beef Sandwich
Chicken Ceasar Wrap
Meatloaf and Sides
Chicken & Ribs
BBQ Chicken
Menu
Photos
+9 photos
+8 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Prices are honestly pretty decent compared to many other bagel places / delis. Staff was super nice and inviting to me and my 4 year old. Michelle is a sweetheart and Bob makes a good egg sandwich! Will deff be back. Coffee is decent too!! Soup made me feel better. I live up the road and never been here. Thank you guys!!!
Chicken parm hero is too saucy and could use a little more meat. Decent flavor. Mac and cheese just ok. Just salt and pepper flavoring.
Chicken club panini is just ok. Grilled chicken was bland. Good amount for $12. Would eat again though. Chocolate cake is good. More like a fudge cake. It's $4.
Captain hook hero is tasty. Chicken ceasar wrap is good. Overall a good lunch spot 👍.
Chicken club panini is just ok. Grilled chicken was bland. Good amount for $12. Would eat again though. Chocolate cake is good. More like a fudge cake. It's $4.
Captain hook hero is tasty. Chicken ceasar wrap is good. Overall a good lunch spot 👍.
Since 1996 I have been coming here to Fireside Caterers, and the food here is simply outstanding! Everything is fresh and wonderful, but their chicken cutlet Parmesan hero is probably the best I ever had, anywhere. Fresh cutlets and homemade sauce, on soft hero rolls, this really is the standard that your local deli or pizza joint should be holding itself up to. Counter service is ok 9/10, the tall woman doing checkout is very fast and keeps it moving, but not very friendly—...
You May Also Like
Burger King - 501 Old Country Rd
![]()
Burgers, Fast Food
Taco Bell - 638 S Oyster Bay Rd
![]()
Fast Food, Mexican
Hicksville Diner - 495 E Old Country Rd
![]()
Diner, American